Scent Trail
35K subscribers on YouTube. Counted in 2 comparisons.
Disclosed in video descriptions: affiliate links, sponsored.
Which versions Scent Trail picks
| Fragrance | Pick | In their words |
|---|---|---|
| Parfums de Marly Layton2020 | None named | Watch the video |
| Terre d'Hermès2025 | EDT | “The original is an all year, you know, round fragrance, perfect if you just want to get one” Watch at 4:40 |
On Parfums de Marly Layton
Compare all Parfums de Marly Layton versions
Scent TrailReviewed in 2020MixedGoes in a different direction from Layton right after the top notes fade.
“this is where the fragrance starts going in a different direction for me”Watch at 6:18
Scent TrailReviewed in 2020MixedBy the dry down the original Layton profile is barely there. (to his nose)
“the dry down the original latent profile is barely there it is still there but”Watch at 8:18
Scent TrailReviewed in 2020MixedThe oud gives it a slight phenol smell, like freshly polished leather shoes.
“there's a little bit of a phenol smell to this fragrance”Watch at 9:12
Scent TrailReviewed in 2020MixedThe coffee note is hardly detectable; it does not smell like a coffee scent. (to his nose)
“but to my nose it's not a coffee scent”Watch at 9:43
Scent TrailReviewed in 2020CriticismNot deep, dark or smoky; more green and phenolic, so some will be disappointed. (if you expect a dark smoky oud)
“it is not deep dark and smoky at all you'll be disappointed if that's what you're looking for”Watch at 10:20
Scent TrailReviewed in 2020CriticismUnnecessary to buy unless you are a collector who enjoys small nuances. (if you already own Layton)
“then getting latent exclusive is superfluous really i think in my opinion”Watch at 10:42
On Terre d'Hermès
Compare all Terre d'Hermès versions
Scent TrailReviewed in 2025MixedVery little sweetness, which makes it lean more mature. (for younger wearers)
“The absence of sweetness for me puts it a little bit more on the mature side.”Watch at 1:47
Scent TrailReviewed in 2025PraiseStill widely worn almost 20 years on; he calls it timeless.
“wearing this original as it is a truly timeless fragrance”Watch at 2:03
Scent TrailReviewed in 2025MixedHe was unsure about it at launch and did not buy it then. (when it first came out in 2006)
“when the original came out, I wasn't sure how I felt about it.”Watch at 0:35
Scent TrailReviewed in 2025MixedLoses some of the original's freshness, replaced by spice and warm earthy moss.
“the Parfum version does lose a little bit of the freshness, you know, from the original as it replaces it with some spice and warm earthy moss notes”Watch at 3:04
Scent TrailReviewed in 2025MixedSmells very similar to the original; many people will not notice the differences.
“all in all, they smell very, very similar.”Watch at 3:26
Scent TrailReviewed in 2025PraiseHe liked it from the first smell and fell in love with it immediately.
“I smelled this one and immediately fell in love with it.”Watch at 5:36
This page reports what Scent Trail said in public videos. It is not written or endorsed by them. Quotes come from automatic transcripts; the timestamp links let you check. If you are Scent Trail and want a quote corrected or removed, write to us.