# WhichScent > What YouTube reviewers say about each version of a fragrance: which one they pick, what they praise and criticise, and where they disagree. Every line links to the moment it was said. Counts are of named YouTube reviewers, out of those who compared each version. They are not ratings. Every claim on a guide page links to the timestamp where it was said. ## Version guides - [Dior Sauvage EDT vs EDP vs Parfum vs Elixir: which to buy](https://whichscent.com/dior-sauvage): Of 10 reviewers, 3 of the 7 who compared the Elixir pick it; 2 of 9 pick the EDP, 2 of 10 pick the EDT, 2 of 10 pick the Parfum. - [Bleu de Chanel EDT vs EDP vs Parfum: which to buy](https://whichscent.com/bleu-de-chanel): Of 8 reviewers, 6 of the 8 who compared the EDP pick it; 1 of 8 pick the EDT, 1 of 8 pick the Parfum. - [YSL Y EDT vs EDP vs Le Parfum vs Elixir: which to buy](https://whichscent.com/ysl-y): Of 8 reviewers, 5 of the 8 who compared the EDP pick it; 1 of 7 pick the EDT, 1 of 7 pick the Le Parfum. - [Armani Stronger With You Original vs Intensely vs Absolutely: which to buy](https://whichscent.com/stronger-with-you): Of 8 reviewers, 6 of the 8 who compared the Absolutely pick it; 1 of 8 pick the Intensely. - [Versace Eros EDT vs EDP vs Parfum: which to buy](https://whichscent.com/versace-eros): Of 8 reviewers, 3 of the 8 who compared the EDP pick it; 2 of 6 pick the Parfum, 1 of 8 pick the EDT. - [Parfums de Marly Layton vs Layton Exclusif: which to buy](https://whichscent.com/layton): Of 8 reviewers, 4 of the 8 who compared the Layton pick it; 2 of 8 pick the Layton Exclusif. - [Baccarat Rouge 540 EDP vs Extrait: which to buy](https://whichscent.com/baccarat-rouge-540): Of 8 reviewers, 3 of the 8 who compared the Extrait pick it; 2 of 8 pick the EDP. - [Club de Nuit Intense Man EDT vs EDP vs Parfum vs Limited Edition: which to buy](https://whichscent.com/club-de-nuit-intense-man): Of 8 reviewers, 4 of the 8 who compared the EDP pick it; 2 of 5 pick the Limited Edition, 2 of 6 pick the Parfum. - [Acqua di Gio EDT vs EDP vs Profondo vs Parfum: which to buy](https://whichscent.com/acqua-di-gio): Of 8 reviewers, 2 of the 3 who compared the Parfum pick it; 2 of 6 pick the EDT, 2 of 8 pick the Profondo, 1 of 4 pick the EDP. - [Jean Paul Gaultier Le Male EDT vs Le Parfum vs Elixir: which to buy](https://whichscent.com/le-male): Of 9 reviewers, 6 of the 9 who compared the Le Parfum pick it; 1 of 9 pick the Elixir. - [Paco Rabanne 1 Million EDT vs Parfum vs Elixir vs Royal: which to buy](https://whichscent.com/one-million): Of 8 reviewers, 2 of the 5 who compared the Royal pick it; 2 of 6 pick the Parfum, 2 of 8 pick the EDT. - [Paco Rabanne Invictus EDT vs Victory vs Platinum vs Victory Elixir: which to buy](https://whichscent.com/invictus): Of 7 reviewers, 5 of the 6 who compared the Victory Elixir pick it; 1 of 3 pick the EDT. - [Viktor&Rolf Spicebomb Original vs Extreme vs Infrared vs Night Vision: which to buy](https://whichscent.com/spicebomb): Of 8 reviewers, 4 of the 8 who compared the Extreme pick it; 2 of 6 pick the Infrared, 1 of 6 pick the Original, 1 of 8 pick the Night Vision. - [Dior Homme EDT vs Intense vs Parfum: which to buy](https://whichscent.com/dior-homme): Of 8 reviewers, 3 of the 8 who compared the Intense pick it; 2 of 7 pick the Parfum, 1 of 4 pick the EDT. - [Terre d'Hermès EDT vs Parfum vs Eau Intense Vétiver: which to buy](https://whichscent.com/terre-dhermes): Of 8 reviewers, 4 of the 7 who compared the EDT pick it; 3 of 7 pick the Eau Intense Vétiver, 1 of 6 pick the Parfum. - [Boss Bottled EDT vs EDP vs Elixir: which to buy](https://whichscent.com/boss-bottled): Of 7 reviewers, 2 of the 2 who compared the Elixir pick it; 2 of 5 pick the EDT, 1 of 3 pick the EDP. - [Armani Code EDT vs EDP vs Parfum: which to buy](https://whichscent.com/armani-code): Of 8 reviewers, 3 of the 7 who compared the EDP pick it; 3 of 8 pick the Parfum. - [Montblanc Explorer EDP vs Platinum vs Extreme: which to buy](https://whichscent.com/montblanc-explorer): Of 8 reviewers, 3 of the 4 who compared the Extreme pick it; 2 of 8 pick the EDP, 1 of 6 pick the Platinum. - [Valentino Uomo Born in Roma EDT vs Intense vs Coral Fantasy vs Extradose: which to buy](https://whichscent.com/born-in-roma): Of 8 reviewers, 3 of the 6 who compared the Intense pick it; 2 of 5 pick the EDT, 2 of 5 pick the Coral Fantasy. - [YSL Libre EDT vs EDP vs Intense vs Le Parfum: which to buy](https://whichscent.com/ysl-libre): Of 8 reviewers, 2 of the 7 who compared the EDP pick it; 2 of 7 pick the Intense, 1 of 4 pick the EDT, 1 of 6 pick the Le Parfum. - [Chanel Coco Mademoiselle EDT vs EDP vs Intense: which to buy](https://whichscent.com/coco-mademoiselle): Of 8 reviewers, 3 of the 7 who compared the EDP pick it; 2 of 8 pick the Intense. - [YSL Black Opium EDP vs Le Parfum vs Over Red vs Extreme: which to buy](https://whichscent.com/black-opium): Of 8 reviewers, 3 of the 4 who compared the Over Red pick it; 3 of 7 pick the Le Parfum, 1 of 4 pick the Extreme, 1 of 6 pick the EDP. - [Parfums de Marly Delina vs Delina Exclusif vs Delina La Rosée: which to buy](https://whichscent.com/delina): Of 8 reviewers, 3 of the 7 who compared the Delina La Rosée pick it; 3 of 8 pick the Delina, 2 of 7 pick the Delina Exclusif. - [Carolina Herrera Good Girl EDP vs Suprême vs Blush: which to buy](https://whichscent.com/good-girl): Of 8 reviewers, 2 of the 3 who compared the Suprême pick it; 3 of 8 pick the EDP, 2 of 6 pick the Blush. - [Lancôme La Vie Est Belle EDP vs Intensément vs L'Elixir: which to buy](https://whichscent.com/la-vie-est-belle): Of 8 reviewers, 3 of the 3 who compared the L'Elixir pick it; 3 of 5 pick the Intensément, 2 of 5 pick the EDP. ## Head-to-head pages - [Dior Sauvage EDT vs EDP](https://whichscent.com/dior-sauvage/edt-vs-edp) - [Dior Sauvage EDT vs Parfum](https://whichscent.com/dior-sauvage/edt-vs-parfum) - [Dior Sauvage EDT vs Elixir](https://whichscent.com/dior-sauvage/edt-vs-elixir) - [Dior Sauvage EDP vs Parfum](https://whichscent.com/dior-sauvage/edp-vs-parfum) - [Dior Sauvage EDP vs Elixir](https://whichscent.com/dior-sauvage/edp-vs-elixir) - [Dior Sauvage Parfum vs Elixir](https://whichscent.com/dior-sauvage/parfum-vs-elixir) - [Bleu de Chanel EDT vs EDP](https://whichscent.com/bleu-de-chanel/edt-vs-edp) - [Bleu de Chanel EDT vs Parfum](https://whichscent.com/bleu-de-chanel/edt-vs-parfum) - [Bleu de Chanel EDP vs Parfum](https://whichscent.com/bleu-de-chanel/edp-vs-parfum) - [YSL Y EDT vs EDP](https://whichscent.com/ysl-y/edt-vs-edp) - [YSL Y EDT vs Le Parfum](https://whichscent.com/ysl-y/edt-vs-le-parfum) - [YSL Y EDT vs Elixir](https://whichscent.com/ysl-y/edt-vs-elixir) - [YSL Y EDP vs Le Parfum](https://whichscent.com/ysl-y/edp-vs-le-parfum) - [YSL Y EDP vs Elixir](https://whichscent.com/ysl-y/edp-vs-elixir) - [YSL Y Le Parfum vs Elixir](https://whichscent.com/ysl-y/le-parfum-vs-elixir) - [Armani Stronger With You Original vs Intensely](https://whichscent.com/stronger-with-you/original-vs-intensely) - [Armani Stronger With You Original vs Absolutely](https://whichscent.com/stronger-with-you/original-vs-absolutely) - [Armani Stronger With You Intensely vs Absolutely](https://whichscent.com/stronger-with-you/intensely-vs-absolutely) - [Versace Eros EDT vs EDP](https://whichscent.com/versace-eros/edt-vs-edp) - [Versace Eros EDT vs Parfum](https://whichscent.com/versace-eros/edt-vs-parfum) - [Versace Eros EDP vs Parfum](https://whichscent.com/versace-eros/edp-vs-parfum) - [Parfums de Marly Layton Layton vs Layton Exclusif](https://whichscent.com/layton/layton-vs-layton-exclusif) - [Baccarat Rouge 540 EDP vs Extrait](https://whichscent.com/baccarat-rouge-540/edp-vs-extrait) - [Club de Nuit Intense Man EDT vs EDP](https://whichscent.com/club-de-nuit-intense-man/edt-vs-edp) - [Club de Nuit Intense Man EDT vs Parfum](https://whichscent.com/club-de-nuit-intense-man/edt-vs-parfum) - [Club de Nuit Intense Man EDT vs Limited Edition](https://whichscent.com/club-de-nuit-intense-man/edt-vs-limited-edition) - [Club de Nuit Intense Man EDP vs Parfum](https://whichscent.com/club-de-nuit-intense-man/edp-vs-parfum) - [Club de Nuit Intense Man EDP vs Limited Edition](https://whichscent.com/club-de-nuit-intense-man/edp-vs-limited-edition) - [Club de Nuit Intense Man Parfum vs Limited Edition](https://whichscent.com/club-de-nuit-intense-man/parfum-vs-limited-edition) - [Acqua di Gio EDT vs EDP](https://whichscent.com/acqua-di-gio/edt-vs-edp) - [Acqua di Gio EDT vs Profondo](https://whichscent.com/acqua-di-gio/edt-vs-profondo) - [Acqua di Gio EDT vs Parfum](https://whichscent.com/acqua-di-gio/edt-vs-parfum) - [Acqua di Gio EDP vs Profondo](https://whichscent.com/acqua-di-gio/edp-vs-profondo) - [Acqua di Gio EDP vs Parfum](https://whichscent.com/acqua-di-gio/edp-vs-parfum) - [Acqua di Gio Profondo vs Parfum](https://whichscent.com/acqua-di-gio/profondo-vs-parfum) - [Jean Paul Gaultier Le Male EDT vs Le Parfum](https://whichscent.com/le-male/edt-vs-le-parfum) - [Jean Paul Gaultier Le Male EDT vs Elixir](https://whichscent.com/le-male/edt-vs-elixir) - [Jean Paul Gaultier Le Male Le Parfum vs Elixir](https://whichscent.com/le-male/le-parfum-vs-elixir) - [Paco Rabanne 1 Million EDT vs Parfum](https://whichscent.com/one-million/edt-vs-parfum) - [Paco Rabanne 1 Million EDT vs Elixir](https://whichscent.com/one-million/edt-vs-elixir) - [Paco Rabanne 1 Million EDT vs Royal](https://whichscent.com/one-million/edt-vs-royal) - [Paco Rabanne 1 Million Parfum vs Elixir](https://whichscent.com/one-million/parfum-vs-elixir) - [Paco Rabanne 1 Million Parfum vs Royal](https://whichscent.com/one-million/parfum-vs-royal) - [Paco Rabanne 1 Million Elixir vs Royal](https://whichscent.com/one-million/elixir-vs-royal) - [Paco Rabanne Invictus EDT vs Victory](https://whichscent.com/invictus/edt-vs-victory) - [Paco Rabanne Invictus EDT vs Platinum](https://whichscent.com/invictus/edt-vs-platinum) - [Paco Rabanne Invictus EDT vs Victory Elixir](https://whichscent.com/invictus/edt-vs-victory-elixir) - [Paco Rabanne Invictus Victory vs Platinum](https://whichscent.com/invictus/victory-vs-platinum) - [Paco Rabanne Invictus Victory vs Victory Elixir](https://whichscent.com/invictus/victory-vs-victory-elixir) - [Paco Rabanne Invictus Platinum vs Victory Elixir](https://whichscent.com/invictus/platinum-vs-victory-elixir) - [Viktor&Rolf Spicebomb Original vs Extreme](https://whichscent.com/spicebomb/original-vs-extreme) - [Viktor&Rolf Spicebomb Original vs Infrared](https://whichscent.com/spicebomb/original-vs-infrared) - [Viktor&Rolf Spicebomb Original vs Night Vision](https://whichscent.com/spicebomb/original-vs-night-vision) - [Viktor&Rolf Spicebomb Extreme vs Infrared](https://whichscent.com/spicebomb/extreme-vs-infrared) - [Viktor&Rolf Spicebomb Extreme vs Night Vision](https://whichscent.com/spicebomb/extreme-vs-night-vision) - [Viktor&Rolf Spicebomb Infrared vs Night Vision](https://whichscent.com/spicebomb/infrared-vs-night-vision) - [Dior Homme EDT vs Intense](https://whichscent.com/dior-homme/edt-vs-intense) - [Dior Homme EDT vs Parfum](https://whichscent.com/dior-homme/edt-vs-parfum) - [Dior Homme Intense vs Parfum](https://whichscent.com/dior-homme/intense-vs-parfum) - [Terre d'Hermès EDT vs Parfum](https://whichscent.com/terre-dhermes/edt-vs-parfum) - [Terre d'Hermès EDT vs Eau Intense Vétiver](https://whichscent.com/terre-dhermes/edt-vs-eau-intense-ve-tiver) - [Terre d'Hermès Parfum vs Eau Intense Vétiver](https://whichscent.com/terre-dhermes/parfum-vs-eau-intense-ve-tiver) - [Boss Bottled EDT vs EDP](https://whichscent.com/boss-bottled/edt-vs-edp) - [Boss Bottled EDT vs Elixir](https://whichscent.com/boss-bottled/edt-vs-elixir) - [Boss Bottled EDP vs Elixir](https://whichscent.com/boss-bottled/edp-vs-elixir) - [Armani Code EDT vs EDP](https://whichscent.com/armani-code/edt-vs-edp) - [Armani Code EDT vs Parfum](https://whichscent.com/armani-code/edt-vs-parfum) - [Armani Code EDP vs Parfum](https://whichscent.com/armani-code/edp-vs-parfum) - [Montblanc Explorer EDP vs Platinum](https://whichscent.com/montblanc-explorer/edp-vs-platinum) - [Montblanc Explorer EDP vs Extreme](https://whichscent.com/montblanc-explorer/edp-vs-extreme) - [Montblanc Explorer Platinum vs Extreme](https://whichscent.com/montblanc-explorer/platinum-vs-extreme) - [Valentino Uomo Born in Roma EDT vs Intense](https://whichscent.com/born-in-roma/edt-vs-intense) - [Valentino Uomo Born in Roma EDT vs Coral Fantasy](https://whichscent.com/born-in-roma/edt-vs-coral-fantasy) - [Valentino Uomo Born in Roma EDT vs Extradose](https://whichscent.com/born-in-roma/edt-vs-extradose) - [Valentino Uomo Born in Roma Intense vs Coral Fantasy](https://whichscent.com/born-in-roma/intense-vs-coral-fantasy) - [Valentino Uomo Born in Roma Intense vs Extradose](https://whichscent.com/born-in-roma/intense-vs-extradose) - [Valentino Uomo Born in Roma Coral Fantasy vs Extradose](https://whichscent.com/born-in-roma/coral-fantasy-vs-extradose) - [YSL Libre EDT vs EDP](https://whichscent.com/ysl-libre/edt-vs-edp) - [YSL Libre EDT vs Intense](https://whichscent.com/ysl-libre/edt-vs-intense) - [YSL Libre EDT vs Le Parfum](https://whichscent.com/ysl-libre/edt-vs-le-parfum) - [YSL Libre EDP vs Intense](https://whichscent.com/ysl-libre/edp-vs-intense) - [YSL Libre EDP vs Le Parfum](https://whichscent.com/ysl-libre/edp-vs-le-parfum) - [YSL Libre Intense vs Le Parfum](https://whichscent.com/ysl-libre/intense-vs-le-parfum) - [Chanel Coco Mademoiselle EDT vs EDP](https://whichscent.com/coco-mademoiselle/edt-vs-edp) - [Chanel Coco Mademoiselle EDT vs Intense](https://whichscent.com/coco-mademoiselle/edt-vs-intense) - [Chanel Coco Mademoiselle EDP vs Intense](https://whichscent.com/coco-mademoiselle/edp-vs-intense) - [YSL Black Opium EDP vs Le Parfum](https://whichscent.com/black-opium/edp-vs-le-parfum) - [YSL Black Opium EDP vs Over Red](https://whichscent.com/black-opium/edp-vs-over-red) - [YSL Black Opium EDP vs Extreme](https://whichscent.com/black-opium/edp-vs-extreme) - [YSL Black Opium Le Parfum vs Over Red](https://whichscent.com/black-opium/le-parfum-vs-over-red) - [YSL Black Opium Le Parfum vs Extreme](https://whichscent.com/black-opium/le-parfum-vs-extreme) - [YSL Black Opium Over Red vs Extreme](https://whichscent.com/black-opium/over-red-vs-extreme) - [Parfums de Marly Delina Delina vs Delina Exclusif](https://whichscent.com/delina/delina-vs-delina-exclusif) - [Parfums de Marly Delina Delina vs Delina La Rosée](https://whichscent.com/delina/delina-vs-delina-la-rose-e) - [Parfums de Marly Delina Delina Exclusif vs Delina La Rosée](https://whichscent.com/delina/delina-exclusif-vs-delina-la-rose-e) - [Carolina Herrera Good Girl EDP vs Suprême](https://whichscent.com/good-girl/edp-vs-supre-me) - [Carolina Herrera Good Girl EDP vs Blush](https://whichscent.com/good-girl/edp-vs-blush) - [Carolina Herrera Good Girl Suprême vs Blush](https://whichscent.com/good-girl/supre-me-vs-blush) - [Lancôme La Vie Est Belle EDP vs Intensément](https://whichscent.com/la-vie-est-belle/edp-vs-intense-ment) - [Lancôme La Vie Est Belle EDP vs L'Elixir](https://whichscent.com/la-vie-est-belle/edp-vs-l-elixir) - [Lancôme La Vie Est Belle Intensément vs L'Elixir](https://whichscent.com/la-vie-est-belle/intense-ment-vs-l-elixir) ## Lists - [Longest-lasting fragrance versions](https://whichscent.com/best/longest-lasting): The versions whose longevity reviewers praise most consistently. - [Fragrance versions that project the most](https://whichscent.com/best/strongest-projection): The versions reviewers say carry furthest. - [Best-value fragrance versions](https://whichscent.com/best/best-value): The versions reviewers most often call worth the money. - [Most complimented fragrance versions](https://whichscent.com/best/most-complimented): The versions reviewers say get noticed and complimented. - [Safest fragrances to buy without smelling](https://whichscent.com/best/safe-blind-buys): Versions almost no reviewer criticises on scent. - [Fragrance versions for summer](https://whichscent.com/best/for-summer): Versions reviewers say suit summer, ordered by how many pick them. - [Fragrance versions for winter](https://whichscent.com/best/for-winter): Versions reviewers say suit winter, ordered by how many pick them. - [Fragrance versions for spring](https://whichscent.com/best/for-spring): Versions reviewers say suit spring, ordered by how many pick them. - [Fragrance versions for fall](https://whichscent.com/best/for-fall): Versions reviewers say suit fall, ordered by how many pick them. - [Fragrance versions for the office](https://whichscent.com/best/for-office): Versions reviewers say suit office, ordered by how many pick them. - [Fragrance versions for a date night](https://whichscent.com/best/for-date-night): Versions reviewers say suit date night, ordered by how many pick them. - [Fragrance versions for everyday wear](https://whichscent.com/best/for-everyday): Versions reviewers say suit everyday wear, ordered by how many pick them. - [Fragrance versions for a night out](https://whichscent.com/best/for-night-out): Versions reviewers say suit night out, ordered by how many pick them. - [Fragrance versions for formal occasions](https://whichscent.com/best/for-formal): Versions reviewers say suit formal, ordered by how many pick them. - [Fragrance versions for the gym](https://whichscent.com/best/for-gym): Versions reviewers say suit gym, ordered by how many pick them. ## About - [Reviewers and what they pick](https://whichscent.com/reviewers) - [How the guides are made](https://whichscent.com/method) - [About](https://whichscent.com/about)