
The short answer
Of 8 reviewers, 3 of the 8 who compared the Extrait pick it; 2 of 8 pick the EDP.
Reviewers generally describe the EDP as lighter, airier and more transparent, and the Extrait as richer, smoother, woodier and longer lasting. They disagree on projection, strength and whether the Extrait is worth the higher price.
Leaving out the 1 video that discloses sponsorship or a gifted bottle: of 7 reviewers, 2 of the 7 who compared the EDP pick it; 2 of 7 pick the Extrait.
A count of what 8 reviewers said, not our rating. Counted on .
Maison Francis Kurkdjian
Baccarat Rouge 540: EDP or Extrait?
Baccarat Rouge 540 Extrait
Richer, denser, woodier version with almond and musk notes and longer staying power, though it costs more and some find it heavy.
Reviewers smell: saffron, jasmine, sweet, almond, bitter almond, woody, cedar wood, creamy
Picked by The Perfume Guy, Fashion and Fitness Over 40, Lavishly Chi Chi
Choose it if you
- you want a richer, smoother, woodier scent
- you want longer lasting, more consistent presence
- you like almond or bitter almond sweetness
Skip it if you
- you need an office or work scent
- you want a light daytime scent for hot weather
- you dislike a stronger burnt smoke note
Where to buy
US prices at MicroPerfumes on 2026-11-15. Travel sizes and samples there are decanted by the shop, not made by the brand. Also sold at MicroPerfumes, Scent Split, Sephora, Amazon.
The versions side by side
| What reviewers say | EDP | Extrait |
|---|---|---|
| Pick it | 2 of 8 reviewers | 3 of 8 reviewers |
| US price | $34.97 travel size | $42.99 travel size |
| scent | Mostly praised 7 praise, 2 criticise | Mostly praised 8 praise |
| longevity | Mixed 7 praise, 3 criticise | Mostly praised 8 praise |
| projection | Mixed 1 praise, 1 criticise | Mostly praised 7 praise |
| occasion | Mixed 5 praise, 2 criticise | Mixed 3 praise, 4 criticise |
| value | Mostly praised 3 praise | Mixed 3 praise, 3 criticise |
| compliments | Mostly praised 2 praise | Mostly praised 2 praise |
What reviewers compare it to
Other fragrances reviewers bring up when they talk about Baccarat Rouge 540, most-mentioned first. A comparison is one reviewer's nose, not a claim that two fragrances are the same.
Ariana Grande Cloud
2 reviewers, compared with, smells like
“people try to say that like ariana cloud smells like in other words i smelled that and i was like uh they're lying to you”
The Santa Maria on the EDP. Watch at 8:27
Burberry Her
2 reviewers, compared with, smells like
“people are saying burberry hurt all”
The Santa Maria on the EDP. Watch at 8:36
Initio Oud for Greatness
1 reviewer, smells like
“I definitely pick up that Accord that's in back rat Rouge here in initio”
The Perfume Guy on the EDP. Watch at 11:36
Thomas Kosmala No. 4 Apres l'Amour
1 reviewer, smells like
“you can totally pick up the baccarat Rouge 540 DNA here”
The Perfume Guy on the EDP. Watch at 13:35
Mancera Instant Crush
1 reviewer, smells like
“that DNA of background Rouge 540 is in here and it's really really prominent”
The Perfume Guy on the EDP. Watch at 14:46
Montale Sensual Instinct
1 reviewer, smells like
“it's like a Mont ha esque version of factor at rouge”
The Perfume Guy on the EDP. Watch at 16:50
Mizensir For Your Love
1 reviewer, smells like
“it's in there that baccarat Rouge like DNA or a chord”
The Perfume Guy on the EDP. Watch at 18:00
Tiziana Terenzi Spirito Fiorentino
1 reviewer, smells like
“that's when it'll remind you of a little bit of the DNA of baccarat Rouge”
The Perfume Guy on the EDP. Watch at 20:18
Where reviewers disagree
Reviewers mostly praise what they show, so the splits are the part worth reading before you buy.
EDP: longevity
7 praise it
Erin Nicole TVReviewed in 2021PraiseLasts for days on clothing, hair and pillowcases. (in her personal experience)
“it lasts for days days on my clothing”Watch at 9:43
The Santa MariaReviewed in 2022PraiseLasts eight hours or more, though the wearer may stop noticing it.
“lasts eight hours a day plus sometimes eight hours plus depending on your circumstance”Watch at 7:49
3 criticise it
The ScentedReviewed in 2021CriticismHad already faded after a midday shower while the Extrait was still noticeable. (on her skin, after a shower)
“i could still smell the x-ray and then the original had already faded”Watch at 12:27
Jimmy C FragranceReviewed in 2026CriticismFar weaker days later; the Extrait has clearly more staying power. (on paper, days after spraying)
“it's far weaker now. The staying power is definitely more on the extrate”Watch at 4:59
Extrait: occasion
3 praise it
Erin Nicole TVReviewed in 2021PraiseBest kept for evenings, special occasions and date nights.
“i think this should be reserved for evening special occasions date nights”Watch at 14:55
The Santa MariaReviewed in 2022PraiseIts thickness works better in colder weather, especially autumn and winter.
“me this is better in colder weather”Watch at 15:26
4 criticise it
Erin Nicole TVReviewed in 2021CriticismShe would not feel as comfortable wearing it during the day. (for daytime wear)
“i would personally not feel as comfortable wearing this during the day”Watch at 14:50
The Santa MariaReviewed in 2022CriticismToo thick and heavy for very hot weather. (in 100-degree heat)
“it gets 100 degrees in my area and yeah this could choke somebody out”Watch at 15:40
Extrait: value
3 praise it
The Santa MariaReviewed in 2022PraiseThe longevity justifies the price tag.
“with their price tag you are getting your money's worth”Watch at 13:45
Jimmy C FragranceReviewed in 2026PraiseStill projects off paper days later, so he considers the money well spent.
“it projects off paper days later. Your money is well spent with this fragrance”Watch at 5:58
3 criticise it
The Santa MariaReviewed in 2022CriticismCosts noticeably more than the already expensive EDP.
“this is already expensive but yeah the x-ray costs even more”Watch at 10:31
The Perfume GuyReviewed in 2020CriticismCosts a lot more than the EDP.
“one is a lot more expensive than the other”Watch at 3:06
EDP: scent
7 praise it
Erin Nicole TVReviewed in 2021PraiseVanilla sugar note gives a cotton candy sweetness that is stronger here than in the Extrait. (if you love sugary sweetness)
“candy cotton candy sweetness you really get that in the edp”Watch at 6:51
The Santa MariaReviewed in 2022PraiseLighter, airier and more playful than the Extrait.
“the edp is more light and airy it's more whimsical it's more fun”Watch at 14:35
2 criticise it
Perfume Talk: fragrance reviews, cologne exploringReviewed in 2023CriticismPeople who dislike it say it reminds them of a dentist's office. (for people who don't like it)
“it's remind them of dentist office something like this”Watch at 6:36
Fashion and Fitness Over 40Reviewed in 2018CriticismSomething in the EDP does not sit well with him.
“there's something in the Eau de Parfum like that just doesn't sit well with me”Watch at 1:18
EDP: occasion
5 praise it
Erin Nicole TVReviewed in 2021PraiseWorks for almost any occasion and in any season.
“perfect to wear for just about any occasion it's a seasonless fragrance”Watch at 13:17
The Santa MariaReviewed in 2022PraiseShe finds it best suited to spring and summer.
“i think it's more appropriate for the spring and the summer”Watch at 14:57
2 criticise it
Jimmy C FragranceReviewed in 2026CriticismBorderline too much for jobs like chef or hospital work. (for chefs or hospital workers)
“you work in the hospital, EDP is borderline not good”Watch at 7:09
Perfume Talk: fragrance reviews, cologne exploringReviewed in 2023CriticismNot suggested for hot summer daytime wear. (in summer heat during the day)
“I wouldn't suggest it to wear during the summer hits during the daytime”Watch at 11:58
Reviews, version by version
133 comments from 8 reviewers
Baccarat Rouge 540 Eau de Parfum 8 reviewers
overall8 comments
Erin Nicole TVReviewed in 2021MixedBecoming so popular it risks feeling cliche, though she says it is not there yet.
“it's just too popular maybe cliche i don't think it's there yet”Watch at 12:33
The Santa MariaReviewed in 2022PraiseShe loved it the first time she smelled it.
“this is the type of scent that this was a love at first sniff”Watch at 6:31
The Perfume GuyReviewed in 2020MixedDid not like it at first sniff, but grew to be obsessed with how it smells.
“it wasn't a love it for sniff but now I'm obsessed with the way it smells”Watch at 1:11
The Perfume GuyReviewed in 2020PraiseFans of the EDP can stick with it; the Extrait is only for those wanting something stronger. (if you like lighter fragrances)
“a lot of you are fans of this and you could you can stick with it”Watch at 8:39
The ScentedReviewed in 2021PraiseCan be worn every day without getting tired of it.
“every single day and not get tired of it”Watch at 11:21
Perfume Talk: fragrance reviews, cologne exploringReviewed in 2023MixedThe original is the louder, attention-seeking one that announces wealth.
“original one screaming I'm rich and famous take a look at me”Watch at 8:05
Fashion and Fitness Over 40Reviewed in 2018PraiseCalls the EDP a beautiful fragrance and an absolute masterpiece. (if you like sweet fragrances)
“really is a beautiful fragrance I mean it's it is an absolute masterpiece as far as I'm concerned”Watch at 0:39
Lavishly Chi ChiReviewed in 2023MixedRarely worn alone, but still loved in her collection as a layering fragrance.
“So even though I don't wear this alone a lot of the time, I still love it in my collection”Watch at 4:56
scent20 comments
Erin Nicole TVReviewed in 2021PraiseVanilla sugar note gives a cotton candy sweetness that is stronger here than in the Extrait. (if you love sugary sweetness)
“candy cotton candy sweetness you really get that in the edp”Watch at 6:51
Erin Nicole TVReviewed in 2021PraiseFeels light, airy and luminous when compared side by side with the Extrait.
“it's not very heavy it's kind of light and there's an airiness to it”Watch at 8:09
The Santa MariaReviewed in 2022PraiseLighter, airier and more playful than the Extrait.
“the edp is more light and airy it's more whimsical it's more fun”Watch at 14:35
The Perfume GuyReviewed in 2020PraiseAmbroxan combined with saffron, jasmine and cedar wood makes a very sexy scent.
“combined it with that sexy saffron and jasmine and cedar wood”Watch at 4:16
The Perfume GuyReviewed in 2020MixedLess dense than the Extrait; wears airy and transparent.
“it's less dense a lot more Airy transparent comes to mind”Watch at 8:08
The ScentedReviewed in 2021PraiseAiry, crisp, slightly salty sweetness with woods and a toasted cotton candy feel.
“it's very airy it's a very crisp little bit salty sweetness”Watch at 3:39
The ScentedReviewed in 2021MixedHas a noticeable medicinal facet that smells like a dentist, gauze or a hospital.
“describe as this medicinal facet that smells like a dentist or gauze or a hospital and that is definitely there”Watch at 4:28
Jimmy C FragranceReviewed in 2026PraiseBoth are heavy and sweet, but the EDP is more transparent, especially in the drydown.
“the EDP is more transparent, especially as it dries down”Watch at 0:51
Jimmy C FragranceReviewed in 2026PraiseThe burnt smoke accord is at just the right level, though it may still put some off.
“weaker in the EDP because it's just right in the EDP”Watch at 6:14
Perfume Talk: fragrance reviews, cologne exploringReviewed in 2023PraiseOpens with saffron and a burnt-sugar sweetness.
“sweetness sweetness like burnt sugar”Watch at 1:28
Perfume Talk: fragrance reviews, cologne exploringReviewed in 2023PraiseAmbroxan gives it a fresh, clean, statement-making feel.
“ambroxton here will give the feeling of freshness clean like you want to make a statement”Watch at 6:02
Perfume Talk: fragrance reviews, cologne exploringReviewed in 2023CriticismPeople who dislike it say it reminds them of a dentist's office. (for people who don't like it)
“it's remind them of dentist office something like this”Watch at 6:36
Perfume Talk: fragrance reviews, cologne exploringReviewed in 2023PraiseIn the dry down it smells much fresher and cleaner. (in the dry down)
“the buckaro roost smells much more fresher much more cleaner”Watch at 12:24
Perfume Talk: fragrance reviews, cologne exploringReviewed in 2023PraiseComes across as the fresher, more floral of the two.
“Much More Much More fresher floral like fresh”Watch at 14:03
Fashion and Fitness Over 40Reviewed in 2018CriticismSomething in the EDP does not sit well with him.
“there's something in the Eau de Parfum like that just doesn't sit well with me”Watch at 1:18
Fashion and Fitness Over 40Reviewed in 2018CriticismFinds the EDP slightly bleachy; his wife noticed the same note.
“and I find it just a tiny bit bleachy”Watch at 1:53
Fashion and Fitness Over 40Reviewed in 2018CriticismSuspects a rose or floral note makes the EDP smell a little sour.
“that sits out to me that just makes things smell a little bit sour”Watch at 3:20
Fashion and Fitness Over 40Reviewed in 2018MixedSays many people will not notice the off note in the EDP.
“a lot of people won't notice that note”Watch at 3:10
Lavishly Chi ChiReviewed in 2023PraiseSmells like delicately spun sugar, a refined cotton candy rather than fairground cotton candy.
“It smells like the most delicately spun sugar of cotton candy but not your, you know, state”Watch at 2:41
Lavishly Chi ChiReviewed in 2023PraiseMixes well with almost everything she layers it with. (when layered)
“And literally like 95% of the things that I mix with this, it just works.”Watch at 4:29
longevity12 comments
Erin Nicole TVReviewed in 2021PraiseLasts for days on clothing, hair and pillowcases. (in her personal experience)
“it lasts for days days on my clothing”Watch at 9:43
The Santa MariaReviewed in 2022PraiseLasts eight hours or more, though the wearer may stop noticing it.
“lasts eight hours a day plus sometimes eight hours plus depending on your circumstance”Watch at 7:49
The Santa MariaReviewed in 2022MixedClings to clothes better than it does to skin.
“the edp hooks clothes better than it hugs skin in my opinion”Watch at 16:46
The Perfume GuyReviewed in 2020PraiseLasts a very long time, especially when sprayed on clothing. (on clothing)
“it has major major longevity especially on clothing”Watch at 4:22
The Perfume GuyReviewed in 2020PraiseLasts about six to seven hours. (for him)
“last six hours six and a half hours maybe pushing seven hours”Watch at 5:47
The ScentedReviewed in 2021PraiseLasts reliably, even on her very dry skin. (on her dry skin)
“the original lasts it just it objectively lasts it just does even on my skin”Watch at 13:28
The ScentedReviewed in 2021CriticismHad already faded after a midday shower while the Extrait was still noticeable. (on her skin, after a shower)
“i could still smell the x-ray and then the original had already faded”Watch at 12:27
Jimmy C FragranceReviewed in 2026CriticismFar weaker days later; the Extrait has clearly more staying power. (on paper, days after spraying)
“it's far weaker now. The staying power is definitely more on the extrate”Watch at 4:59
Perfume Talk: fragrance reviews, cologne exploringReviewed in 2023PraiseLongevity is described as very good, same as the Extrait. (depends on your skin)
“longevity of both of them are pretty amazing”Watch at 8:38
Fashion and Fitness Over 40Reviewed in 2018PraiseLongevity and projection of the EDP are fantastic.
“the longevity and the projection of this one are fantastic as well”Watch at 0:51
Lavishly Chi ChiReviewed in 2023CriticismFades in and out repeatedly; the biggest disappearing act she has seen from a fragrance. (on her skin)
“This one does the biggest disappearing act I have ever seen with a fragrance but I still”Watch at 2:32
Lavishly Chi ChiReviewed in 2023PraiseLasts on clothing as well. (on clothing)
“She definitely lasts on clothing as well.”Watch at 9:24
projection6 comments
The Santa MariaReviewed in 2022MixedNoticeable but not very strong; she rates strength seven out of ten. (on skin)
“it's not super duper strong yes you do smell it but it's not over the top”Watch at 7:14
The Perfume GuyReviewed in 2020MixedLongevity is good but the wearing experience is thin.
“it does have great longevity but it's a thin longevity”Watch at 6:06
The ScentedReviewed in 2021MixedComes and goes for the wearer; others smell it even when she cannot.
“the odepak fum does play more of that peekaboo game”Watch at 9:35
Perfume Talk: fragrance reviews, cologne exploringReviewed in 2023CriticismThe second host could barely smell it on skin after a while. (for the second host, after some minutes on skin)
“this one is I I almost can't feel you know”Watch at 13:43
Fashion and Fitness Over 40Reviewed in 2018PraiseFinds the EDP slightly stronger than the Extrait.
“I've defined this one a tiny bit stronger than the x-ray”Watch at 0:56
Fashion and Fitness Over 40Reviewed in 2018PraiseRecommends the EDP if strength and projection are the priority. (if strength and projection are what you want)
“if its strengths and the projection you're looking for definitely check out the Eau de Parfum”Watch at 3:03
occasion10 comments
Erin Nicole TVReviewed in 2021PraiseWorks for almost any occasion and in any season.
“perfect to wear for just about any occasion it's a seasonless fragrance”Watch at 13:17
Erin Nicole TVReviewed in 2021MixedCan be strong depending on sprays, so it may not suit the office. (for office wear)
“it can be pretty strong depending on how much you spray so i'm not sure it is office appropriate”Watch at 13:36
The Santa MariaReviewed in 2022PraiseShe finds it best suited to spring and summer.
“i think it's more appropriate for the spring and the summer”Watch at 14:57
The Santa MariaReviewed in 2022PraiseA casual, easy everyday reach that works with a plain t-shirt.
“the edp version to me is more casual i literally throw this on with a white t-shirt”Watch at 16:07
The ScentedReviewed in 2021PraiseEasy-wearing, light and airy; works as an everyday signature scent.
“original however is more of an everyday easy wearing light airy”Watch at 10:33
Jimmy C FragranceReviewed in 2026MixedFeels more feminine to him because he associates it with women, but it is truly unisex.
“more feminine in my opinion now cuz I associate it with women wearing it, going out on the weekends, but truly a unisex scent”Watch at 2:46
Jimmy C FragranceReviewed in 2026PraiseWorks in any season, day or night, and comes across as professional. (if the stronger burnt accord is a deal breaker)
“the EDP will work well for any season truly. And day or night, I think it's professional”Watch at 6:37
Jimmy C FragranceReviewed in 2026CriticismBorderline too much for jobs like chef or hospital work. (for chefs or hospital workers)
“you work in the hospital, EDP is borderline not good”Watch at 7:09
Perfume Talk: fragrance reviews, cologne exploringReviewed in 2023CriticismNot suggested for hot summer daytime wear. (in summer heat during the day)
“I wouldn't suggest it to wear during the summer hits during the daytime”Watch at 11:58
Lavishly Chi ChiReviewed in 2023PraiseShe mainly uses it to layer, adding sweetness to other fragrances without being sickly. (as a layering fragrance)
“Anytime I want a sweetness to a fragrance, this is what I top it off with or put a nice”Watch at 3:45
value5 comments
Erin Nicole TVReviewed in 2021MixedVery expensive, but she has no regrets about buying it.
“no regrets even though it is very expensive”Watch at 12:01
The Santa MariaReviewed in 2022PraiseThe more affordable of the two, though still expensive.
“the edp is the more affordable one and of course the x-ray one is more expensive”Watch at 15:59
The ScentedReviewed in 2021PraiseSlightly cheaper and gets more wear, so better value for money.
“get more bang for the buck it's cheaper it's just a little bit cheaper than the x-ray”Watch at 15:12
Fashion and Fitness Over 40Reviewed in 2018PraiseNotes many people still prefer the EDP and see no point paying more for the Extrait. (according to people he sees on Instagram)
“I met a lot of people still prefer the Eau de Parfum and don't see the point in spending the extra on the x-ray”Watch at 3:42
Lavishly Chi ChiReviewed in 2023MixedA nice scent, but whether it wows enough to keep buying at $325 depends on you.
“With that being said, for 325, is it like wowing enough to keep on buying?”Watch at 3:13
compliments2 comments
Erin Nicole TVReviewed in 2021PraiseOne of her most complimented fragrances; people ask what it is.
“it's also one of my most complimented fragrances”Watch at 10:56
The Santa MariaReviewed in 2022PraiseReliably turns heads and gets compliments.
“this is a certified head turning cinch”Watch at 8:06
Baccarat Rouge 540 Extrait 8 reviewers
overall8 comments
Erin Nicole TVReviewed in 2021MixedShe likes it, but the woodier, more masculine character appeals to her less than the EDP. (for her personal taste)
“doesn't really speak to me the same way this one does”Watch at 18:34
The Perfume GuyReviewed in 2020PraiseHighly recommended if you prefer stronger fragrances and can afford it. (if you prefer stronger fragrances and have the money)
“if you prefer stronger fragrances and you have the money I highly recommend this one”Watch at 8:26
The ScentedReviewed in 2021PraiseHer current personal preference, for the almond cookie sweetness. (personal preference after owning the EDP for a long time)
“i'm leaning more towards the x-ray as my personal preference”Watch at 14:44
The ScentedReviewed in 2021CriticismShe disliked it at first, finding it too sweet and too powerful. (the first two times she smelled it)
“i didn't like it and i thought it was too sweet and i thought it was too powerful”Watch at 9:52
Perfume Talk: fragrance reviews, cologne exploringReviewed in 2023PraiseThe quieter, more self-assured one that doesn't need to make a statement.
“this person already know that I'm rich and famous and that I don't care about your opinion”Watch at 8:14
Fashion and Fitness Over 40Reviewed in 2018PraiseCalls the Extrait absolute perfection, with the EDP very close behind.
“I think the x-ray is absolute perfection this one is very very close”Watch at 1:45
Fashion and Fitness Over 40Reviewed in 2018PraiseConsiders the Extrait a much better made fragrance.
“it's much better made fragrance in my opinion”Watch at 2:34
Lavishly Chi ChiReviewed in 2023PraiseSuits all her needs; in hindsight she might have bought only the Extrait.
“If I had to redo it again, I think I would have just gotten the Extrate.”Watch at 10:42
scent23 comments
Erin Nicole TVReviewed in 2021PraiseThe added woody accord is noticeable right away and adds depth.
“that woody accord really shines through you will pick up on it right away”Watch at 3:44
Erin Nicole TVReviewed in 2021PraiseHas a spiciness that the EDP does not have.
“there's a spiciness in the x-ray that i don't get with the eau de parfum”Watch at 4:52
Erin Nicole TVReviewed in 2021PraiseSmells very rich and clearly different from the EDP.
“it smells so so rich very different from the eau de parfum”Watch at 8:28
The Santa MariaReviewed in 2022PraiseRicher and more decadent; it makes her feel wealthy.
“this is definitely more decadent more rich and i'm loving it”Watch at 12:34
The Santa MariaReviewed in 2022PraiseNuttier than the EDP, with an almond note in her older batch. (her batch, which listed an almond note)
“the x-ray is more wittier and it's more nutty”Watch at 14:41
The Perfume GuyReviewed in 2020PraiseHas a bitter almond smell that adds a smooth, slightly creamy quality.
“this one does have that bitter almond smell so there is a little bit of a smooth cream creamy”Watch at 7:26
The Perfume GuyReviewed in 2020PraiseMuskiness is amped up compared with the EDP.
“the muskiness here compared to here has been amped up as well”Watch at 7:47
The Perfume GuyReviewed in 2020PraiseWoody, musky and very sexy, with cedar.
“it's definitely woody it's definitely musky and it's very very sexy along with cedar”Watch at 5:28
The ScentedReviewed in 2021PraiseSweeter, warmer and woodier than the EDP, with more jasmine. (in the opening)
“what you get with the extra is a sweeter version it's almost warmer it's woodier and i get the jasmine a lot more”Watch at 5:04
The ScentedReviewed in 2021PraiseSmells like a sugar-crusted amaretti cookie with an almond note.
“like sugar encrusted like amaretti cookie it has a little bit of this almondy smell”Watch at 5:22
The ScentedReviewed in 2021PraiseLess of the medicinal, dentist-like note than the EDP, though a little remains. (if the dentist vibe bothers you)
“you don't get as much of that like medicinal dentisty note it's a little bit there”Watch at 7:00
Jimmy C FragranceReviewed in 2026MixedNot just a stronger EDP; he finds it a compositionally different fragrance.
“I found that the X-ray in this case is compositionally different”Watch at 0:39
Jimmy C FragranceReviewed in 2026PraiseDenser and sweeter than the EDP without being loud.
“It's more dense, sweeter, and without being loud, it's just calm like a bomb”Watch at 3:28
Jimmy C FragranceReviewed in 2026MixedThe burnt smoke accord is more prominent, which bothers some people.
“but it's definitely more prominent in the Xrate”Watch at 6:20
Perfume Talk: fragrance reviews, cologne exploringReviewed in 2023PraiseNot stronger so much as rounder and smoother than the original.
“it's much more rounded version much more smooth version compared to original one”Watch at 2:26
Perfume Talk: fragrance reviews, cologne exploringReviewed in 2023PraiseMore vivid and saturated without being strong.
“it's more Vivid more saturated but not strong”Watch at 2:37
Perfume Talk: fragrance reviews, cologne exploringReviewed in 2023PraiseAdded cedar wood gives it smoothness and warmth the original lacks.
“they added a little bit of cedar wood which give the smoothness and Warmness in a red one version”Watch at 4:34
Perfume Talk: fragrance reviews, cologne exploringReviewed in 2023PraiseMusk in the dry down gives it a mysterious feel. (in the dry down)
“mask it gives feeling of a mysterious kind of mystery around you like a veil of mystery”Watch at 6:07
Perfume Talk: fragrance reviews, cologne exploringReviewed in 2023PraiseDoes not have the dentist-office feeling some people get from the original.
“in this fragrance you will not have this feeling”Watch at 6:40
Perfume Talk: fragrance reviews, cologne exploringReviewed in 2023PraiseMore saturated, deeper and creamier than the original.
“more saturated more deep more kind of a kind of uh creamy”Watch at 13:51
Fashion and Fitness Over 40Reviewed in 2018PraiseFinds the Extrait much smoother than the EDP.
“the x-ray version I found this much much smoother”Watch at 1:13
Lavishly Chi ChiReviewed in 2023PraiseHas a bitter almond note she finds extremely good.
“Now this has a note of bitter almond that, ooh, chow.”Watch at 5:47
Lavishly Chi ChiReviewed in 2023PraiseSmells expensive, like money.
“this actually smells like money”Watch at 5:59
longevity13 comments
Erin Nicole TVReviewed in 2021PraiseLasts even longer than the already long-wearing EDP.
“it is impressively long wearing the extra parfum is even more so”Watch at 16:20
The Santa MariaReviewed in 2022PraiseExtremely long lasting; she can still smell it on clothes after dry cleaning.
“i will dry clean something and still smell the extract”Watch at 13:27
The Perfume GuyReviewed in 2020PraiseLasts even longer than the EDP.
“especially if it's the xray version even longer it lasts and lasts”Watch at 4:44
The Perfume GuyReviewed in 2020PraiseNot double the EDP's longevity, but about a third longer. (for him)
“not necessarily double the length of the time of longevity but definitely a third more”Watch at 5:36
The ScentedReviewed in 2021PraiseLasts a little longer and is stronger than the EDP.
“i do find the extra lasts a little bit longer it's stronger”Watch at 12:08
Jimmy C FragranceReviewed in 2026PraiseSits calmly around the whole body and lasts for days.
“around your whole body and it stays for days”Watch at 3:57
Jimmy C FragranceReviewed in 2026MixedClings to clothes, carpet and bed sheets, so it effectively becomes your signature scent.
“extrate, be ready for it to be your your signature scent”Watch at 5:14
Perfume Talk: fragrance reviews, cologne exploringReviewed in 2023MixedHigher concentration should last longer, but it may just be more saturated rather than longer lasting.
“sometimes perfumes which is more concentrated they're more saturated they not stain much longer”Watch at 3:49
Perfume Talk: fragrance reviews, cologne exploringReviewed in 2023PraiseSecond host finds it stronger and expects it to wear longer. (for the second host)
“more concentrate more strong you will wear it maybe longer”Watch at 13:37
Fashion and Fitness Over 40Reviewed in 2018PraiseLongevity and projection are still fantastic on the Extrait.
“the longevity and the projection which is still fantastic with the x-ray”Watch at 2:19
Lavishly Chi ChiReviewed in 2023PraiseLasts much longer than the original on her. (on her body)
“she has way longer lasting power on my body than the original”Watch at 8:08
Lavishly Chi ChiReviewed in 2023PraiseStays consistently present and never fades in and out, which is why she prefers it.
“And she never does a disappearing act.”Watch at 8:20
Lavishly Chi ChiReviewed in 2023PraiseClings to fabric for days after wearing. (on clothing)
“get up in the fabrics and it does not let up”Watch at 9:12
projection8 comments
Erin Nicole TVReviewed in 2021PraiseAfter eight to ten hours it is easier to smell on the arm than the EDP. (in her one-on-each-arm tests)
“the extra parfum is just a little bit more apparent i don't have to get my nose quite as close to my arm”Watch at 16:33
The Santa MariaReviewed in 2022PraiseSlightly stronger than the EDP, eight out of ten, but not overpowering.
“is just a little bit stronger to me than the original”Watch at 13:08
The Perfume GuyReviewed in 2020PraiseHigher oil concentration makes it stronger and longer lasting.
“it's a lot stronger here and that's why it lasts a lot longer”Watch at 6:26
The ScentedReviewed in 2021PraiseShe can smell it on herself more consistently throughout the day. (if you want to smell it on yourself all the time)
“the x-ray i can actually smell a lot more throughout the day”Watch at 9:23
Jimmy C FragranceReviewed in 2026PraiseDays after spraying, it still gives off a cloud he can smell from feet away. (sprayed on a paper card)
“pumping out this kind of a cloud around it where I can smell it feet away”Watch at 1:02
Perfume Talk: fragrance reviews, cologne exploringReviewed in 2023PraiseStill smells strong on skin once the original has faded for the second host. (close to the dry down)
“the extract is still strong”Watch at 13:20
Fashion and Fitness Over 40Reviewed in 2018MixedExtrait is smoother but may not be quite as strong as the EDP.
“it's smoother although it may not be quite as strong”Watch at 2:27
Lavishly Chi ChiReviewed in 2023PraisePerforms best for her without needing heavy application or wondering where the smell went.
“And I know I'm going to smell like baccarat and I don't have to like douse my entire body.”Watch at 10:09
occasion10 comments
Erin Nicole TVReviewed in 2021PraiseBest kept for evenings, special occasions and date nights.
“i think this should be reserved for evening special occasions date nights”Watch at 14:55
Erin Nicole TVReviewed in 2021CriticismShe would not feel as comfortable wearing it during the day. (for daytime wear)
“i would personally not feel as comfortable wearing this during the day”Watch at 14:50
The Santa MariaReviewed in 2022PraiseIts thickness works better in colder weather, especially autumn and winter.
“me this is better in colder weather”Watch at 15:26
The Santa MariaReviewed in 2022CriticismToo thick and heavy for very hot weather. (in 100-degree heat)
“it gets 100 degrees in my area and yeah this could choke somebody out”Watch at 15:40
The Santa MariaReviewed in 2022MixedMore upscale; she saves it for events rather than daily wear.
“elevated more upscale to me so this is more special occasion in my opinion”Watch at 16:37
The ScentedReviewed in 2021MixedMore lavish and amped up; better suited to special events.
“it's more like lavish it's more amped up it's more a special event version of the”Watch at 7:20
The ScentedReviewed in 2021CriticismLess of an everyday fragrance and can get a little overwhelming.
“it is less of an everyday fragrance it can get a little bit overwhelming”Watch at 9:38
Jimmy C FragranceReviewed in 2026CriticismNot suited to work settings because people overspray it and bother others. (for work)
“extrate, I think, is not good for working situations”Watch at 6:56
Jimmy C FragranceReviewed in 2026CriticismWay over the top for those jobs; the burnt tar smell is unusual to many people. (for chefs or hospital workers)
“The extrate is way over the top. You don't want that burnt tar smell”Watch at 7:12
Perfume Talk: fragrance reviews, cologne exploringReviewed in 2023PraiseSuited to clubs, balls and events where you want to show off. (when you want to show off)
“perfect for Club perfect for any ball or something when you need to show off”Watch at 14:43
value6 comments
The Santa MariaReviewed in 2022PraiseThe longevity justifies the price tag.
“with their price tag you are getting your money's worth”Watch at 13:45
The Santa MariaReviewed in 2022CriticismCosts noticeably more than the already expensive EDP.
“this is already expensive but yeah the x-ray costs even more”Watch at 10:31
The Perfume GuyReviewed in 2020CriticismCosts a lot more than the EDP.
“one is a lot more expensive than the other”Watch at 3:06
Jimmy C FragranceReviewed in 2026PraiseStill projects off paper days later, so he considers the money well spent.
“it projects off paper days later. Your money is well spent with this fragrance”Watch at 5:58
Fashion and Fitness Over 40Reviewed in 2018PraiseThinks the Extrait is worth the extra money.
“this is definitely the one I think is worth spending the extra money on”Watch at 2:23
Lavishly Chi ChiReviewed in 2023CriticismCosts considerably more than the original at $435 for 70 ml.
“run you a whopping $435”Watch at 1:28
compliments2 comments
The Santa MariaReviewed in 2022PraiseIt was her most complimented fragrance of 2021.
“this was my number one most complimented scent of 2021”Watch at 14:03
Lavishly Chi ChiReviewed in 2023PraiseBoth versions get compliments, which she considers a selling point.
“They both get compliments and that's a selling point.”Watch at 12:30
Which would you buy?
Hear when this count changes
The videos behind this page
| Reviewer | Video | Pick | Disclosed in description |
|---|---|---|---|
| BACCARAT ROUGE 540 EDP VS EXTRAIT DE PARFUM COMPARISON REVIEW! “i would have to go with the eau de parfum this one is my favorite” 18:14 | EDP | affiliate links, discount code | |
| MFK Baccarat Rouge 540 EDP vs Extrait Review and Comparison | None named | affiliate links, discount code | |
| MAISON FRANCIS KURKDJIAN BACCARAT ROUGE 540 EDP VS EXTRAIT + 11 BR540 BABIES “even more obsessed with the excavated p'fon version over the original version” 1:18 | Extrait | affiliate links, discount code, own brand | |
| MFK BACCARAT ROUGE 540 EXTRAIT VS EDP - FULL REVIEW & COMPARISON “i think i would still recommend the original oripac because i think you get more wear out of it you get more bang for the buck” 15:04 | EDP | discount code, affiliate links | |
| Maison Francis Kurkdjian Baccarat Rouge 540 EDP VS Extrait Thoughts | None named | affiliate links | |
| Battle of Baccarat Rouge 540: Eau de Parfum VS Extrait | None named | Nothing found | |
| Baccarat Rouge 540 - EDP vs Extrait “between the two of them it's definitely give me the x-ray” 4:13 | Extrait | Nothing found | |
| MFK BACCARAT ROUGE 540 VS BACCARAT ROUGE 540 EXTRAIT “So if I have to pick, definitely the Extrate.” 10:26 | Extrait | affiliate links |
Quotes come from automatic transcripts, so a word may be misheard; the timestamp link lets you check. “Disclosed in description” reports what the video description says about sponsorship, gifts or affiliate links. Silence is not an accusation. How we count.