YSL Black Opium: EDP or Over Red?
Of the 3 reviewers who compared both, 0 pick the EDP and 2 pick the Over Red; 1 prefer another version or name none.

YSL Black Opium Eau de Parfum
The original, described as lighter, airier and less sweet than Le Parfum, with coffee, white flowers and vanilla. Longevity is medium; some reviewers feel it is overused.
1 of 6 reviewers who compared it pick this version.
Reviewers smell: coffee, orange blossom, vanilla, jasmine, patchouli, white flowers, black coffee, cedarwood
Picked by Rose's Rosy Life
YSL Black Opium Over Red
The original with a soft cherry twist, less sweet, creamy and woody. Reviewers are lukewarm to positive; some find it unoriginal and pricey.
3 of 4 reviewers who compared it pick this version.
Reviewers smell: cherry, coffee, creamy, patchouli, plasticky, smoky, syrupy, vanilla
Picked by The Gossip Closet, Monika Cioch, The Santa Maria
How they compare
| What reviewers say | EDP | Over Red |
|---|---|---|
| scent | Mostly praised4 praise, 1 criticise | Mostly praised3 praise, 1 criticise |
| longevity | Mostly praised2 praise | No comment |
| projection | One comment1 praise | Mixed2 praise, 1 criticise |
| occasion | Mostly praised3 praise, 1 criticise | One comment1 praise |
| value | No comment | Mostly criticised1 praise, 2 criticise |
| compliments | One comment1 praise | One comment1 praise |
overall
EDP
The Stush LifeReviewed in 2023PraiseReviewer likes the original as a standalone fragrance and has long favored it.
“I love this fragrance I love it as a standalone fragrance”Watch at 2:46
The Stush LifeReviewed in 2023PraiseReviewer says the original will always be one of her favorite YSL scents.
“this will forever be one of my favorite YSL scents”Watch at 2:52
The Stush LifeReviewed in 2023PraiseOriginal suits people who are not into very sweet, super vanilla scents. (if not into very sweet super vanilla)
“if you're not really like a sweet girl or you're not really into the super sweet”Watch at 6:51
Over Red
The Gossip ClosetReviewed in 2023MixedNot in love with it, but doesn't hate it and likes it somewhat.
“I like it I'm not in love with it”Watch at 8:10
The Gossip ClosetReviewed in 2023CriticismDoubts they'd reach for it as often as they'd hoped.
“I don't think I would uh reach for this one as much as I would have loved to”Watch at 8:13
The Gossip ClosetReviewed in 2023MixedSays it is definitely not a bad scent and they do like it.
“it's definitely not a bad scent I do like it”Watch at 7:49
scent
EDP
The Stush LifeReviewed in 2023PraiseCoffee, white flowers, and vanilla blend well together in the original.
“the medley of the coffee the white flowers and the vanilla just works”Watch at 2:43
The Stush LifeReviewed in 2023PraiseCoffee note stays noticeable on her wrist as the original dries down. (on her wrist)
“I could still smell the coffee on my wrist”Watch at 4:50
Sassy DragonReviewed in 2023PraiseStill smells quite good to her, despite overuse.
“it's still it still smells quite good”Watch at 1:11
Over Red
The Gossip ClosetReviewed in 2023PraiseA nice perfume: sweet and creamy, yet woody and smoky.
“it is really nice it's sweet creamy yet Woody and Smoky”Watch at 5:36
The Gossip ClosetReviewed in 2023CriticismFeels unoriginal, like something already available on the market.
“like this is not something unique or special this is something that I feel like it's already out in the markets”Watch at 5:22
The Gossip ClosetReviewed in 2023CriticismCherry note is timid and faint compared with typical cherry perfumes.
“the Cherry note it's very like very timid”Watch at 4:01
longevity
EDP
The Stush LifeReviewed in 2023PraiseOriginal already lasted long on her skin before the new version arrived. (on her skin)
“I felt like the OG already lasted pretty long for me”Watch at 5:31
Sassy DragonReviewed in 2023MixedMedium longevity, around three to five hours when sprayed decently. (when sprayed pretty decently)
“I probably get about three or four maybe five hours”Watch at 2:33
Soki LondonReviewed in 2025PraiseLasts well and is a known long-wearing bestseller.
“that really does last and project well”Watch at 1:16
Over Red
The Santa MariaReviewed in 2024MixedLasts about four hours regardless of how much is sprayed.
“I get 4 hours out of the sink no matter how much I spray of it”Watch at 10:01
projection
EDP
Soki LondonReviewed in 2025PraiseProjects well and is noticeable when worn.
“that really does last and project well”Watch at 1:16
Over Red
The Gossip ClosetReviewed in 2023PraiseExpects it to leave a nice trail and linger, based on first impressions.
“I think this is going to leave a nice Trail it's probably going to linger with you”Watch at 8:32
The Gossip ClosetReviewed in 2023MixedNot a skin scent and not shy either; sits somewhere in between.
“it's not necessarily a skin scent I feel like it's in between”Watch at 8:25
Monika Cioch Reviewed in 2025CriticismSays it doesn't project or last as long as the others, so reapplying helps.
“the only downside of this one is it doesn't project or last as long as as the the other ones”Watch at 7:22
occasion
EDP
The Stush LifeReviewed in 2023PraiseOriginal reads as a nighttime scent compared with the Le Parfum.
“while the original is more gives more of a nighttime vibe”Watch at 5:26
Monika Cioch Reviewed in 2025CriticismSays the original is too loud for everyday wear. (every day)
“the original is super loud so it's not appropriate”Watch at 3:01
Soki LondonReviewed in 2025PraiseSuits party evenings; quite a sexy fragrance. (evenings)
“I would describe it as quite a party evening fragrance”Watch at 1:43
Over Red
The Santa MariaReviewed in 2024PraiseSuited to casual outings like running errands.
“this is a casual outing it's very casual”Watch at 9:04
The Santa MariaReviewed in 2024PraiseWearable any time of day and any time of year.
“this is anytime day or night and any time of year”Watch at 9:10
compliments
EDP
Soki LondonReviewed in 2025PraiseA flight attendant asked what she was wearing.
“I could smell this perfume and I said what are you wearing”Watch at 1:29
Over Red
The Santa MariaReviewed in 2024PraiseReceived many compliments from a wide range of people.
“I got a ton of compliments from a lot of different people”Watch at 11:02