Carolina Herrera Good Girl: EDP or Suprême?
Of the 3 reviewers who compared both, 1 pick the EDP and 2 pick the Suprême.

Carolina Herrera Good Girl Eau de Parfum
A sweet, creamy, sexy floral with strong presence. Most reviewers place it in the evening, and opinions on projection and everyday wear differ.
3 of 8 reviewers who compared it pick this version.
Reviewers smell: jasmine, vanilla, almond, tonka, tuberose, cocoa, creamy, orange blossom
Picked by Jeremy Fragrance, The Glow Quest, Emerald Sea
Carolina Herrera Good Girl Suprême
Described as a softer, sweeter, candier daytime version of the original, with a juicy berry note up front.
2 of 3 reviewers who compared it pick this version.
Reviewers smell: almond, berries, berry, candy, creamy, cupcake, fruitier, jasmine
Picked by The Gossip Closet, SimplyShaughnessy
How they compare
| What reviewers say | EDP | Suprême |
|---|---|---|
| scent | Mixed7 praise, 3 criticise | Mostly praised3 praise |
| longevity | Mostly praised5 praise | Mostly praised2 praise |
| projection | Mixed2 praise, 3 criticise | One comment0 praise, 1 criticise |
| occasion | Mostly praised5 praise | Mostly praised2 praise |
| value | One comment1 praise | No comment |
| compliments | Mixed2 praise, 1 criticise | One comment1 praise |
overall
EDP
Soki LondonReviewed in 2025PraiseGood fragrance that lasts, sexy and wearable and modern.
“it is a good fragrance it lasts”Watch at 3:43
Jus de RoseReviewed in 2022PraiseRecommends the original Good Girl to women who like sweeter, creamier scents.
“and I would recommend good girl the OD”Watch at 3:35
Jeremy FragranceReviewed in 2020PraiseReviewer rates it 8 out of 10 as a very good fragrance.
“I give this one an 8 out of 10”Watch at 3:40
Suprême
The Gossip ClosetReviewed in 2024PraiseSays no other Good Girl release has matched this one as her favorite.
“none of them have been able to top this one”Watch at 21:38
The Gossip ClosetReviewed in 2024PraiseSays the perfume makes her feel very confident.
“feel very very confident”Watch at 22:08
SimplyShaughnessyReviewed in 2020PraiseReviewer says she really loves Supreme and loves wearing it.
“i really love this i love wearing it”Watch at 13:09
scent
EDP
Soki LondonReviewed in 2025PraiseStrong white florals over sweet vanilla and warm tonka base.
“loads of white florals Jasmine Orange Blossom tuberose strong”Watch at 3:18
Jus de RoseReviewed in 2022PraiseDescribes the original as the most opulent, creamy, and rich in the range.
“it is the most opulent creamy and Rich fragrance out of the entire range”Watch at 2:22
Jus de RoseReviewed in 2022CriticismOriginal can be too intoxicating, thick, and dense for some wearers. (if you find it too intoxicating)
“you find it to be too intoxicating too thick and dense”Watch at 3:42
Suprême
The Gossip ClosetReviewed in 2024PraiseSays it smells so good, and she is obsessed with it.
“it's just smells so so freaking good”Watch at 23:11
The Gossip ClosetReviewed in 2024MixedSays the scent doesn't match the listed notes, though she still loves it.
“the scent that I'm getting out of this perfume doesn't match the notes”Watch at 23:39
SimplyShaughnessyReviewed in 2020PraiseReviewer says the berries stand out strongly when Supreme is first sprayed.
“you really get a burst of berries when you first spray this”Watch at 7:58
longevity
EDP
Jus de RoseReviewed in 2022PraiseSays the range lasts about 12 hours on her skin, which she finds phenomenal. (on my skin)
“these fragrances last around 12 hours plus which is phenomenal”Watch at 1:20
Jeremy FragranceReviewed in 2020PraiseReviewer says it is long lasting and perfectly versatile.
“it's long lasting so it's perfectly versatile”Watch at 0:51
Jeremy FragranceReviewed in 2020PraiseReviewer says its performance is very good, lasting well for a sweet scent.
“the performance of this is very good”Watch at 1:30
Suprême
SimplyShaughnessyReviewed in 2020PraiseSupreme lasted eight hours on her skin.
“it lasted eight hours on my skin”Watch at 7:41
The Glow QuestReviewed in 2025PraiseLasts six to eight hours on clothes and skin.
“All of these variants easily last for 6 to 8 hours on your clothes and on your body”Watch at 0:38
projection
EDP
Soki LondonReviewed in 2025PraiseLasts well and projects strongly.
“it lasts IT projects”Watch at 3:43
The Gossip ClosetReviewed in 2024CriticismVery strong, so she doesn't reach for it for everyday wear. (not for everyday wear)
“it's just a really really strong scent it's not a everyday wear”Watch at 2:22
SimplyShaughnessyReviewed in 2020CriticismThe original doesn't project well on her skin, though she notes others say it does. (on her skin)
“on me it doesn't project well it doesn't”Watch at 3:53
Suprême
The Glow QuestReviewed in 2025CriticismProjection is too loud; people will notice it.
“or projection is too loud. People will notice”Watch at 0:47
occasion
EDP
Soki LondonReviewed in 2025PraiseQuite an evening fragrance.
“would say quite evening fragrance”Watch at 3:16
Jus de RoseReviewed in 2022PraiseCalls the original an ultimate clubbing or evening scent.
“this is your ultimate clubbing scent or evening scent”Watch at 2:42
The Gossip ClosetReviewed in 2024PraiseSuits special occasions, like a date night or a wedding. (for special occasions)
“perfumes perfect for special occasions”Watch at 3:12
Suprême
SimplyShaughnessyReviewed in 2020PraiseReviewer calls Supreme the daytime version of the original, softer and less intense. (daytime)
“like i said the day version of the original good girl”Watch at 10:55
The Glow QuestReviewed in 2025PraiseSuited to day wear and spring wear. (for day or spring wear)
“perfect for day wear or spring wear”Watch at 2:39
compliments
EDP
Jeremy FragranceReviewed in 2020PraiseReviewer says it draws compliments; they received compliments on it.
“it's a compliment magnet”Watch at 3:05
SimplyShaughnessyReviewed in 2020CriticismShe has never received a compliment while wearing the original.
“i've never received a compliment from wearing this fragrance”Watch at 3:44
The Glow QuestReviewed in 2025PraiseReports receiving many compliments while wearing it.
“I've got many compliments on this one”Watch at 1:45
Suprême
SimplyShaughnessyReviewed in 2020PraiseSupreme earned her a compliment, unlike the original.
“i did receive compliment a compliment when i was”Watch at 7:44