Montblanc Explorer: EDP or Extreme?

Of the 4 reviewers who compared both, 0 pick the EDP and 3 pick the Extreme; 1 prefer another version or name none.

Montblanc Explorer Eau de Parfum

Montblanc Explorer Eau de Parfum

The original Explorer, called versatile and approachable with a citrusy, woody Aventus-style scent. One reviewer found it boring and another found it weak.

2 of 8 reviewers who compared it pick this version. Bottle $31.

springsummerfallwinterofficedate nighteveryday

Reviewers smell: fresh, bergamot, bold, citrusy, leathery, masculine, woodsy

Picked by Gents Scents, Chaos Fragrances

Montblanc Explorer Extreme

Montblanc Explorer Extreme

Described as a bolder, darker, richer Explorer, a mix of Aventus Absolu and Sauvage Elixir. One reviewer found it cheap and flat.

3 of 4 reviewers who compared it pick this version. Bottle $50.

springfallwinternightofficedate nightnight out

Reviewers smell: bergamot, dark, earthy, pineapple, bold, cheap, citrus creamsicle, coffee grounds

Picked by Mr Couts The Fragrance Guy, Chad Secrets, Cubaknow

How they compare

What reviewers sayEDPExtreme
scentMixed3 praise, 2 criticiseMostly praised4 praise, 1 criticise
longevityMixed1 praise, 1 criticiseOne comment1 praise
projectionMostly criticised0 praise, 2 criticiseMixed1 praise, 1 criticise
occasionMostly praised4 praiseMixed2 praise, 1 criticise
valueMixed3 praise, 2 criticiseMixed2 praise, 1 criticise
complimentsMixed1 praise, 1 criticiseMostly praised2 praise

overall

EDP

Gents ScentsReviewed in 2023Praise

The original remains his favorite of the Explorer line, ahead of Platinum.

“the original Explorer still is going to be my favorite at this point”
Watch at 10:39
Mr Couts The Fragrance GuyReviewed in 2026Praise

Strongly recommended as an everyday fragrance. (as an everyday driver)

“It's one of the ones that I strongly recommend that anybody get for their everyday driver.”
Watch at 2:01
Mr Couts The Fragrance GuyReviewed in 2026Mixed

Ranked third of the four, behind Extreme and Platinum.

“Now, the OG is definitely the one that I'm gonna go with next.”
Watch at 11:00

Extreme

Mr Couts The Fragrance GuyReviewed in 2026Praise

His favorite and number one of the whole Explorer line.

“This one is definitely my favorite out of the whole collection.”
Watch at 7:24
Chad SecretsReviewed in 2026Praise

Calls it a fantastic new release and rates it 8.75 out of 10.

“I think this is a fantastic new release.”
Watch at 7:58
Chad SecretsReviewed in 2026Criticism

Loses points for creativity because it does nothing new.

“it's not really doing anything new”
Watch at 6:08

scent

EDP

Hamza SaabReviewed in 2026Mixed

The original Explorer is essentially a reinterpretation of Creed Aventus.

“The original is a reinterpretation on Creed Aventus,”
Watch at 14:01
Mr Couts The Fragrance GuyReviewed in 2026Praise

Smells woody, masculine and bold.

“This is very woodsy, very masculine, very, very bold.”
Watch at 1:17
Chad SecretsReviewed in 2026Mixed

The original is a fresher, more leathery twist on Creed Aventus with sharp bergamot instead of pineapple.

“the original Mambla Explorer is kind of like a twist on Creeds Aventus”
Watch at 2:13

Extreme

Mr Couts The Fragrance GuyReviewed in 2026Praise

Bolder, richer and darker than the others in the line.

“It's bolder, it's richer, it's darker.”
Watch at 9:34
Chad SecretsReviewed in 2026Praise

Smells like a hybrid of Creed Aventus Absolu and Dior Sauvage Elixir, and it works well.

“Creed Aventus Absolute and Dior Savage Elixir. And in my opinion, it works very very well”
Watch at 4:13
Chad SecretsReviewed in 2026Praise

Opens fresher and cleaner, then dries down into a dry, spicy, sweet scent.

“it starts fresher, cleaner, and then kind of dries down into this like charismatic boss-like like aggressive dry spicy sweet fragrance”
Watch at 7:31

longevity

EDP

Mr Couts The Fragrance GuyReviewed in 2026Praise

Lasts around seven to eight hours or more in total.

“maybe seven to eight hours plus out of this.”
Watch at 2:31
HonestReviewsReviewed in 2025Criticism

Weak longevity, only a few hours on skin.

“so both have weak longevity”
Watch at 2:11

Extreme

Chad SecretsReviewed in 2026Praise

Lasts around 12 to 15 hours. (on his skin)

“But you get around 12 to 15 hours”
Watch at 5:37

projection

EDP

Mr Couts The Fragrance GuyReviewed in 2026Mixed

Projects noticeably for three to five hours, then becomes a skin scent. (without layering)

“You're gonna get like three for maybe five hours of like strong, like where people can actually be able to smell you”
Watch at 2:17
HonestReviewsReviewed in 2025Criticism

Weak performance; projection fades within an hour at most.

“so both have weak performance”
Watch at 2:41
Eau D' EricaReviewed in 2025Criticism

The original was a letdown and she could barely smell it, unlike Extreme. (for her)

“It's literally just as much of a letown as the original Explorer for me, but at least I can actually smell this one”
Watch at 8:05

Extreme

Chad SecretsReviewed in 2026Praise

Projects very strongly in the first hour.

“the first hour is super super strong”
Watch at 6:46
Chad SecretsReviewed in 2026Praise

Settles to about two feet of projection with a good trail for 8 to 10 hours. (after the first hour or two)

“it kind of backs down to like a twoft projector, still giving you a good trail”
Watch at 6:52
Chad SecretsReviewed in 2026Mixed

Not the strongest projector once it reaches the dry down.

“it's not the highest projector towards the dry down”
Watch at 5:33

occasion

EDP

Gents ScentsReviewed in 2023Praise

He finds it highly versatile, usable and approachable.

“the versatility is huge”
Watch at 3:25
Mr Couts The Fragrance GuyReviewed in 2026Praise

Versatile enough for the office, church, date night or any occasion.

“to the office, you can wear out to any occasion, church, date night, it's very versatile”
Watch at 0:57
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2023Praise

Says the original is very versatile.

“really nice one great versatility”
Watch at 0:25

Extreme

Mr Couts The Fragrance GuyReviewed in 2026Praise

Can be worn to the office but best for date nights, clubbing and going out. (especially for single guys going out)

“you could wear it to an office, but if my recommendation, it's gonna be date night.”
Watch at 9:46
Chad SecretsReviewed in 2026Praise

Wearable year round but best suited to spring, fall and winter.

“I think it does favor kind of like spring, fall, and more winter type of vibes for me”
Watch at 5:12
Chad SecretsReviewed in 2026Criticism

Strong and potent enough to become cloying in hot weather. (in high summer heat)

“It's very strong. It's very potent and can be a little bit cloying in the high heat.”
Watch at 5:24

value

EDP

Gents ScentsReviewed in 2023Criticism

At launch he could not recommend it at full retail because cheaper fragrances did something similar. (at full retail)

“at full retail there are so many other fragrances out there for a much lower price”
Watch at 3:08
Gents ScentsReviewed in 2023Praise

Now that discounter prices have dropped a lot, he considers it a fantastic buy. (at discounter prices)

“now I think it's a fantastic buy for the price you can pick this up at”
Watch at 3:21
Mr Couts The Fragrance GuyReviewed in 2026Praise

A budget option for anyone who does not want to pay Creed Aventus prices. (if you don't want to spend $500)

“if you're not looking to spend $500, this would be one of the ones you can go with.”
Watch at 1:55

Extreme

Chad SecretsReviewed in 2026Praise

Found it for about $99 Canadian for 100 ml, which he considers very cheap for a new release. (at discounter prices)

“I found it for around $99 Canadian for 100 ml, which is actually insane considering this is a new release”
Watch at 1:18
Chad SecretsReviewed in 2026Praise

Expects it to be one of the best buys once the price drops. (when it comes down in price)

“it's going to be probably one of the best fragrances you can buy”
Watch at 8:04
CubaknowReviewed in 2026Praise

A solid fragrance under $60 that he will keep in rotation.

“100% gonna be a rotation a solid solid fragrance under $60”
Watch at 3:36

compliments

EDP

Gents ScentsReviewed in 2023Praise

He thinks the original likely gets more compliments than Platinum for most people.

“the original Explorer probably has a little more of a compliment factor for most people”
Watch at 10:49
HonestReviewsReviewed in 2025Criticism

Got him no compliments.

“none of them got me compliments”
Watch at 3:06

Extreme

Mr Couts The Fragrance GuyReviewed in 2026Praise

Expects it to get a lot of compliments.

“you get gonna get so many compliments on this.”
Watch at 8:56
CubaknowReviewed in 2026Praise

Recommended for a small, easy-to-wear, compliment-getting collection, especially on a budget. (if you're on a budget)

“Compliment grabbing possibly easy to wear dumb reach fragrance collection should have especially if you're on a budget”
Watch at 4:37

See every Montblanc Explorer version