Jean Paul Gaultier Le Male: EDT or Elixir?

Of the 5 reviewers who compared both, 0 pick the EDT and 1 pick the Elixir; 4 prefer another version or name none.

Jean Paul Gaultier Le Male Eau de Toilette

Jean Paul Gaultier Le Male Eau de Toilette

The original: fresh, clean vanilla with lavender, easy and affordable, but several reviewers find it dated or dull.

0 of 5 reviewers who compared it pick this version. Bottle $69.

springsummerfallwinterdaynighteveryday

Reviewers smell: lavender, vanilla, mint, barbershop, powdery, sweet, aquatic, clean

Jean Paul Gaultier Le Male Elixir

Jean Paul Gaultier Le Male Elixir

Sweeter, stronger and bolder than Le Parfum, with honey, tobacco and vanilla. Reviewers split on whether it beats Le Parfum.

1 of 9 reviewers who compared it pick this version.

fallwinterdaynightnight out

Reviewers smell: honey, lavender, tobacco, mint, vanilla, sweet, benzoin, tonka bean

Picked by Gents Scents

How they compare

What reviewers sayEDTElixir
scentMostly praised3 praise, 1 criticiseMixed7 praise, 4 criticise
longevityNo commentMostly praised2 praise
projectionNo commentMixed4 praise, 2 criticise
occasionMostly praised2 praiseMostly praised5 praise
valueMostly praised2 praiseOne comment0 praise, 1 criticise
complimentsOne comment1 praiseMostly praised3 praise

overall

EDT

Gents ScentsReviewed in 2025Mixed

Much younger guys may prefer the later releases over it. (for much younger guys)

“much younger guys may not go for it quite as much as some of the other fragrances that have come after it”
Watch at 3:47
Eau D' EricaReviewed in 2023Criticism

She respects it but it sits just outside what she loves on a man. (for her taste)

“the mall is just a little right outside of what I really love in a fragrance on a man”
Watch at 6:41
Chad SecretsReviewed in 2024Praise

Credits the original with reinventing fragrances.

“the original lamalan itself reinvented fragrances as we know it”
Watch at 1:50

Elixir

Gents ScentsReviewed in 2025Mixed

Similar enough to Le Parfum that owning both is redundant for some people. (if you already own Le Parfum)

“for some people, it's going to be redundant to own this if you own this and vice versa”
Watch at 11:33
Gents ScentsReviewed in 2025Praise

He rates it slightly above Le Parfum, though opinions are split. (to his own taste)

“to my own taste, Elixir is just a touch better”
Watch at 11:46
Eau D' EricaReviewed in 2023Mixed

Not a bad perfume, but she doesn't think it deserves the hype it has received.

“not a bad perfume do I think that it deserves the amount of hype that it's gotten not necessarily”
Watch at 1:04

scent

EDT

Gents ScentsReviewed in 2025Praise

A mix of fresh, clean and sweet, with a slightly powdery vanilla.

“It's a mix of fresh, clean, and sweet. The vanilla comes across a little bit powdery”
Watch at 2:30
Gents ScentsReviewed in 2025Criticism

Some people will find it smells a bit dated after 30 years.

“some people are going to think that it smells a little bit dated”
Watch at 3:16
Gents ScentsReviewed in 2025Praise

Comes across as a semi barbershop vanilla scent with a classy edge.

“It also comes across as like a semi barbershop vanilla fragrance to an extent”
Watch at 3:05

Elixir

Hamza SaabReviewed in 2024Praise

Has a sweet honey and tobacco character.

“Lal Elixir which is going to have a sweet honey tobacco vibe”
Watch at 3:08
Hamza SaabReviewed in 2024Criticism

Two women passed on it for being a little too sweet. (according to women asked)

“it's like more subtle that's a little too sweet little too sweet”
Watch at 7:44
Hamza SaabReviewed in 2024Mixed

Warm and sweet, which one woman felt leans slightly feminine. (according to women asked)

“it's more warm and sweet”
Watch at 18:17

longevity

EDT

FBFragrancesReviewed in 2024Mixed

Longevity is average.

“Projection, longevity is average”
Watch at 2:05

Elixir

Eau D' EricaReviewed in 2023Mixed

Performance is only moderate; she never got more than about eight hours.

“it's not a beast by any means I definitely never got more than like eight hours wearing this”
Watch at 2:54
Monika ColognesReviewed in 2023Praise

Lasts eight hours or more with good projection, same as Le Parfum.

“they're both eight hours plus, very nice projection”
Watch at 2:27
Sandra Solomon FragranceReviewed in 2023Praise

Performance is similar to Le Parfum; lasts on skin and clothes for quite some time.

“but it's not overpowering and it stays on your skin and on your clothes for quite some time.”
Watch at 1:50

projection

EDT

FBFragrancesReviewed in 2024Mixed

Projection is average.

“Projection, longevity is average”
Watch at 2:05

Elixir

Hamza SaabReviewed in 2024Praise

A stronger concentration and the latest version in the line.

“so the Elixir is going to be like a stronger concentration kind of the latest version of this fragrance”
Watch at 10:04
Hamza SaabReviewed in 2024Praise

Smells a bit stronger on the strip, which the reviewer agrees with.

“it just smells A Little Bit Stronger smells A Little Bit Stronger absolutely”
Watch at 15:48
Eau D' EricaReviewed in 2023Criticism

Projection is very soft and stays close to the skin. (in her testing, on her and on other people)

“projection on it is very soft at least for me in my testing”
Watch at 3:00

occasion

EDT

Gents ScentsReviewed in 2025Praise

Very easy to wear, works year round, day or night.

“It's super easy to wear. You can pull it off pretty much year round, daytime or nighttime”
Watch at 2:37
Chilled FragrancesReviewed in 2026Praise

A way to wear vanilla in summer; it can be worn all year. (in summer)

“it's a way of wearing vanilla in the summer”
Watch at 1:05

Elixir

Gents ScentsReviewed in 2025Praise

More of a fall and winter fragrance, day or evening, with good performance.

“Also more of a fall wintertime fragrance, daytime or evening, and good performance as well”
Watch at 11:54
Monika ColognesReviewed in 2023Praise

Good for clubbing and cold winter weather. (going out or in cold weather)

“It's a very nice clubbing fragrance, or like if it's a bit cold out, like winter, this is a perfect fragrance”
Watch at 3:21
Monika ColognesReviewed in 2023Mixed

More of a special occasion, fall and winter scent than an all-year one.

“whereas this one could be a special occasion fragrance, your fall winter fragrance.”
Watch at 4:16

value

EDT

Gents ScentsReviewed in 2025Praise

Still performs and is one of the most affordable in the line.

“It still performs and it's one of the most affordable in the whole line”
Watch at 3:52
FBFragrancesReviewed in 2024Praise

The most affordable of the line, a good option on a tight budget. (if you are on a tight budget)

“It is the most affordable though so if you want a Jean-Paul Gaultier fragrance but you're”
Watch at 2:07

Elixir

Eau D' EricaReviewed in 2023Criticism

Costs almost as much as Naxos, so it isn't an affordable substitute.

“which by the way it's not even that much less money than Nexus”
Watch at 10:03

compliments

EDT

Gents ScentsReviewed in 2025Praise

Still reliably gets compliments.

“Still a solid compliment puller”
Watch at 3:28

Elixir

Hamza SaabReviewed in 2024Mixed

Lost the poll narrowly; votes kept swinging and it could have been a tie. (in a blind strip test with women)

“honestly guys this could have been a tie they kept going back and forth”
Watch at 18:40
Hamza SaabReviewed in 2024Praise

Some women preferred it because it came across as more intense.

“some women like this one more because it was more intense”
Watch at 18:56
Eau D' EricaReviewed in 2023Praise

Women love the scent profile, though she rates Ultra Male higher for attention.

“yes women love the scent profile of lamal Elixir”
Watch at 8:07

See every Jean Paul Gaultier Le Male version