Rotten Rebel
184K subscribers on YouTube. Counted in 14 comparisons.
Disclosed in video descriptions: nothing found.
Which versions Rotten Rebel picks
| Fragrance | Pick | In their words |
|---|---|---|
| Dior Sauvage2021 | Elixir | “if you're gonna have one fragrance in your collection like get this one” Watch at 14:34 |
| YSL Y2022 | EDP | “if i am going to choose one sorry perform i'm going with the edp i love it that much” Watch at 8:18 |
| YSL Y2026 | EDP | “I am going to say that the right now Y Eau de Parfum secures first place” Watch at 15:49 |
| Armani Stronger With You2022 | Absolutely | “if i am going to choose one um yeah i'm still leaning towards absolutely” Watch at 8:31 |
| Versace Eros2022 | EDP | “i am actually going to go with the edp i think so” Watch at 10:54 |
| Parfums de Marly Layton2021 | Layton | “if i had to choose one i would definitely choose layton” Watch at 4:59 |
| Club de Nuit Intense Man2022 | EDP | “if I had to choose between the two, I'd go with Club de Nuit Intense Man EDP” Watch at 3:37 |
| Club de Nuit Intense Man2022 | Limited Edition | “I prefer limited edition so I'm going to put a limited edition on number one EDP number two and the EDT on number three” Watch at 9:30 |
| Acqua di Gio2022 | EDP | “between these two i am definitely going to choose the edp” Watch at 12:14 |
| Paco Rabanne Invictus2023 | Victory Elixir | “the new Invictus Victor Elixir just feels more exciting” Watch at 14:59 |
| Dior Homme2026 | None named | Watch the video |
| Boss Bottled2025 | Elixir | “Boss bottle elixir is my favorite. It's easier to wear compared to the richness of Absolute.” Watch at 8:36 |
| Armani Code2024 | Parfum | “code perform is my absolute favorite out of these three” Watch at 7:29 |
| Valentino Uomo Born in Roma2025 | None named | Watch the video |
On Dior Sauvage
Compare all Dior Sauvage versions
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2021CriticismIts only real flaw is that it has become too common.
“nowadays i think it's a bit too common and that's pretty much the only bad thing i can say about it”Watch at 2:28
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2021MixedA stunning scent but overdone; rated about 8 to 8.5 out of 10.
“it is a quite a stunning kind of scent but it's a bit overdone”Watch at 4:04
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2021PraiseVery likable; hard to find someone who dislikes it.
“it's going to be hard for you to find someone who doesn't like this one”Watch at 6:11
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2021MixedBetter than the EDT but still not perfect; rated around 9 out of 10.
“it's better than the original it's still not perfection but it's really good”Watch at 6:44
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2021CriticismLacks the bright peppery opening that the EDT and EDP have.
“i'm really missing that sort of a bright peppery kind of opening that both the edp and the original has”Watch at 8:28
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2021MixedSmooth, sweet and mass appealing, similar to many other perfumes with a Sauvage twist.
“which makes it sort of like a lot of the other perfumes out there but with that sort of a salvage twist to it”Watch at 9:01
On YSL Y
Compare all YSL Y versions
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2022PraiseFinds the EDP more layered and more exciting than Le Parfum. (to his nose)
“the edp has more layers to it it's more exciting at least to me”Watch at 8:11
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2022MixedOpening is still bright but less bright and less fresh than the EDP. (opening)
“it's still bright but it's not as bright as the edp and it doesn't come across as as fresh as that one”Watch at 3:37
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2022MixedThinks tonka gives the dry down a creaminess that the EDP does not have. (dry down)
“maybe it's a tonka blend that gives it that sort of creaminess”Watch at 5:56
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2022MixedNoticeably less woody than the EDP in the dry down. (to his nose)
“the perform is way less woody than the edp”Watch at 6:32
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2022CriticismFinds it flatter, lacking the different sides that make the EDP attractive. (to him)
“the perfume to me is a bit more flat almost it doesn't have all these different size that i find is so attractive about the edp”Watch at 6:47
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2022MixedSmoother than the EDP in both the opening and the dry down.
“now when it comes to dry down same thing perform is way more smooth”Watch at 7:55
On YSL Y
Compare all YSL Y versions
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2026MixedRanks the original EDT seventh of ten but calls it underrated. (original 2017 version)
“The OG Y EDT takes seventh place. I think it's so underrated”Watch at 13:33
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2026PraiseRanks it first; finds it slightly more addictive than the 2022 EDT.
“it's slightly more addictive”Watch at 15:56
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2026MixedThe 2025 version is not groundbreaking and may feel too similar to earlier releases. (2025 version)
“definitely not groundbreaking in any way”Watch at 9:41
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2026CriticismHis least favorite of the line; mostly lavender and lacking excitement.
“I do feel Y Elixir lacks a bit of excitement”Watch at 13:15
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2026CriticismDoes not deliver the promised oud or deep woody character.
“I also feel it fails to deliver on the precious oud”Watch at 8:43
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2026CriticismYou are mostly paying for lavender; more exciting lavender scents cost less.
“you can get more exciting lavender focused scents for less than that what you pay for”Watch at 8:51
On Armani Stronger With You
Compare all Armani Stronger With You versions
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2022PraisePeople who dislike very sweet scents may prefer it over Intensely. (for people less inclined to super sweet scents)
“less inclined to super sweet scents might actually prefer absolutely over intensely”Watch at 5:53
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2022PraiseFeels better made than Intensely to him.
“this one feels a bit more well made to me”Watch at 8:17
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2022PraiseThe guest calls it one of the best, or the best, in the Stronger With You line.
“one of the best or the best and the stronger with you line”Watch at 8:53
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2022PraiseHe loves it and used up a whole bottle quickly.
“i also love intensely and i burn through a bottle of intensely really really fast”Watch at 0:42
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2022MixedIn the dry down the sweetness fades, leaving more lavender and a fresher spiciness. (in the dry down)
“more of the lavender and less of that sweetness that i really enjoyed in the opening”Watch at 4:47
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2022MixedStill a great blend, but fuzzier and more vibrant than Absolutely.
“but it's a bit more fuzzy and vibrant”Watch at 5:20
On Versace Eros
Compare all Versace Eros versions
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2022MixedA great fresh scent, but he wanted a little more sweetness. (in the opening)
“i would have hoped for a little bit more sweetness”Watch at 1:27
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2022MixedThe brightest of the three, and also the least complex.
“the edt to me feels a bit like the brightest version of them all and sort of the the least complex”Watch at 8:01
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2022PraiseHe expected to be tired of it, but it still holds up against the newer versions.
“even though it's the oldest of them all it's still really really nice”Watch at 10:43
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2022MixedMore nuanced, luxurious and well made than the EDT, but a bit less bright.
“it feels a bit more luxurious and well made and a bit less bright”Watch at 8:18
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2022PraiseThe one he would keep, because it blends the other two and offers a bit of everything. (if he could only keep one)
“i think i'm going to go with the edp because it actually feels like the blend between these two so i'm getting a bit of everything in that one”Watch at 12:41
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2022MixedHe loves the opening, but side by side he prefers the EDP's opening. (in the opening)
“i love the opening on this one but now when i compare them i actually lean towards the edp as well”Watch at 5:13
On Parfums de Marly Layton
Compare all Parfums de Marly Layton versions
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2021PraiseScored it 9.5 in his own review.
“i gave layton a nine and a half in my review”Watch at 1:20
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2021PraiseLoved it immediately, from the first sniff.
“layton i i loved it from the get-go from my first sniff”Watch at 4:20
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2021MixedOpening is similar to Layton, with pepper and citrus, but not identical.
“opens up in a similar way to layton with a spicy blend of pepper and citrus”Watch at 1:39
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2021MixedDries down spicier and woodier than Layton.
“it dries down into something that is definitely more spicy more woody”Watch at 1:52
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2021MixedOnly slightly sweet; far less sweet than Layton.
“not nowhere near the same level of sweetness as layton”Watch at 2:04
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2021MixedA darker, rawer take on Layton.
“is sort of a darker more raw version of leyton”Watch at 2:12
On Club de Nuit Intense Man
Compare all Club de Nuit Intense Man versions
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2022CriticismOpening is a heavy overdose of smoky lemon and bergamot; not his favorite part. (in the opening)
“The opening is not my favorite part of it and it's this part that a lot of people think is too strong in a citrusy and smoky way”Watch at 0:54
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2022PraiseRecommended if you want a cheap Aventus-style scent and can tolerate the intense opening. (if you don't mind the intense smoky citrus opening)
“get the EDT. It's cheaper, it smells great”Watch at 4:00
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2022MixedHe will reach for it less, mainly when he wants a strong smoky citrus hit. (when he wants an overdose of smoky citrus)
“I will most likely turn to the EDT when I want an overdose of that smoky citrus”Watch at 4:31
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2022MixedCosts a bit more than the EDT; worth it if you want the smoother version. (if you don't mind spending a bit extra)
“don't mind spending a bit extra, then I would go with the EDP”Watch at 4:14
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2022PraiseSmoother, easier to wear and more mass-appealing than the EDT.
“the EDP is smoother and thus easier to wear and more mass-appealing”Watch at 3:24
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2022PraiseHe will wear the EDP far more often because he prefers its smoother scent.
“I will definitely use the EDP way more from now on since I enjoy its more smooth scent”Watch at 4:24
On Club de Nuit Intense Man
Compare all Club de Nuit Intense Man versions
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2022MixedOpening is citrusy and smoky; the birch can be too harsh for some people. (in the opening)
“the opening is sort of a citrusy smoky and that the Birch can be a bit too harsh for some people”Watch at 1:15
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2022MixedAgrees the opening is a bit harsh but does not think it is that bad. (in the opening)
“the opening is a bit harsh but I don't think it's that bad”Watch at 1:23
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2022MixedLoves the EDT and calls it a fantastic scent, but ranks it third of the three.
“in love with the EDT it's a fantastic scent”Watch at 9:14
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2022PraiseSmoother opening makes it more mass appealing and easier to wear and enjoy than the EDT.
“the opening of the EDP is much much smoother and thus much more mass appealing much easier to wear and much easier to enjoy”Watch at 3:37
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2022PraiseEssentially the EDT but much smoother and easier to wear and enjoy.
“this is basically like the EDT but much smoother and easier to wear and easier to enjoy”Watch at 4:22
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2022MixedConcedes the EDT has something that gets a bit lost in the other two, but still prefers it. (at least right now)
“this has something that's sort of a just a bit gets lost in these two but still I actually prefer at least right now I prefer limited edition”Watch at 9:22
On Acqua di Gio
Compare all Acqua di Gio versions
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2022MixedUnderstands its popularity and calls it really good, but it is not his style. (for his own taste)
“i understand why it's so popular because it is a really really good scent but it's just not my kind of really good scent”Watch at 2:08
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2022PraiseSmells better now than he had long remembered it.
“i gotta give it credit for actually being better than what i sort of almost always been thinking about it”Watch at 2:26
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2022PraiseStill thinks you cannot go wrong with it.
“i still don't think you can go wrong with it”Watch at 7:21
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2022CriticismMen enjoy it on themselves, but in his experience women do not react much. (in his experience)
“a lot of guys enjoy on themselves they feel it smells amazing but that's not the case with women”Watch at 8:22
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2022PraisePrefers the EDP, but says the EDT is a classic for a reason.
“the edt is a classic for a reason”Watch at 12:38
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2022PraiseArmani aimed for mass appeal done nicely and he thinks they achieved it.
“they wanted to make it really mass appealing in a really nice way and i believe they did just that”Watch at 5:44
On Paco Rabanne Invictus
Compare all Paco Rabanne Invictus versions
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2023MixedNot truly unique, but smells very good from the first spray.
“it might not blow me away with something truly unique but it definitely smells gorgeous straight away”Watch at 2:26
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2023PraiseFeels more exciting and more unique than the original Victory, and makes him feel better. (to his nose)
“more unique than the original Invictus Victory”Watch at 15:06
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2023MixedOpening is nice and pepper-heavy but feels more common than the Elixir's.
“the opening in this one definitely feels more common”Watch at 7:21
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2023MixedDry down is very mass appealing: mostly vanilla with soft spice.
“a big load of vanilla something that is spicy”Watch at 9:47
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2023CriticismThe vanilla-centric style is something he has smelled in other fragrances before.
“vanilla Centric scent is definitely something I've smelled in other sense before”Watch at 10:13
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2023PraiseHe is on his second bottle; very easy to wear and widely liked.
“this is my second bottle so I really really like this scent”Watch at 14:46
On Dior Homme
Compare all Dior Homme versions
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2026PraiseCalls it one of his fragrances for life.
“that's basically why both of these are my fragrances for life and why I absolutely love both”Watch at 4:05
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2026PraiseCalls it one of his fragrances for life.
“that's basically why both of these are my fragrances for life and why I absolutely love both”Watch at 4:05
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2026MixedIts powderiness is far more intense and dense than Dior Homme Original's.
“its powderness is nowhere near the intense and dense kind of powderness that you can find in Dior Intense Dior perfume”Watch at 3:05
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2026MixedIts powderiness is far more intense and dense than Dior Homme Original's.
“the intense and dense kind that you can find in both Dior Mint intense and Dior perfume”Watch at 1:36
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2026MixedLess versatile because it is so intensely powdery. (for people who want something more versatile)
“if you're someone who enjoys these two, but always wanted a more versatile version of these that are less intensely powdery”Watch at 8:12
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2026MixedLess versatile because it is so intensely powdery. (for people who want something more versatile)
“if you're someone who enjoys these two, but always wanted a more versatile version of these that are less intensely powdery”Watch at 8:12
On Boss Bottled
Compare all Boss Bottled versions
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2025MixedThe smoky incense is inconsistent; sometimes barely noticeable, sometimes clear.
“that smoky part of a boss bottle alexir behaves so differently from wearing to wearing”Watch at 1:55
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2025MixedHas a soft background sweetness but he does not consider it a sweet scent.
“I do not consider Boss Bottle Alexir a sweet scent”Watch at 2:54
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2025MixedHis first impression was that it was decent but lacked something. (first impressions over a year ago)
“I said it wasn't bad, but that it lacked something”Watch at 0:15
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2025PraiseIt has grown on him since he bought it.
“Boss Bottle Alex has definitely grown on me since I bought it”Watch at 3:22
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2025CriticismNot among the most mass-appealing fragrances; not ideal if you only buy crowd-pleasers.
“None of these two are at the very top when it comes to mass appeal”Watch at 5:55
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2025CriticismNot his first choice on a warm day. (on a warm day)
“Boss Bottle Lexzy is definitely not my first choice on a warm day”Watch at 6:34
On Armani Code
Compare all Armani Code versions
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2024PraiseRanks it first; finds it almost perfectly balanced between freshness, woodiness and vanilla.
“I think they pretty much nailed it with this release almost perfectly balanced with its freshness woodiness and vanilla”Watch at 7:21
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2024MixedRanks it third of the three, though says it is not bad and the dry down is nice.
“going to put the EDT on third place it's not bad the dry down is a nice one”Watch at 7:03
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2024PraiseRanks it second; its spicy vanilla and extra sweetness narrowly beat the EDT.
“code EDP and its spicy vanilla and its bigger dose of sexy sweetness slightly sort of edge out the Ed”Watch at 7:09
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2024CriticismNot a strong scent on him, though he notes others get great performance. (on his skin)
“code EDP 2024 on my skin is not a strong scent”Watch at 4:53
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2024MixedOverall performance is about average for him. (on his skin)
“skin this is somewhere around average or so”Watch at 5:02
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2024MixedPerformance feels similar to the new EDP, which he rates around average. (on his skin)
“the performance of the EDT does feel kind of similar to the new code EDP”Watch at 5:10
On Valentino Uomo Born in Roma
Compare all Valentino Uomo Born in Roma versions
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2025CriticismThe dry down remains his main complaint about the fragrance.
“My biggest issue though is still the dry down”Watch at 10:43
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2025CriticismIn the dry down it turns flat as the lavender loses its strength. (in the dry down)
“starts to get a bit sort of a flat when it starts to lose the potency”Watch at 11:04
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2025MixedCould be too sweet for people who dislike sweetness. (for people sensitive to sweetness)
“this can be a bit too sweet to some”Watch at 7:35
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2025MixedSmells closest to Intense, minus the vanilla.
“mostly similar to Bourne Roma intense but without the vanilla”Watch at 3:51
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2025MixedHe rates longevity and projection around 6.5 out of 10. (on his skin)
“performance of it around 6.5 for both projection and longevity”Watch at 5:39
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2025MixedAmong the stronger performers in the line, but not a beast-mode fragrance. (on his skin)
“I do not feel this is a beast mode like kind of performing fragrance”Watch at 5:59
This page reports what Rotten Rebel said in public videos. It is not written or endorsed by them. Quotes come from automatic transcripts; the timestamp links let you check. If you are Rotten Rebel and want a quote corrected or removed, write to us.