Acqua di Gio: EDT or Profondo?
Of the 6 reviewers who compared both, 2 pick the EDT and 1 pick the Profondo; 3 prefer another version or name none.

Acqua di Gio Eau de Toilette
Citrus-heavy, clean aquatic original; reviewers call it a classic that is easy to wear, though performance is moderate to weak.
2 of 6 reviewers who compared it pick this version. Bottle $62.
Reviewers smell: aquatic, citrus, fresh, aromatic, clean, green, bergamot, bright
Picked by Top Notes, Reviews_and_more

Acqua di Gio Profondo
Marine, mineral and aromatic, with rosemary and less citrus than the original; reviewers disagree on how it ranks, some calling it their favorite.
2 of 8 reviewers who compared it pick this version.
Reviewers smell: mineral, aromatic, lavender, rosemary, sweet, aquatic, citrus, cypress
Picked by Hamza Saab, CurlyFragrance
How they compare
| What reviewers say | EDT | Profondo |
|---|---|---|
| scent | Mostly praised5 praise | Mostly praised6 praise, 1 criticise |
| longevity | One comment0 praise, 1 criticise | Mostly praised3 praise, 1 criticise |
| projection | No comment | Mostly praised4 praise, 1 criticise |
| occasion | Mostly praised3 praise | Mostly praised5 praise, 1 criticise |
| value | Mostly praised2 praise | No comment |
| compliments | Mixed1 praise, 1 criticise | One comment1 praise |
overall
EDT
TLTG ReviewsReviewed in 2023PraiseCalls the original timeless and says it still smells great.
“it's timeless it still smells great”Watch at 1:55
TLTG ReviewsReviewed in 2023CriticismHe likes every later version of the line better than the original.
“every version that's come after including profondo profondo lights absolute absolute Instinct and so on I like all of them better”Watch at 11:57
Gents ScentsReviewed in 2025MixedHe would rather wear most of the newer ones, despite strong nostalgia for the original EDT. (original version)
“I would rather wear most of those than this one even though this one has a strong nostalgic part in my heart”Watch at 10:08
Profondo
Hamza SaabReviewed in 2024PraiseHis choice if keeping only one; he calls it the best current Acqua di Gio.
“to me today, this is currently the best Aqua digital.”Watch at 5:34
Gents ScentsReviewed in 2025PraiseHe loved the original Profondo on release as a great reworking of the Acqua di Gio DNA. (original version)
“I thought it was just absolutely fantastic a great reimagining of the aquae DNA”Watch at 13:47
Top NotesReviewed in 2024MixedStill good at about 8.5, but less notable than the original.
“notable than the other one not that aqua di geo profondo isn't good it's still maybe an 8.5 but”Watch at 4:02
scent
EDT
TLTG ReviewsReviewed in 2023PraiseTraditional cologne smell: aquatic, synthetic, fresh, with citrus and a lot of green freshness.
“it's aquatic it's synthetic it's fresh there's citruses there's a lot of green freshness to this fragrance”Watch at 1:34
Gents ScentsReviewed in 2025PraiseThe new EDT is sweeter and less floral, which makes it wear as a more modern fragrance. (new version)
“to me it also comes across as sweeter as well which does make it a better wearing modern contemporary fragrance”Watch at 12:51
Top NotesReviewed in 2024PraiseCitrus-heavy scent focused on lime, bergamot and mandarin orange with an aquatic, oceanic feel.
“but really this was mostly focusing on lime, bergamot, mandarin orange you know”Watch at 1:18
Profondo
TLTG ReviewsReviewed in 2023MixedExtremely synthetic but very oceanic; the bluest of the line.
“the blue bottle the extremely synthetic but very Oceanic The Bluest of them”Watch at 2:49
Hamza SaabReviewed in 2024PraiseSmells like a modernised version of the original EDT.
“aqua digital profando smells like the original aqua digital or a toilette,”Watch at 0:54
Hamza SaabReviewed in 2024PraiseMineral notes make it smell like the ocean.
“They included like mineral notes.”Watch at 0:59
longevity
EDT
TLTG ReviewsReviewed in 2023MixedHe gets about six hours, though he notes some people report only two. (on his skin)
“I still get every bit of six hours easily on my skin some people will say two hours”Watch at 5:55
Gents ScentsReviewed in 2025CriticismThe original EDT generally performs weaker than everything else in the lineup. (original version)
“performance is generally going to be lower with the original Aqua Deo Oda tolet here compared to everything else”Watch at 9:52
Profondo
Hamza SaabReviewed in 2024CriticismLasts only five or six hours, weaker than Parfum.
“The performance on this one is not as good as parfum.”Watch at 4:52
CurlyFragranceReviewed in 2022PraiseLasts 8 to 10 hours in his experience.
“i know how long this one lasts and it is 8 to 10 hours”Watch at 6:02
Pure Scent ClubReviewed in 2025PraiseThe EDP lasts longer than the EDT. (Profondo EDP 2020 vs Profondo EDT)
“parfam is longerlasting”Watch at 3:04
projection
EDT
TLTG ReviewsReviewed in 2023MixedProjection is arm's reach, moderate to average.
“projection is on the Arms Reach moderate average type of side”Watch at 6:58
Reviews_and_moreReviewed in 2025MixedSits closer to the skin; people need to be near you to smell it.
“This one's a little more intimate, a little more close like you got to hug somebody to smell it on them”Watch at 4:50
Profondo
Hamza SaabReviewed in 2024PraiseProjects nicely when it is very hot and a breeze catches it. (when running outside in high heat)
“hot, it just has like this really nice projection.”Watch at 2:46
CurlyFragranceReviewed in 2022PraiseProjects the same as the EDP. (two hours after spraying)
“the projection of both of them is the same”Watch at 5:52
Pure Scent ClubReviewed in 2025PraiseThe EDP projects better than the EDT after the first hour. (Profondo EDP 2020 vs Profondo EDT)
“it projects better after the first hour”Watch at 3:04
occasion
EDT
TLTG ReviewsReviewed in 2023PraiseBest as a spring and summer daytime scent; safe for work.
“this is more of a spring to summer fragrance daytime wear obviously a safe wear to work”Watch at 8:55
Top NotesReviewed in 2024PraiseCitrus-heavy fragrance that suits summer best. (in summer)
“Amazing citrus heavy fragrance perfect for summer”Watch at 1:33
Top NotesReviewed in 2024PraiseAnyone can wear it, especially in summer. (especially in the summer)
“I think this is a great fragrance that anybody could paw off especially in the summer though”Watch at 2:02
Profondo
Hamza SaabReviewed in 2024PraiseVersatile, but at its best in hot summer weather. (in 80-90 degree heat)
“Aqua digital profando shines a little bit more in the”Watch at 2:31
Gents ScentsReviewed in 2025PraiseWears like an Acqua di Gio with some of the versatility of a blue fragrance. (original version)
“it's almost like they made an aqua Deo here with a little bit of a blue fragrance versatility”Watch at 14:15
Top NotesReviewed in 2024PraiseThe better choice if you want something more versatile. (if you want more versatility)
“know summer vibe if you want something that's a little bit more versatile I would go with”Watch at 3:10
compliments
EDT
Gents ScentsReviewed in 2025PraiseThe original EDT is fresh, clean, easy to wear and gets compliments. (original version)
“still very fresh clean easy to wear big compliment puller”Watch at 12:30
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2022CriticismMen enjoy it on themselves, but in his experience women do not react much. (in his experience)
“a lot of guys enjoy on themselves they feel it smells amazing but that's not the case with women”Watch at 8:22
Profondo
Hamza SaabReviewed in 2024PraiseGets far more positive reactions from women than Parfum, more than he expected.
“This one right here gets so much positive ladies”Watch at 5:12