
The short answer
Of 8 reviewers, 5 of the 8 who compared the EDP pick it; 1 of 7 pick the EDT, 1 of 7 pick the Le Parfum.
Reviewers describe the EDT as the lightest, cleanest version, the EDP as sweeter, woodier and longer lasting, and Le Parfum as a smoother, slightly sweeter take on the EDP. Elixir is the most different and priciest; opinions on rankings vary.
Leaving out the 2 videos that disclose sponsorship or a gifted bottle: of 6 reviewers, 4 of the 6 who compared the EDP pick it; 1 of 5 pick the EDT, 1 of 5 pick the Le Parfum.
A count of what 8 reviewers said, not our rating. Counted on .
Yves Saint Laurent
YSL Y: EDT, EDP, Le Parfum or Elixir?
YSL Y Eau de Parfum
Apple-led, sweeter and woodier than the EDT, with long wear and strong projection; most reviewers rank it highly, one ranked it last.
Reviewers smell: apple, sweet, aromatic, woody, amberwood, bergamot, fresh, ginger
Picked by Chaos Fragrances, Chaos Fragrances, Rotten Rebel, Mr Seasons, Rotten Rebel
Choose it if you
- want a louder, sweeter scent
- want it for dates, nights out or varied use
- want compliments
Skip it if you
- plan to wear it heavily in summer heat or humidity
- dislike sweet or floral-leaning scents
- need long wear (one reviewer says it fades)
Where to buy
US prices at MicroPerfumes on 2026-11-15. Travel sizes and samples there are decanted by the shop, not made by the brand. Also sold at MicroPerfumes, Scent Split, Sephora, Amazon.
The versions side by side
| What reviewers say | EDT | EDP | Le Parfum | Elixir |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pick it | 1 of 7 reviewers | 5 of 8 reviewers | 1 of 7 reviewers | 0 of 4 reviewers |
| US price | $12.99 travel size | $97 bottle | Not listed | Not listed |
| scent | Mostly praised 5 praise, 1 criticise | Mostly praised 6 praise | Mostly praised 7 praise, 1 criticise | Mostly praised 3 praise, 1 criticise |
| longevity | Mostly criticised 0 praise, 2 criticise | Mostly praised 3 praise, 1 criticise | Mostly praised 4 praise, 1 criticise | Mixed 2 praise, 1 criticise |
| projection | No comment | Mostly praised 3 praise | Mixed 1 praise, 1 criticise | Mixed 1 praise, 1 criticise |
| occasion | Mostly praised 3 praise, 1 criticise | Mixed 4 praise, 2 criticise | Mixed 2 praise, 1 criticise | Mostly praised 2 praise |
| value | Mostly criticised 0 praise, 2 criticise | Mostly praised 3 praise | Mostly criticised 1 praise, 2 criticise | Mostly criticised 0 praise, 3 criticise |
| compliments | Mostly praised 2 praise | Mostly praised 3 praise | Mostly praised 2 praise | Mostly praised 2 praise |
Head to head
What reviewers compare it to
Other fragrances reviewers bring up when they talk about YSL Y, most-mentioned first. A comparison is one reviewer's nose, not a claim that two fragrances are the same.
1 reviewer, compared with
“there are some fragrances like saage elixir that don't actually really smell like Savage Oda tolet”
Gents Scents on the Elixir. Watch at 18:32
Bottega Veneta Pour Homme
1 reviewer, compared with
“think of uh a couple of my favorites, Bayga Vanetta Pome”
Chaos Fragrances on the Le Parfum. Watch at 11:47
Montblanc Legend Spirit
1 reviewer, smells like
“opening that you get from mont blanc legend spirit is the same thing”
BowTie FragranceGuy on the Le Parfum. Watch at 5:12
1 reviewer, compared with
“I probably prefer it just over my Blur Chanels, all of them”
Mr Seasons on the EDP. Watch at 0:35
Where reviewers disagree
Reviewers mostly praise what they show, so the splits are the part worth reading before you buy.
EDP: occasion
4 praise it
Gents ScentsReviewed in 2024PraiseWorks well for nights out, clubbing and dates.
“it's a great night out fragrance a great clubbing fragrance a great date fragrance”Watch at 5:43
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2022PraiseVery versatile; works for the gym, formal events, drinks with friends and dates.
“if i'm going out for a drink if i'm going out on a date this one works”Watch at 2:22
2 criticise it
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2023CriticismMay be too heavy and sweet for some in summer heat or humidity. (during the summertime)
“heavy and sweet for some during the summertime”Watch at 15:50
Gents ScentsReviewed in 2024CriticismCan be cloying and headache-inducing when sprayed heavily in hot weather. (in summer heat when applied heavily)
“very sweet it can be cloying and so that can cause some people to get headaches”Watch at 5:24
EDT: overall
3 praise it
Gents ScentsReviewed in 2024PraiseThe current 2022 reformulation is better than the discontinued 2017 original.
“this new version the 2022 version is better”Watch at 1:22
BowTie FragranceGuyReviewed in 2021PraiseThe EDT remains his favorite of the four Y versions he owns.
“is this something about the edt that makes it my favorite of the bunch”Watch at 10:28
2 criticise it
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2025CriticismThe last one in the line he would buy.
“OD twelet would be about the last one that I would”Watch at 2:59
Mr SeasonsReviewed in 2025CriticismNot worth bothering with if you already own the EDP. (if you already have the EDP)
“you start on the EDP, you're not really going to bother with the EDT”Watch at 8:02
EDP: overall
7 praise it
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2023PraiseStill great and not made obsolete by newer flankers.
“probably the EDP and it's great it's not obsolete”Watch at 16:22
Gents ScentsReviewed in 2024PraiseThe most popular and best-selling version in the line.
“one is the most popular in the Y lineup”Watch at 4:09
1 criticise it
SoCal ScentsReviewed in 2024CriticismRanked last of the five in her final order.
“And then and dead last. The eau de parfum.”Watch at 5:54
Le Parfum: scent
7 praise it
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2023PraiseSweet but still aromatic and clean; apple gives it more substance.
“helps to drive this one home and it gives it more”Watch at 11:57
Gents ScentsReviewed in 2024PraiseLess sweet than the EDP, though still has some sweetness.
“not quite as sweet as why Oda param though it does have sweetness”Watch at 13:19
1 criticise it
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2022CriticismFinds it flatter, lacking the different sides that make the EDP attractive. (to him)
“the perfume to me is a bit more flat almost it doesn't have all these different size that i find is so attractive about the edp”Watch at 6:47
Le Parfum: overall
6 praise it
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2023PraiseA great flanker he really likes; a richer take with better performance.
“I think it's a great flanker I really”Watch at 12:03
Gents ScentsReviewed in 2024PraiseChoose it for a more grown-up, mature and smoother take on the EDP. (if you want it more mature)
“little more grown up little more mature and smoother overall go for Lear”Watch at 13:55
1 criticise it
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2025CriticismHe never loved the 2021 version and found it redundant next to the EDP. (2021 version)
“I never have really loved Learfam 2021”Watch at 9:20
Reviews, version by version
154 comments from 8 reviewers
YSL Y Eau de Toilette 7 reviewers
overall13 comments
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2023MixedSmells great but there are better options in the line, in his view.
“so many better options um at least subjectively uh”Watch at 6:01
Gents ScentsReviewed in 2024PraiseThe current 2022 reformulation is better than the discontinued 2017 original.
“this new version the 2022 version is better”Watch at 1:22
Gents ScentsReviewed in 2024PraiseOne of the best in the lineup if you want versatility. (if you want extreme versatility)
“you're looking for just extreme versatility this is going to be one of the best in the entire lineup”Watch at 3:50
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2025CriticismThe last one in the line he would buy.
“OD twelet would be about the last one that I would”Watch at 2:59
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2025CriticismSkip it and choose any of the other versions instead. (if you just want to smell good and are not a collector)
“I would skip the OD twelet and I would go for basically any of the others”Watch at 4:04
BowTie FragranceGuyReviewed in 2021PraiseThe EDT remains his favorite of the four Y versions he owns.
“is this something about the edt that makes it my favorite of the bunch”Watch at 10:28
Mr SeasonsReviewed in 2025MixedA nice, light, airy, easy-wearing scent, but outclassed by the EDP.
“The EDT, very light, airy, easy wearing”Watch at 7:35
Mr SeasonsReviewed in 2025CriticismNot worth bothering with if you already own the EDP. (if you already have the EDP)
“you start on the EDP, you're not really going to bother with the EDT”Watch at 8:02
SoCal ScentsReviewed in 2024PraiseJordan liked it a lot on first smell and rated it 7.5 out of 10. (on first spray)
“Yeah, I like this one a lot.”Watch at 0:37
SoCal ScentsReviewed in 2024PraiseHeld up on the drydown; she liked it as much as at the start. (on the drydown)
“I say the same. I still really like this one.”Watch at 4:15
SoCal ScentsReviewed in 2024PraiseFinished second in her final ranking of the five, behind Le Parfum.
“Second place eau de toilette”Watch at 5:47
SoCal ScentsReviewed in 2024PraiseAnother bonus reviewer loved it and scored it about nine out of ten. (bonus reviewer, 2022 version)
“I'm going to say like nine, maybe a lemon nine.”Watch at 7:46
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2026MixedRanks the original EDT seventh of ten but calls it underrated. (original 2017 version)
“The OG Y EDT takes seventh place. I think it's so underrated”Watch at 13:33
scent13 comments
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2023PraiseSmells very clean, like fresh linen and freshly washed clothes.
“smells like clean linen smells like clean fresh”Watch at 5:39
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2023PraiseCrisp, clean and very inoffensive.
“and super inoffensive”Watch at 5:49
Gents ScentsReviewed in 2024PraiseExtremely fresh and easy to wear, a bit like clean laundry.
“it's extremely fresh very easy to wear might remind you a little bit of like clean laundry”Watch at 2:52
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2025PraiseBright, fresh and sparkling; he says it smells amazing.
“It smells absolutely amazing”Watch at 2:38
Mr SeasonsReviewed in 2025CriticismNo apple in the opening, unlike the EDP.
“Straight off the bat, no apples.”Watch at 4:25
Mr SeasonsReviewed in 2025MixedMore floral, with a lavender or sage feel.
“Getting like a bit of maybe a lavender or sage, that type of vibe.”Watch at 4:42
Mr SeasonsReviewed in 2025CriticismLess fruity and lacks the lively fizz of the EDP.
“It doesn't have that same, as I say, snap, crackle, and pop that the EDP has.”Watch at 4:51
Mr SeasonsReviewed in 2025MixedLess musky and less masculine than the EDP.
“The EDT isn't as musky or masculine”Watch at 5:07
Mr SeasonsReviewed in 2025MixedLess wood and depth than the EDP; lighter and fresher instead.
“not as much wood, not as much depth as the EDP, just more lighter, fresher”Watch at 6:45
SoCal ScentsReviewed in 2024PraiseSmells very clean and fresh.
“Very clean. Fresh.”Watch at 0:33
SoCal ScentsReviewed in 2024PraiseA bonus reviewer found it fresh, a little sweet and citrusy, with a grapefruit feel. (bonus reviewer, 2022 version)
“It gives me like a grapefruit.”Watch at 7:01
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2026PraiseFresh, bright opening with spicy ginger, bergamot and aldehydes over a soft woody drydown. (original 2017 version)
“you get a fresh and bright opening with a prominent dose of spicy freshness from ginger”Watch at 0:52
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2026PraiseThe 2022 EDT is very smooth, fresh and softly sweet; more modern and rounder than the original. (2022 version)
“it's so incredibly smoothly fresh and softly sweet”Watch at 6:28
longevity5 comments
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2023CriticismSecond-weakest performer in the line; not a good choice if you want performance.
“this one doesn't really have the best performance”Watch at 4:49
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2023MixedLasts roughly 6 to 7 hours, fine alone but weak next to the others.
“it's in that 6 6 and 1/2 maybe”Watch at 6:32
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2025CriticismLasts six to seven hours, weaker than basically all the others.
“six, seven hour performer. That's not hateful.”Watch at 4:08
BowTie FragranceGuyReviewed in 2021MixedLasts about five and a half to six and a half hours on a good day. (on his skin)
“with the original edt i get that five and a half maybe six and a half hour mark”Watch at 9:09
Mr SeasonsReviewed in 2025MixedPerformance is his main concern, but he has not tested a full wear yet. (first impressions, not a full wear test)
“that's my only concern with the EDT is what's the performance like on this”Watch at 3:44
occasion4 comments
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2023PraiseWorks well for many situations. (for collectors who already own the others)
“theoda tolet is a great wear”Watch at 6:26
Gents ScentsReviewed in 2024CriticismMay feel too light in winter for people who want something heavier. (for people who prefer warm, spicy, heavier scents in winter)
“winter time it may not pack enough punch for a lot of people”Watch at 3:09
Gents ScentsReviewed in 2024PraiseOffice safe and good for casual daytime wear.
“it's office safe it's a great casual fragrance great for a day out in general”Watch at 3:27
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2026PraiseA favorite for the gym and when he wants a lighter take on the Y scent. (2022 version)
“The new EDT has been one of my favorites for the gym and when I want a lighter take on that Y DNA”Watch at 11:44
value2 comments
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2023CriticismCosts about the same as versions that last roughly twice as long.
“the same price as some of the others that perform”Watch at 6:15
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2025CriticismStill costs $80 or more at discounters, so not cheap for what it offers.
“you're not getting the OD twelet for cheap”Watch at 3:10
compliments3 comments
BowTie FragranceGuyReviewed in 2021PraiseCalls the original a compliment magnet and has used up much of his bottle.
“as i told you guys before there's a compliment magnet i love the original dna”Watch at 3:11
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2026PraiseThe original EDT is one of his most complimented in the line. (original 2017 version)
“the OG is one of my most complimented in the line”Watch at 0:49
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2026PraiseThe 2022 EDT is his most complimented of the fresh Y scents. (2022 version)
“Y Eau de Toilette 2022 is my most complimented, most fresh Y so Y”Watch at 6:57
YSL Y Eau de Parfum 8 reviewers
overall11 comments
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2023PraiseStill great and not made obsolete by newer flankers.
“probably the EDP and it's great it's not obsolete”Watch at 16:22
Gents ScentsReviewed in 2024PraiseThe most popular and best-selling version in the line.
“one is the most popular in the Y lineup”Watch at 4:09
Gents ScentsReviewed in 2024PraiseChoose it if you want the sweeter, more playful, louder take. (if you want it sweeter and louder)
“little bit sweeter more playful a little bit more loud go for the OD param”Watch at 13:52
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2022PraiseFinds the EDP more layered and more exciting than Le Parfum. (to his nose)
“the edp has more layers to it it's more exciting at least to me”Watch at 8:11
BowTie FragranceGuyReviewed in 2021PraiseNow glad he owns the EDP; it is his second favorite of the line.
“i'm glad i have the edp because now i think this is honestly my second favorite uh of the whole line”Watch at 3:44
Mr SeasonsReviewed in 2025PraiseDeclared the overall winner; does more than the EDT in every respect.
“the EDP is a better beast all around. It just does more.”Watch at 7:38
SoCal ScentsReviewed in 2024MixedSimilar to the EDT but she preferred the EDT; rated it 5 out of 10. (on first spray)
“not too crazy different from the first. I think I like the first better, though, so I'd say like a 5/10”Watch at 1:17
SoCal ScentsReviewed in 2024MixedSlipped a little on the drydown, though she still liked it. (on the drydown)
“Maybe, like a step down from the last one.”Watch at 4:27
SoCal ScentsReviewed in 2024CriticismRanked last of the five in her final order.
“And then and dead last. The eau de parfum.”Watch at 5:54
SoCal ScentsReviewed in 2024PraiseA bonus reviewer loves the EDP, which her boyfriend wears, despite disliking the Intense. (bonus reviewer)
“so it's funny how you love y eau de parfum, but you didn't like the intense.”Watch at 9:20
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2026PraiseRanks it first; finds it slightly more addictive than the 2022 EDT.
“it's slightly more addictive”Watch at 15:56
scent13 comments
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2023PraiseApple-led sweetness with plenty of amberwood, aromatics and some citrus.
“uses a lot of Apple here going back to”Watch at 15:31
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2025PraiseAdds sweet apple to the EDT DNA; sweeter, stronger, heavier and richer.
“It's sweeter. It's stronger. It's it's more heavy, more rich”Watch at 5:05
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2022PraiseOpening is fresh and citrusy with some depth, slightly herbal and aromatic. (opening)
“fresh citrusy opening with some depth to it slightly herbal slightly aromatic but really nice and fresh”Watch at 1:06
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2022PraisePrefers the EDP's bright, nuanced, citrusy and slightly sweet opening over Le Parfum's. (opening)
“i think i actually enjoy that bright really nuanced aromatic citrusy and slightly sweet opening of the edp”Watch at 4:02
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2022PraiseDry down loses some freshness and becomes fuller, rounder and woodier; he loves it. (dry down)
“it's more full it's more round i absolutely love the dry down”Watch at 5:02
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2022PraiseThinks it smells even better in the dry down than in the opening. (dry down)
“it was beautiful in the beginning but it's almost even more beautiful now woody aromatic”Watch at 5:07
BowTie FragranceGuyReviewed in 2021MixedFound the EDP more floral and sweet, and passed on it at first sniff.
“for some reason to me this one was a little bit more floral and sweet”Watch at 3:28
Mr SeasonsReviewed in 2025PraiseHas a ginger note he really enjoys.
“the EDP just has a lovely ginger note”Watch at 0:57
Mr SeasonsReviewed in 2025PraiseOpens with apple and bergamot plus a hint of pepper.
“the uplifting essence of bergamot and apple and the little hint of peppery notes that dance”Watch at 3:20
Mr SeasonsReviewed in 2025PraiseWoodier, with more character and depth than the EDT.
“The EDP has more wood, more character, more depth.”Watch at 5:14
Mr SeasonsReviewed in 2025PraiseComes across as a masculine, sexy fragrance.
“It's such a, dare I say, masculine, sexy fragrance.”Watch at 3:14
SoCal ScentsReviewed in 2024PraiseReminded her of the beach.
“Like like, I don't know, the beach.”Watch at 1:05
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2026PraiseLess fresh and more woody than the EDT, with fruity apple and soft sweet tonka.
“it has the fruitiness from fresh apple together with a soft dose of sweet tonka”Watch at 2:39
longevity4 comments
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2023PraiseStrongest of the line, lasting 11 to 12 hours.
“11 12h hour performer very strong”Watch at 15:42
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2025PraiseLasts 12 hours or more and is often still going after that.
“12 plus hour longevity runs with the soda parfoam and a lot of times it'll still be kicking”Watch at 5:46
Mr SeasonsReviewed in 2025CriticismLike other fresh fragrances, it does not last particularly long.
“Like all freshies though, it doesn't last particularly long.”Watch at 3:39
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2026PraiseOne of the top performers in the line, close to strong but not beast mode.
“Y Eau de Parfum is among the top compliment getters and top performers in the line”Watch at 3:08
projection4 comments
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2023PraiseGreat projection and scent trail.
“very strong great projection”Watch at 15:42
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2023MixedAbout as strong and overpowering as the line gets.
“and obnoxious and overpowering as it gets”Watch at 15:42
Gents ScentsReviewed in 2024PraiseProjects more and lasts longer than the EDT.
“it also packs more of a punch than yod to twet so it projects more it last longer”Watch at 5:11
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2025PraiseProjects very well.
“Great projection as well”Watch at 6:18
occasion8 comments
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2023CriticismMay be too heavy and sweet for some in summer heat or humidity. (during the summertime)
“heavy and sweet for some during the summertime”Watch at 15:50
Gents ScentsReviewed in 2024CriticismCan be cloying and headache-inducing when sprayed heavily in hot weather. (in summer heat when applied heavily)
“very sweet it can be cloying and so that can cause some people to get headaches”Watch at 5:24
Gents ScentsReviewed in 2024PraiseWorks well for nights out, clubbing and dates.
“it's a great night out fragrance a great clubbing fragrance a great date fragrance”Watch at 5:43
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2025MixedWorks most of the year but may be too sweet in extreme heat. (in very hot, humid weather)
“sweet for some people during certain periods of the year when it's really, really hot and”Watch at 6:24
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2022PraiseVery versatile; works for the gym, formal events, drinks with friends and dates.
“if i'm going out for a drink if i'm going out on a date this one works”Watch at 2:22
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2022PraiseCalls it a super versatile fragrance with many sides to it.
“it's also a super versatile fragrance”Watch at 1:57
Mr SeasonsReviewed in 2025PraiseVersatile and easy to wear.
“it's a really versatile, easy wearing fragrance”Watch at 3:53
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2026PraiseAmong the very best in the line for everyday, year-round wear. (for everyday use)
“I do feel this is among the very best for everyday use”Watch at 3:02
value3 comments
Gents ScentsReviewed in 2024PraiseDiscounters knock more dollars off the EDP than the EDT. (at discounters)
“actually more of a discount available for yod to parfum”Watch at 4:43
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2025PraiseAround $100 at discounters, which he considers reasonable.
“It's reasonable, especially in this day and age. 100 bucks doesn't seem too bad”Watch at 6:02
Mr SeasonsReviewed in 2025PraiseOffers more for the money than the EDT.
“You get more bang for your buck, baby.”Watch at 7:41
compliments3 comments
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2025PraiseGets a lot of compliments, which drives its popularity.
“compliment puller, everybody is wanting to get this stuff”Watch at 5:57
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2022PraiseGets a lot of compliments wearing it, which he treats as a bonus.
“all the compliments i get with it is just an amazing bonus”Watch at 8:26
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2026PraiseAlways in his versatile rotation and gets a lot of compliments.
“It's always been in my rotation of versatile fragrances and it's a compliment master”Watch at 15:56
YSL Y Le Parfum 7 reviewers
overall9 comments
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2023PraiseA great flanker he really likes; a richer take with better performance.
“I think it's a great flanker I really”Watch at 12:03
Gents ScentsReviewed in 2024PraiseChoose it for a more grown-up, mature and smoother take on the EDP. (if you want it more mature)
“little more grown up little more mature and smoother overall go for Lear”Watch at 13:55
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2025CriticismHe never loved the 2021 version and found it redundant next to the EDP. (2021 version)
“I never have really loved Learfam 2021”Watch at 9:20
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2025PraiseThe 2025 version is far better than the first Le Parfum. (2025 version)
“but the Lelay Parfoam 2025 to me is worlds better than the the first version”Watch at 12:08
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2022PraiseSays both are really good and you can't go wrong with either.
“both of these are really really good you can't go wrong with any of them”Watch at 9:09
BowTie FragranceGuyReviewed in 2021PraisePleased with the purchase, though he ranks it third behind the EDT and EDP.
“i am pleased with this purchase and having this in my collection”Watch at 10:13
SoCal ScentsReviewed in 2024PraiseHer favourite on first smell; she gave it 10 out of 10. (on first spray)
“This might be my favorite. I like this one a lot. I give it a ten, honestly.”Watch at 2:08
SoCal ScentsReviewed in 2024PraiseStill her favourite after it settled; beachy and fresh. (on the drydown)
“This is still my favorite. I love this one. Very, like beachy, very fresh.”Watch at 4:55
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2026MixedThe 2025 version is not groundbreaking and may feel too similar to earlier releases. (2025 version)
“definitely not groundbreaking in any way”Watch at 9:41
scent18 comments
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2023PraiseSweet but still aromatic and clean; apple gives it more substance.
“helps to drive this one home and it gives it more”Watch at 11:57
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2023MixedDoes not wear as heavy as a true parfum concentration.
“quite wear like a true param doesn't have the same”Watch at 10:48
Gents ScentsReviewed in 2024PraiseLess sweet than the EDP, though still has some sweetness.
“not quite as sweet as why Oda param though it does have sweetness”Watch at 13:19
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2025MixedSmells very close to the EDP, just a little sweeter. (2021 version)
“very close to the Odaparfam. A little bit sweeter, but other than that, very close”Watch at 9:35
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2025PraisePine and balsam fir give an earthy, rugged, traditional masculine cologne smell. (2025 version)
“outdoor kind of rugged smell. Just a true cologne smell and that's what this one has”Watch at 11:57
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2022MixedOpening is still bright but less bright and less fresh than the EDP. (opening)
“it's still bright but it's not as bright as the edp and it doesn't come across as as fresh as that one”Watch at 3:37
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2022PraiseLikes the opening; describes it as aromatic and semi-fresh. (opening)
“i like it it's aromatic it's semi-fresh”Watch at 3:51
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2022MixedThinks tonka gives the dry down a creaminess that the EDP does not have. (dry down)
“maybe it's a tonka blend that gives it that sort of creaminess”Watch at 5:56
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2022MixedNoticeably less woody than the EDP in the dry down. (to his nose)
“the perform is way less woody than the edp”Watch at 6:32
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2022CriticismFinds it flatter, lacking the different sides that make the EDP attractive. (to him)
“the perfume to me is a bit more flat almost it doesn't have all these different size that i find is so attractive about the edp”Watch at 6:47
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2022MixedSmoother than the EDP in both the opening and the dry down.
“now when it comes to dry down same thing perform is way more smooth”Watch at 7:55
BowTie FragranceGuyReviewed in 2021MixedThe opening does not smell like the original EDT at first; the DNA appears after several minutes.
“the opening the initial opening did not initially remind me of the original why”Watch at 4:50
BowTie FragranceGuyReviewed in 2021MixedLacks the EDT's mint in the opening, so it is a little less fresh.
“this one doesn't have that mint in the opening so it's missing a little bit of that extra freshness”Watch at 6:00
BowTie FragranceGuyReviewed in 2021PraiseDries down warmer and woodier than the EDT.
“it's a little bit more of a warm kind of woody dry down on this one”Watch at 7:55
BowTie FragranceGuyReviewed in 2021PraiseTonka bean makes the dry down sweeter than the EDT's, which he likes.
“so the dry down on lapar foam is sweeter than the dry down on the edt”Watch at 8:03
SoCal ScentsReviewed in 2024PraiseVery fresh, like a new body wash that suits you.
“Like when you get a new body wash and you're like, wow, this really works for me”Watch at 2:19
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2026PraiseA darker, richer, slightly warmer take on the EDP with apple, tonka and lavender. (original Le Parfum)
“I think it's a darker, richer, more nuanced, and a bit a warmer version of the eau de parfum”Watch at 5:04
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2026PraiseThe 2025 version smells good and stands out for its piney woodiness. (2025 version)
“I think it smells good and I do think it stands out with its prominent sort of a piney kind of woodiness”Watch at 9:33
longevity6 comments
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2023PraiseLasts around 9 hours, a big jump over the EDT.
“more about roughly around 9 or so 9 hours”Watch at 11:04
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2023MixedDespite the name, it is not the top performer in the line.
“believe it or not the lay param is not the”Watch at 10:04
Gents ScentsReviewed in 2024PraiseGreat performance; lasts a long time.
“it has great performance this one lasts a long time”Watch at 12:33
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2025CriticismSlightly weaker than the EDP, around ten hours rather than twelve plus. (2021 version)
“I've even found it to be slightly less strong than”Watch at 10:43
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2025PraiseGood performer at about ten hours, though not as strong as the EDP. (2025 version)
“Find it to be a good performer. It's back around that 10hour mark as well”Watch at 12:33
BowTie FragranceGuyReviewed in 2021PraiseStill lightly detectable at about seven and a half hours, longer than the EDT. (on his skin)
“i can still pick it up lightly at about the seven and a half hour mark”Watch at 9:18
projection2 comments
Gents ScentsReviewed in 2024PraiseProjects heavily enough to get you noticed.
“it projects heavily so it will get you noticed”Watch at 12:35
BowTie FragranceGuyReviewed in 2021CriticismProjects less than the EDT, which he expected from the higher concentration.
“it does not project as much as the edt but that is to be expected”Watch at 8:56
occasion4 comments
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2023CriticismCan be too sweet for people to wear in warm weather. (when it's warm outside)
“with wearing the Oda param the lay param sweeter”Watch at 12:59
BowTie FragranceGuyReviewed in 2021PraiseBest in spring and summer, but also wearable in the fall.
“pretty much spring summer is the best time to wear it but you can work get away with wearing this in the fall as well”Watch at 9:44
BowTie FragranceGuyReviewed in 2021PraiseCan work in winter too, particularly indoors at the office. (in a climate controlled or office environment)
“work as well in the winter time especially in an office type environment”Watch at 10:01
SoCal ScentsReviewed in 2024PraiseThe host sees it as the date night version of the line; she agreed. (for date night)
“To me, this is like the date night version of this.”Watch at 2:31
value3 comments
Gents ScentsReviewed in 2024CriticismRetail price is considerably higher than the EDT or EDP. (at retail)
“the price jumped up with this one it is considerably more than either of these at retail”Watch at 11:45
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2025CriticismCosts more than the others at discounters, around $140, as a new release. (2025 version)
“So on discounters it's still going to be more expensive”Watch at 12:14
BowTie FragranceGuyReviewed in 2021PraiseDifferent enough from the EDT to justify buying; not a redundant purchase. (if you like this DNA enough)
“it would warrant a purchase and it's not going to be a redundant purchase”Watch at 8:40
compliments2 comments
BowTie FragranceGuyReviewed in 2021PraiseLike the EDT, it has a mass-appealing scent people are attracted to and is easy to wear.
“just like the edt it's a massive feeling dna that people just are attracted to”Watch at 10:05
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2026PraiseThe original Le Parfum also gets compliments. (original Le Parfum)
“it's another compliment getter”Watch at 6:04
YSL Y Elixir 4 reviewers
overall5 comments
Gents ScentsReviewed in 2024MixedAt its price a cheaper version may be the better buy, unless price doesn't matter.
“may be better off uh going with one of these but if the price doesn't matter this is a comp puller”Watch at 21:22
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2025MixedHe likes it but thinks other versions are better options for the money.
“So, I do like it. I just think that maybe there”Watch at 15:21
SoCal ScentsReviewed in 2024MixedShe liked it but rated it 6.5 to 7 because it is so different. (on first spray)
“I give it like a 7 or a 6.5 I like it, it's just very different.”Watch at 3:15
SoCal ScentsReviewed in 2024MixedMiddle of the pack after settling; finished third of five. (on the drydown)
“It's kind of in the middle for me.”Watch at 5:13
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2026CriticismHis least favorite of the line; mostly lavender and lacking excitement.
“I do feel Y Elixir lacks a bit of excitement”Watch at 13:15
scent7 comments
Gents ScentsReviewed in 2024PraiseSoapy, clean and classy, more aromatic than the others.
“so a bit soapy very clean very classy”Watch at 18:55
Gents ScentsReviewed in 2024PraiseSmells higher quality than the cheaper versions when compared side by side.
“it does smell higher quality when you put it side by side with some of the cheaper versions in the line”Watch at 21:30
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2025PraiseHe loves the smell; keeps the original DNA with a punchier, sweeter depth.
“I personally love how it smells”Watch at 13:50
SoCal ScentsReviewed in 2024MixedSmells the most different from the rest of the line, which made it hard to describe.
“it is the most extreme difference from the rest of the group.”Watch at 2:52
SoCal ScentsReviewed in 2024PraiseThe host says it has a soapy undertone and smells clean and professional.
“it has a sexy soap undertone to it.”Watch at 3:32
SoCal ScentsReviewed in 2024PraiseA bonus reviewer found it unique, unlike anything she had smelled, and rated it eight. (bonus reviewer)
“it's really unique. I have not smelled anything like this.”Watch at 11:22
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2026CriticismDoes not deliver the promised oud or deep woody character.
“I also feel it fails to deliver on the precious oud”Watch at 8:43
longevity3 comments
Gents ScentsReviewed in 2024PraiseLongevity is good; it lasts a long time.
“the longevity is good lasts a long time”Watch at 19:01
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2025PraiseGood performer, lasting about ten to eleven hours.
“it's a good performer. It's a 10 11”Watch at 14:52
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2026CriticismGoes soft too quickly. (on his skin)
“I also feel it goes a bit too soft too fast at least on my skin”Watch at 8:56
projection2 comments
Gents ScentsReviewed in 2024CriticismDoes not project as heavily as some other versions in the line.
“just doesn't project quite as heavily as some of these other fragrances”Watch at 19:03
SoCal ScentsReviewed in 2024PraiseNot overpowering; more subtle while still fresh. (bonus reviewer)
“It's not too overwhelming either. Overpowering.”Watch at 11:40
occasion2 comments
Gents ScentsReviewed in 2024PraiseWearable year round, day or night.
“you can wear this yearr round Daytime Nighttime does not matter”Watch at 19:19
SoCal ScentsReviewed in 2024PraiseThe host calls it safe for the office and school. (for office or school)
“This is going to be office safe, school safe.”Watch at 12:10
value3 comments
Gents ScentsReviewed in 2024CriticismThe most expensive in the line, and only sold in the smaller bottle.
“this is the most expensive why especially when you consider it only comes in the smaller size bottle”Watch at 17:07
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2025CriticismMost expensive and only sold in 60 ml; he dislikes the price.
“I just don't really like the price point really”Watch at 13:57
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2026CriticismYou are mostly paying for lavender; more exciting lavender scents cost less.
“you can get more exciting lavender focused scents for less than that what you pay for”Watch at 8:51
compliments2 comments
Gents ScentsReviewed in 2024PraiseGets compliments; people like how it smells.
“it's also a compliment puller people love the way it smells”Watch at 19:24
SoCal ScentsReviewed in 2024PraiseThe host expects people to think you smell good wearing it.
“People are going to think you smell good wearing it.”Watch at 12:13
Which would you buy?
Hear when this count changes
The videos behind this page
| Reviewer | Video | Pick | Disclosed in description |
|---|---|---|---|
| The ULTIMATE YSL Y Buying Guide Ranked By PERFORMANCE — Y EDT VS EDP, Parfum, EDP Intense + More “the top performer here it's the most popular one” 16:17 | EDP | affiliate links, discount code, own brand | |
| Yves Saint Laurent Y Fragrance Buying Guide - Which Should You Get? (2024) | None named | affiliate links, discount code, own brand | |
| Complete YSL Y Buying Guide (2025) - Which Should You Buy? “as like an all year round signature scent” 6:38 | EDP | affiliate links, discount code | |
| Yves Saint Laurent Y Eau De Parfum Vs Le Parfum👌 Which YSL Y Compliment Getter Fragrance is BEST? “if i am going to choose one sorry perform i'm going with the edp i love it that much” 8:18 | EDP | Nothing found | |
| NEW* YSL Y LE PARFUM! (YSL Y EDT vs EDP vs EAU FRAICHE) Which is Better? “is this something about the edt that makes it my favorite of the bunch” 10:28 | EDT | affiliate links, discount code | |
| YSL Y Showdown 2025: EDT or EDP – Who Wins? “but the EDP is a better beast all around. It just does more. You get more bang for your buck, baby.” 7:38 | EDP | Nothing found | |
| Which YSL “Y” is best? Women decide! Yves Saint Laurent Y fragrances “So your winner is Y Le Parfum. No competition.” 5:17 | Le Parfum | affiliate links, discount code | |
| The YSL Y To Get.. AND The One To Avoid. 10 Yves Saint Laurent Y Men's Fragrances RANKED! “I am going to say that the right now Y Eau de Parfum secures first place” 15:49 | EDP | Nothing found |
Quotes come from automatic transcripts, so a word may be misheard; the timestamp link lets you check. “Disclosed in description” reports what the video description says about sponsorship, gifts or affiliate links. Silence is not an accusation. How we count.
Report an error on this page
People also compare
Pick: ElixirDiorMen's
Dior Sauvage
EDT, EDP, Parfum, Elixir
10 reviewers comparedFrom $2.99
Pick: EDPChanelMen's
Bleu de Chanel
EDT, EDP, Parfum
8 reviewers comparedFrom $4.99
Pick: AbsolutelyEmporio ArmaniMen's
Armani Stronger With You
Original, Intensely, Absolutely
8 reviewers comparedFrom $2.97
Pick: EDPVersaceMen's
Versace Eros
EDT, EDP, Parfum
8 reviewers comparedFrom $2.97