
The short answer
Of 8 reviewers, 2 of the 3 who compared the Suprême pick it; 3 of 8 pick the EDP, 2 of 6 pick the Blush.
Reviewers call the original EDP sweet, strong and mostly an evening scent, though one hears it as a soft spring daytime floral. Suprême is described as a softer, berry-sweet daytime take, and Blush as the lightest, most floral version, with some disagreement on day versus evening.
A count of what 8 reviewers said, not our rating. Counted on .
Carolina Herrera
Carolina Herrera Good Girl: EDP, Suprême or Blush?
Carolina Herrera Good Girl Suprême
Described as a softer, sweeter, candier daytime version of the original, with a juicy berry note up front.
Reviewers smell: almond, berries, berry, candy, creamy, cupcake, fruitier, jasmine
Picked by The Gossip Closet, SimplyShaughnessy
Choose it if you
- want the original's character but softer and less intense
- like a playful, berry-sweet scent for daytime
- want something that lasts about six to eight hours
Skip it if you
- dislike loud projection that people will notice
- expect it to match the listed notes
Where to buy
Also sold at MicroPerfumes, Scent Split, Sephora, Amazon.
The versions side by side
| What reviewers say | EDP | Suprême | Blush |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pick it | 3 of 8 reviewers | 2 of 3 reviewers | 2 of 6 reviewers |
| US price | $13.97 travel size | Not listed | $84 bottle |
| scent | Mixed 7 praise, 3 criticise | Mostly praised 3 praise | Mixed 4 praise, 2 criticise |
| longevity | Mostly praised 5 praise | Mostly praised 2 praise | Mostly praised 3 praise, 1 criticise |
| projection | Mixed 2 praise, 3 criticise | One comment 0 praise, 1 criticise | Mostly criticised 1 praise, 2 criticise |
| occasion | Mostly praised 5 praise | Mostly praised 2 praise | Mostly praised 4 praise |
| value | One comment 1 praise | No comment | No comment |
| compliments | Mixed 2 praise, 1 criticise | One comment 1 praise | No comment |
Head to head
What reviewers compare it to
Other fragrances reviewers bring up when they talk about Carolina Herrera Good Girl, most-mentioned first. A comparison is one reviewer's nose, not a claim that two fragrances are the same.
Yves Saint Laurent Black Opium
1 reviewer, smells like
“a little bit like black opium loads of white florals”
Soki London on the EDP. Watch at 3:16
Parfums de Marly Delina Exclusive
1 reviewer, cheaper alternative
“if you like Delina Exclusive by Mar and perhaps you're looking for a more affordable”
Jus de Rose on the Blush. Watch at 6:53
Dolce & Gabbana Light Blue Intense
1 reviewer, compared with
“if you like the dolce gabbana light blue intense”
Jeremy Fragrance on the EDP. Watch at 3:25
Chanel No. 5
1 reviewer, compared with
“Like a youthful version of the classic iconic Chanel number five.”
Emerald Sea on the EDP. Watch at 1:35
Where reviewers disagree
Reviewers mostly praise what they show, so the splits are the part worth reading before you buy.
EDP: scent
7 praise it
Soki LondonReviewed in 2025PraiseStrong white florals over sweet vanilla and warm tonka base.
“loads of white florals Jasmine Orange Blossom tuberose strong”Watch at 3:18
Jus de RoseReviewed in 2022PraiseDescribes the original as the most opulent, creamy, and rich in the range.
“it is the most opulent creamy and Rich fragrance out of the entire range”Watch at 2:22
3 criticise it
Jus de RoseReviewed in 2022CriticismOriginal can be too intoxicating, thick, and dense for some wearers. (if you find it too intoxicating)
“you find it to be too intoxicating too thick and dense”Watch at 3:42
Jeremy FragranceReviewed in 2020CriticismReviewer says nothing in the scent clearly stands out.
“it has nothing that clearly stands out”Watch at 2:01
Blush: scent
4 praise it
Jus de RoseReviewed in 2022PraiseSays Blush is not candy-like and has a tangy, acidic fruitiness.
“it doesn't smell like candy or some sweets”Watch at 6:24
The Gossip ClosetReviewed in 2024PraiseRecommends it for people who like florals, with vanilla and sweetness. (for people who like florals)
“this one is meant for people who like florals”Watch at 13:09
2 criticise it
Soki LondonReviewed in 2025CriticismFlat, bland vanilla that needs a stronger top note.
“I found it a bit Bland like it needs more of a top note”Watch at 7:14
The Gossip ClosetReviewed in 2024CriticismInitial spray comes out very bitter, from the bergamot. (initial spray)
“the first initial spray of this perfume it does come out very very bitter”Watch at 13:57
EDP: projection
2 praise it
Soki LondonReviewed in 2025PraiseLasts well and projects strongly.
“it lasts IT projects”Watch at 3:43
Emerald SeaReviewed in 2024PraiseSoft and not loud, projects modestly despite long wear.
“I don't feel like it projects very big and it's not a loud fragrance.”Watch at 2:39
3 criticise it
The Gossip ClosetReviewed in 2024CriticismVery strong, so she doesn't reach for it for everyday wear. (not for everyday wear)
“it's just a really really strong scent it's not a everyday wear”Watch at 2:22
SimplyShaughnessyReviewed in 2020CriticismThe original doesn't project well on her skin, though she notes others say it does. (on her skin)
“on me it doesn't project well it doesn't”Watch at 3:53
Blush: overall
4 praise it
Jus de RoseReviewed in 2022PraiseCalls Blush her favorite flanker and the best in the range.
“very good girl by far is my favorite from the range”Watch at 5:45
The Gossip ClosetReviewed in 2024PraiseSays she really likes it quite a lot and rates it highly.
“I really really like this perfume a lot”Watch at 15:15
1 criticise it
Soki LondonReviewed in 2025CriticismReviewer finds it personally boring.
“I found this personally a little bit boring”Watch at 7:08
Blush: longevity
3 praise it
Jus de RoseReviewed in 2022PraiseSays the range lasts about 12 hours on her skin, which she finds phenomenal. (on my skin)
“these fragrances last around 12 hours plus which is phenomenal”Watch at 1:20
The Glow QuestReviewed in 2025PraiseLasts six to eight hours on clothes and skin.
“All of these variants easily last for 6 to 8 hours on your clothes and on your body”Watch at 0:38
1 criticise it
Soki LondonReviewed in 2025CriticismBergamot lemony top note fades very quickly.
“a bit of a bergmont lemony top note and that Fades super quickly”Watch at 7:21
Reviews, version by version
85 comments from 8 reviewers
Carolina Herrera Good Girl Eau de Parfum 8 reviewers
overall6 comments
Soki LondonReviewed in 2025PraiseGood fragrance that lasts, sexy and wearable and modern.
“it is a good fragrance it lasts”Watch at 3:43
Jus de RoseReviewed in 2022PraiseRecommends the original Good Girl to women who like sweeter, creamier scents.
“and I would recommend good girl the OD”Watch at 3:35
Jeremy FragranceReviewed in 2020PraiseReviewer rates it 8 out of 10 as a very good fragrance.
“I give this one an 8 out of 10”Watch at 3:40
SimplyShaughnessyReviewed in 2020PraiseReviewer is a fan of the original and really likes and enjoys it.
“so i am one of the people who really like and enjoy good girl”Watch at 1:08
LindseyraebeautyReviewed in 2024PraiseReviewer loves the original good girl but does not own a bottle.
“which I really do love even though I don't own it in my collection”Watch at 2:13
Emerald SeaReviewed in 2024PraiseReviewer calls it a phenomenal spring and summer daytime fragrance.
“This one is a phenomenal spring summer daytime fragrance.”Watch at 1:24
scent14 comments
Soki LondonReviewed in 2025PraiseStrong white florals over sweet vanilla and warm tonka base.
“loads of white florals Jasmine Orange Blossom tuberose strong”Watch at 3:18
Jus de RoseReviewed in 2022PraiseDescribes the original as the most opulent, creamy, and rich in the range.
“it is the most opulent creamy and Rich fragrance out of the entire range”Watch at 2:22
Jus de RoseReviewed in 2022CriticismOriginal can be too intoxicating, thick, and dense for some wearers. (if you find it too intoxicating)
“you find it to be too intoxicating too thick and dense”Watch at 3:42
The Gossip ClosetReviewed in 2024PraiseCalls the original a beautiful, sweet, sexy scent with a statement presence.
“it's definitely a beautiful scent this is a sweet grown sexy perfume”Watch at 2:30
Jeremy FragranceReviewed in 2020MixedLeans sexy, but reviewer says it avoids being cheap or overwhelmingly sweet.
“fragrance leans very much into the sexy area”Watch at 0:29
Jeremy FragranceReviewed in 2020PraiseNot overwhelmingly super-sweet, with good freshness alongside its sweetness.
“it's not overwhelmingly super-sweet”Watch at 0:42
Jeremy FragranceReviewed in 2020CriticismReviewer says nothing in the scent clearly stands out.
“it has nothing that clearly stands out”Watch at 2:01
Jeremy FragranceReviewed in 2020PraiseReviewer smells fruity notes in the range of peach or mango.
“something fruity something in the range of peach or mango”Watch at 2:22
SimplyShaughnessyReviewed in 2020PraiseReviewer finds the original sexy, smoky, and mysterious when she smells it.
“when i smell good girl i get smokey sexy mysterious”Watch at 2:37
SimplyShaughnessyReviewed in 2020PraiseReviewer describes the original as bold and in-your-face compared with Supreme.
“the good girl original is like in your face bold fragrance”Watch at 8:04
The Glow QuestReviewed in 2025PraiseSweet but strong; makes the wearer feel confident yet feminine.
“This one makes you feel confident but feminine at the same time”Watch at 1:34
The Glow QuestReviewed in 2025PraiseDescribed as bold, bossy, and feminine at the same time.
“this one is bold, bossy and feminine at the same time”Watch at 1:13
LindseyraebeautyReviewed in 2024CriticismFinds the original less sexy and heavy than the Elixir.
“I feel like the original good girl does not have as heavily”Watch at 7:27
Emerald SeaReviewed in 2024PraiseSmells like Sunday church mornings, a youthful nostalgic floral.
“This smells like Sunday mornings in church.”Watch at 1:33
longevity6 comments
Jus de RoseReviewed in 2022PraiseSays the range lasts about 12 hours on her skin, which she finds phenomenal. (on my skin)
“these fragrances last around 12 hours plus which is phenomenal”Watch at 1:20
Jeremy FragranceReviewed in 2020PraiseReviewer says it is long lasting and perfectly versatile.
“it's long lasting so it's perfectly versatile”Watch at 0:51
Jeremy FragranceReviewed in 2020PraiseReviewer says its performance is very good, lasting well for a sweet scent.
“the performance of this is very good”Watch at 1:30
SimplyShaughnessyReviewed in 2020PraiseThe original lasts about eight hours on her skin.
“it does last eight hours on my skin”Watch at 3:38
The Glow QuestReviewed in 2025PraiseLasts six to eight hours on clothes and skin.
“All of these variants easily last for 6 to 8 hours on your clothes and on your body”Watch at 0:38
Emerald SeaReviewed in 2024PraiseVery long lasting, reviewer estimates eight to ten hours.
“It is a very long lasting fragrance.”Watch at 2:29
projection5 comments
Soki LondonReviewed in 2025PraiseLasts well and projects strongly.
“it lasts IT projects”Watch at 3:43
The Gossip ClosetReviewed in 2024CriticismVery strong, so she doesn't reach for it for everyday wear. (not for everyday wear)
“it's just a really really strong scent it's not a everyday wear”Watch at 2:22
SimplyShaughnessyReviewed in 2020CriticismThe original doesn't project well on her skin, though she notes others say it does. (on her skin)
“on me it doesn't project well it doesn't”Watch at 3:53
The Glow QuestReviewed in 2025CriticismProjection is too loud; people will notice it.
“or projection is too loud. People will notice”Watch at 0:47
Emerald SeaReviewed in 2024PraiseSoft and not loud, projects modestly despite long wear.
“I don't feel like it projects very big and it's not a loud fragrance.”Watch at 2:39
occasion5 comments
Soki LondonReviewed in 2025PraiseQuite an evening fragrance.
“would say quite evening fragrance”Watch at 3:16
Jus de RoseReviewed in 2022PraiseCalls the original an ultimate clubbing or evening scent.
“this is your ultimate clubbing scent or evening scent”Watch at 2:42
The Gossip ClosetReviewed in 2024PraiseSuits special occasions, like a date night or a wedding. (for special occasions)
“perfumes perfect for special occasions”Watch at 3:12
Jeremy FragranceReviewed in 2020PraiseReviewer considers it one of the best gifts to give a woman. (as a gift for women)
“this is one of the best gifts you can give to a woman”Watch at 3:52
Emerald SeaReviewed in 2024PraiseSuited to travel and romantic, Paris-style cafe moments.
“This smells like something you can wear if you are traveling to Paris.”Watch at 3:32
value1 comment
Jeremy FragranceReviewed in 2020PraiseReviewer says it is not that expensive.
“it's not that expensive”Watch at 4:04
compliments3 comments
Jeremy FragranceReviewed in 2020PraiseReviewer says it draws compliments; they received compliments on it.
“it's a compliment magnet”Watch at 3:05
SimplyShaughnessyReviewed in 2020CriticismShe has never received a compliment while wearing the original.
“i've never received a compliment from wearing this fragrance”Watch at 3:44
The Glow QuestReviewed in 2025PraiseReports receiving many compliments while wearing it.
“I've got many compliments on this one”Watch at 1:45
Carolina Herrera Good Girl Suprême 3 reviewers
overall4 comments
The Gossip ClosetReviewed in 2024PraiseSays no other Good Girl release has matched this one as her favorite.
“none of them have been able to top this one”Watch at 21:38
The Gossip ClosetReviewed in 2024PraiseSays the perfume makes her feel very confident.
“feel very very confident”Watch at 22:08
SimplyShaughnessyReviewed in 2020PraiseReviewer says she really loves Supreme and loves wearing it.
“i really love this i love wearing it”Watch at 13:09
The Glow QuestReviewed in 2025PraiseReviewer calls it just amazing.
“This one is just amazing.”Watch at 2:43
scent5 comments
The Gossip ClosetReviewed in 2024PraiseSays it smells so good, and she is obsessed with it.
“it's just smells so so freaking good”Watch at 23:11
The Gossip ClosetReviewed in 2024MixedSays the scent doesn't match the listed notes, though she still loves it.
“the scent that I'm getting out of this perfume doesn't match the notes”Watch at 23:39
SimplyShaughnessyReviewed in 2020PraiseReviewer says the berries stand out strongly when Supreme is first sprayed.
“you really get a burst of berries when you first spray this”Watch at 7:58
The Glow QuestReviewed in 2025PraiseSweeter and candier take on the original, with a playful feel.
“This one is the sweeter and candier version of OG Good”Watch at 2:23
The Glow QuestReviewed in 2025PraiseJuicy berry note added alongside jasmine and woodsy almond.
“the juicy berry note along with”Watch at 2:33
longevity2 comments
SimplyShaughnessyReviewed in 2020PraiseSupreme lasted eight hours on her skin.
“it lasted eight hours on my skin”Watch at 7:41
The Glow QuestReviewed in 2025PraiseLasts six to eight hours on clothes and skin.
“All of these variants easily last for 6 to 8 hours on your clothes and on your body”Watch at 0:38
projection1 comment
The Glow QuestReviewed in 2025CriticismProjection is too loud; people will notice it.
“or projection is too loud. People will notice”Watch at 0:47
occasion2 comments
SimplyShaughnessyReviewed in 2020PraiseReviewer calls Supreme the daytime version of the original, softer and less intense. (daytime)
“like i said the day version of the original good girl”Watch at 10:55
The Glow QuestReviewed in 2025PraiseSuited to day wear and spring wear. (for day or spring wear)
“perfect for day wear or spring wear”Watch at 2:39
compliments1 comment
SimplyShaughnessyReviewed in 2020PraiseSupreme earned her a compliment, unlike the original.
“i did receive compliment a compliment when i was”Watch at 7:44
Carolina Herrera Good Girl Blush 6 reviewers
overall6 comments
Soki LondonReviewed in 2025CriticismReviewer finds it personally boring.
“I found this personally a little bit boring”Watch at 7:08
Soki LondonReviewed in 2025CriticismDescribed as the timid, not exciting youngest sister.
“it's like the youngest sister that's like a bit timid”Watch at 7:49
Jus de RoseReviewed in 2022PraiseCalls Blush her favorite flanker and the best in the range.
“very good girl by far is my favorite from the range”Watch at 5:45
The Gossip ClosetReviewed in 2024PraiseSays she really likes it quite a lot and rates it highly.
“I really really like this perfume a lot”Watch at 15:15
LindseyraebeautyReviewed in 2024PraiseReviewer enjoys it and considers it a staple in her collection.
“I really enjoy good girl blush and I think it is a staple in my collection literally phenomenal”Watch at 3:11
Emerald SeaReviewed in 2024PraiseReviewer says they have never disliked an elixir.
“I've never met an elixir that I didn't like”Watch at 0:57
scent10 comments
Soki LondonReviewed in 2025CriticismFlat, bland vanilla that needs a stronger top note.
“I found it a bit Bland like it needs more of a top note”Watch at 7:14
Jus de RoseReviewed in 2022PraiseSays Blush is not candy-like and has a tangy, acidic fruitiness.
“it doesn't smell like candy or some sweets”Watch at 6:24
The Gossip ClosetReviewed in 2024PraiseRecommends it for people who like florals, with vanilla and sweetness. (for people who like florals)
“this one is meant for people who like florals”Watch at 13:09
The Gossip ClosetReviewed in 2024CriticismInitial spray comes out very bitter, from the bergamot. (initial spray)
“the first initial spray of this perfume it does come out very very bitter”Watch at 13:57
The Gossip ClosetReviewed in 2024PraiseDry down is gorgeous, floral with vanilla and a hint of bitterness. (dry down)
“the dry down on this perfume is so so gorgeous”Watch at 14:07
The Glow QuestReviewed in 2025PraiseLightest and most floral scent in the whole range.
“This is the lighter the most floral fragrance in the whole range”Watch at 4:49
LindseyraebeautyReviewed in 2024PraiseDescribes it as sweet, soft, floral and creamy; enjoys it.
“overall it is a really nice sweet soft floral creamy fragrance I really enjoy good girl blush”Watch at 3:05
LindseyraebeautyReviewed in 2024PraiseSays good girl blush feels softer than the Elixir.
“it's not quite as soft as I would say good girl blush is right”Watch at 7:01
Emerald SeaReviewed in 2024MixedVery similar to the EDP but more potent and evening-leaning.
“This smells very similar to the original but it's like this is good girl versus bad girl.”Watch at 4:20
Emerald SeaReviewed in 2024MixedHusky patchouli dry-down adds an evening feel but is somewhat heavy.
“that patchouli the dry down of that is a little bit husky”Watch at 5:53
longevity4 comments
Soki LondonReviewed in 2025CriticismBergamot lemony top note fades very quickly.
“a bit of a bergmont lemony top note and that Fades super quickly”Watch at 7:21
Jus de RoseReviewed in 2022PraiseSays the range lasts about 12 hours on her skin, which she finds phenomenal. (on my skin)
“these fragrances last around 12 hours plus which is phenomenal”Watch at 1:20
The Glow QuestReviewed in 2025PraiseLasts six to eight hours on clothes and skin.
“All of these variants easily last for 6 to 8 hours on your clothes and on your body”Watch at 0:38
LindseyraebeautyReviewed in 2024PraiseGets really great longevity from good girl blush.
“good girl blush I get really great longevity”Watch at 8:33
projection3 comments
The Glow QuestReviewed in 2025CriticismProjection is too loud; people will notice it.
“or projection is too loud. People will notice”Watch at 0:47
LindseyraebeautyReviewed in 2024CriticismProjection is not the best for good girl blush.
“I don't get the best projection”Watch at 8:38
Emerald SeaReviewed in 2024PraiseHas a noticeable kick, stronger than the EDP on application. (when first sprayed)
“And it does have a nice big kick.”Watch at 6:28
occasion6 comments
Soki LondonReviewed in 2025PraiseLighter, daytime-suitable fragrance than the other versions.
“quite daytime I'm a bit lighter than all the others”Watch at 7:47
Jus de RoseReviewed in 2022PraiseSays Blush is fresher and more playful, so it works for daytime wear too. (during the day)
“you can also wear it during the day”Watch at 6:49
The Glow QuestReviewed in 2025PraiseSuited to day wear and spring season. (for day wear or spring)
“perfect for day wear or perfect for your spring time or spring season”Watch at 5:06
The Glow QuestReviewed in 2025PraiseDescribed as suited to girls, college girls, and school girls. (for young women and students)
“This is perfect for girls, college girls or school girls”Watch at 5:09
Emerald SeaReviewed in 2024PraiseA safer scent for office wear than louder fragrances. (for office wear)
“This right here is a safer scent that you can easily wear to the office.”Watch at 6:46
Emerald SeaReviewed in 2024PraiseLeans toward evening and late afternoon wear. (evening or late afternoon)
“slightly more of an evening slash late afternoon fragrance.”Watch at 7:00
value1 comment
LindseyraebeautyReviewed in 2024MixedBlush price rose about five dollars; reviewer finds the increase fair.
“about a $5 increase on all of the bottles”Watch at 4:38
Which would you buy?
Hear when this count changes
The videos behind this page
Quotes come from automatic transcripts, so a word may be misheard; the timestamp link lets you check. “Disclosed in description” reports what the video description says about sponsorship, gifts or affiliate links. Silence is not an accusation. How we count.
Report an error on this page
People also compare
Pick: EDPYves Saint LaurentWomen's
YSL Libre
EDT, EDP, Intense, Le Parfum
8 reviewers comparedFrom $3.97
Pick: EDPChanelWomen's
Chanel Coco Mademoiselle
EDT, EDP, Intense
8 reviewers comparedFrom $4.99
Pick: Over RedYves Saint LaurentWomen's
YSL Black Opium
EDP, Le Parfum, Over Red, Extreme
8 reviewers comparedFrom $3.97
Pick: Delina La RoséeParfums de MarlyWomen's
Parfums de Marly Delina
Delina, Delina Exclusif, Delina La Rosée
8 reviewers comparedFrom $7.97