How the guides are made
Every number on this site is a count of what named reviewers said in a named video. We do not rate fragrances and we have no opinion on which version is best.
Where the evidence comes from
For each fragrance we pick YouTube videos that compare its versions side by side. Videos under three minutes are left out. A small channel counts exactly as much as a large one.
How a video becomes a line on the page
- The video is transcribed automatically.
- A language model lists what the reviewer said about each version: scent, longevity, projection, occasion, value and compliments.
- A script checks every quote word for word against the transcript. A quote that is not there is thrown away, along with its claim.
- The timestamp is worked out from the transcript, not taken from the model.
The short paraphrase above each quote is ours. The words in quotation marks are the reviewer's.
What “3 of 6” means
A reviewer can only pick a version that existed when they filmed. So each version is counted against the reviewers who actually compared it, not against everyone in the guide. A version fewer than three reviewers compared is marked as thin evidence.
What can go wrong
- Automatic transcripts mishear words, especially French names. The quote shows what the transcript says; the link shows what was said.
- A reviewer who names two favourites is counted under the first one.
- Brands reformulate. A 2020 video describes the 2020 bottle. Each quote shows its year.
Who paid for the review
Each guide lists what the video description discloses: sponsorship, gifted bottles, affiliate links, discount codes. We report what is written there. A reviewer who says nothing is not accused of anything.
Corrections
Every guide has a “Report an error” link. You can also write to hello@whichscent.com. Reviewers who want a quote corrected or removed only need to ask.