Baccarat Rouge 540: EDP or Extrait?

Of the 8 reviewers who compared both, 2 pick the EDP and 3 pick the Extrait; 3 prefer another version or name none.

Baccarat Rouge 540 Eau de Parfum

Baccarat Rouge 540 Eau de Parfum

Lighter, airy, sugary version that reviewers call easy to wear and often complimented, though some find it thin, medicinal or inconsistent on skin.

2 of 8 reviewers who compared it pick this version.

springsummerdaynighteveryday

Reviewers smell: saffron, sweet, airy, ambroxan, cotton candy, ambergris, cedar wood, jasmine

Picked by Erin Nicole TV, The Scented

Baccarat Rouge 540 Extrait

Baccarat Rouge 540 Extrait

Richer, denser, woodier version with almond and musk notes and longer staying power, though it costs more and some find it heavy.

3 of 8 reviewers who compared it pick this version.

fallwinternightdate nightnight outformal

Reviewers smell: saffron, jasmine, sweet, almond, bitter almond, woody, cedar wood, creamy

Picked by The Perfume Guy, Fashion and Fitness Over 40, Lavishly Chi Chi

How they compare

What reviewers sayEDPExtrait
scentMostly praised7 praise, 2 criticiseMostly praised8 praise
longevityMixed7 praise, 3 criticiseMostly praised8 praise
projectionMixed1 praise, 1 criticiseMostly praised7 praise
occasionMixed5 praise, 2 criticiseMixed3 praise, 4 criticise
valueMostly praised3 praiseMixed3 praise, 3 criticise
complimentsMostly praised2 praiseMostly praised2 praise

overall

EDP

Erin Nicole TVReviewed in 2021Mixed

Becoming so popular it risks feeling cliche, though she says it is not there yet.

“it's just too popular maybe cliche i don't think it's there yet”
Watch at 12:33
The Santa MariaReviewed in 2022Praise

She loved it the first time she smelled it.

“this is the type of scent that this was a love at first sniff”
Watch at 6:31
The Perfume GuyReviewed in 2020Mixed

Did not like it at first sniff, but grew to be obsessed with how it smells.

“it wasn't a love it for sniff but now I'm obsessed with the way it smells”
Watch at 1:11

Extrait

Erin Nicole TVReviewed in 2021Mixed

She likes it, but the woodier, more masculine character appeals to her less than the EDP. (for her personal taste)

“doesn't really speak to me the same way this one does”
Watch at 18:34
The Perfume GuyReviewed in 2020Praise

Highly recommended if you prefer stronger fragrances and can afford it. (if you prefer stronger fragrances and have the money)

“if you prefer stronger fragrances and you have the money I highly recommend this one”
Watch at 8:26
The ScentedReviewed in 2021Praise

Her current personal preference, for the almond cookie sweetness. (personal preference after owning the EDP for a long time)

“i'm leaning more towards the x-ray as my personal preference”
Watch at 14:44

scent

EDP

Erin Nicole TVReviewed in 2021Praise

Vanilla sugar note gives a cotton candy sweetness that is stronger here than in the Extrait. (if you love sugary sweetness)

“candy cotton candy sweetness you really get that in the edp”
Watch at 6:51
Erin Nicole TVReviewed in 2021Praise

Feels light, airy and luminous when compared side by side with the Extrait.

“it's not very heavy it's kind of light and there's an airiness to it”
Watch at 8:09
The Santa MariaReviewed in 2022Praise

Lighter, airier and more playful than the Extrait.

“the edp is more light and airy it's more whimsical it's more fun”
Watch at 14:35

Extrait

Erin Nicole TVReviewed in 2021Praise

The added woody accord is noticeable right away and adds depth.

“that woody accord really shines through you will pick up on it right away”
Watch at 3:44
Erin Nicole TVReviewed in 2021Praise

Has a spiciness that the EDP does not have.

“there's a spiciness in the x-ray that i don't get with the eau de parfum”
Watch at 4:52
Erin Nicole TVReviewed in 2021Praise

Smells very rich and clearly different from the EDP.

“it smells so so rich very different from the eau de parfum”
Watch at 8:28

longevity

EDP

Erin Nicole TVReviewed in 2021Praise

Lasts for days on clothing, hair and pillowcases. (in her personal experience)

“it lasts for days days on my clothing”
Watch at 9:43
The Santa MariaReviewed in 2022Praise

Lasts eight hours or more, though the wearer may stop noticing it.

“lasts eight hours a day plus sometimes eight hours plus depending on your circumstance”
Watch at 7:49
The Santa MariaReviewed in 2022Mixed

Clings to clothes better than it does to skin.

“the edp hooks clothes better than it hugs skin in my opinion”
Watch at 16:46

Extrait

Erin Nicole TVReviewed in 2021Praise

Lasts even longer than the already long-wearing EDP.

“it is impressively long wearing the extra parfum is even more so”
Watch at 16:20
The Santa MariaReviewed in 2022Praise

Extremely long lasting; she can still smell it on clothes after dry cleaning.

“i will dry clean something and still smell the extract”
Watch at 13:27
The Perfume GuyReviewed in 2020Praise

Lasts even longer than the EDP.

“especially if it's the xray version even longer it lasts and lasts”
Watch at 4:44

projection

EDP

The Santa MariaReviewed in 2022Mixed

Noticeable but not very strong; she rates strength seven out of ten. (on skin)

“it's not super duper strong yes you do smell it but it's not over the top”
Watch at 7:14
The Perfume GuyReviewed in 2020Mixed

Longevity is good but the wearing experience is thin.

“it does have great longevity but it's a thin longevity”
Watch at 6:06
The ScentedReviewed in 2021Mixed

Comes and goes for the wearer; others smell it even when she cannot.

“the odepak fum does play more of that peekaboo game”
Watch at 9:35

Extrait

Erin Nicole TVReviewed in 2021Praise

After eight to ten hours it is easier to smell on the arm than the EDP. (in her one-on-each-arm tests)

“the extra parfum is just a little bit more apparent i don't have to get my nose quite as close to my arm”
Watch at 16:33
The Santa MariaReviewed in 2022Praise

Slightly stronger than the EDP, eight out of ten, but not overpowering.

“is just a little bit stronger to me than the original”
Watch at 13:08
The Perfume GuyReviewed in 2020Praise

Higher oil concentration makes it stronger and longer lasting.

“it's a lot stronger here and that's why it lasts a lot longer”
Watch at 6:26

occasion

EDP

Erin Nicole TVReviewed in 2021Praise

Works for almost any occasion and in any season.

“perfect to wear for just about any occasion it's a seasonless fragrance”
Watch at 13:17
Erin Nicole TVReviewed in 2021Mixed

Can be strong depending on sprays, so it may not suit the office. (for office wear)

“it can be pretty strong depending on how much you spray so i'm not sure it is office appropriate”
Watch at 13:36
The Santa MariaReviewed in 2022Praise

She finds it best suited to spring and summer.

“i think it's more appropriate for the spring and the summer”
Watch at 14:57

Extrait

Erin Nicole TVReviewed in 2021Praise

Best kept for evenings, special occasions and date nights.

“i think this should be reserved for evening special occasions date nights”
Watch at 14:55
Erin Nicole TVReviewed in 2021Criticism

She would not feel as comfortable wearing it during the day. (for daytime wear)

“i would personally not feel as comfortable wearing this during the day”
Watch at 14:50
The Santa MariaReviewed in 2022Praise

Its thickness works better in colder weather, especially autumn and winter.

“me this is better in colder weather”
Watch at 15:26

value

EDP

Erin Nicole TVReviewed in 2021Mixed

Very expensive, but she has no regrets about buying it.

“no regrets even though it is very expensive”
Watch at 12:01
The Santa MariaReviewed in 2022Praise

The more affordable of the two, though still expensive.

“the edp is the more affordable one and of course the x-ray one is more expensive”
Watch at 15:59
The ScentedReviewed in 2021Praise

Slightly cheaper and gets more wear, so better value for money.

“get more bang for the buck it's cheaper it's just a little bit cheaper than the x-ray”
Watch at 15:12

Extrait

The Santa MariaReviewed in 2022Praise

The longevity justifies the price tag.

“with their price tag you are getting your money's worth”
Watch at 13:45
The Santa MariaReviewed in 2022Criticism

Costs noticeably more than the already expensive EDP.

“this is already expensive but yeah the x-ray costs even more”
Watch at 10:31
The Perfume GuyReviewed in 2020Criticism

Costs a lot more than the EDP.

“one is a lot more expensive than the other”
Watch at 3:06

compliments

EDP

Erin Nicole TVReviewed in 2021Praise

One of her most complimented fragrances; people ask what it is.

“it's also one of my most complimented fragrances”
Watch at 10:56
The Santa MariaReviewed in 2022Praise

Reliably turns heads and gets compliments.

“this is a certified head turning cinch”
Watch at 8:06

Extrait

The Santa MariaReviewed in 2022Praise

It was her most complimented fragrance of 2021.

“this was my number one most complimented scent of 2021”
Watch at 14:03
Lavishly Chi ChiReviewed in 2023Praise

Both versions get compliments, which she considers a selling point.

“They both get compliments and that's a selling point.”
Watch at 12:30

See every Baccarat Rouge 540 version