Fragrance versions for fall

Versions reviewers say suit fall, ordered by how many pick them. Ranked by reviewer counts across the fragrances we cover, not by a score of ours.

  1. 1Boss Bottled Elixir2 of 2 reviewers pick this versionA woody, spicy, smoky-incense version that reviewers call unique and niche-like. It is less mainstream, and one reviewer calls it the expensive one in the line.
  2. 2Paco Rabanne Invictus Victory Elixir5 of 6 reviewers pick this versionA sweet, vanilla-led, warm scent, louder than Victory, lasting about eight to ten hours. Some reviewers call it unoriginal, others rank it among the best Invictus.
  3. 3Bleu de Chanel Eau de Parfum6 of 8 reviewers pick this versionSeen as the balanced middle: fresh like the EDT with more depth, versatile across seasons, and the usual pick if buying one.
  4. 4Armani Stronger With You Absolutely6 of 8 reviewers pick this versionDescribed as smoother, boozier and more balanced than Intensely, with chestnut and vanilla; several reviewers rank it higher, but some find it redundant.
  5. 5Montblanc Explorer Extreme3 of 4 reviewers pick this versionDescribed as a bolder, darker, richer Explorer, a mix of Aventus Absolu and Sauvage Elixir. One reviewer found it cheap and flat.
  6. 6YSL Black Opium Over Red3 of 4 reviewers pick this versionThe original with a soft cherry twist, less sweet, creamy and woody. Reviewers are lukewarm to positive; some find it unoriginal and pricey.
  7. 7Jean Paul Gaultier Le Parfum6 of 9 reviewers pick this versionIris-led, spicy-warm and polished. Most reviewers rank it above the other two, with long wear and projection that is strong but not overpowering.
  8. 8Acqua di Gio Parfum2 of 3 reviewers pick this versionRosemary and patchouli-led, green and spicy, and the more refined, dressy option; reviewers disagree on whether it beats Profondo.
  9. 9YSL Y Eau de Parfum5 of 8 reviewers pick this versionApple-led, sweeter and woodier than the EDT, with long wear and strong projection; most reviewers rank it highly, one ranked it last.
  10. 10Lancôme La Vie Est Belle Intensément3 of 5 reviewers pick this versionA fruity raspberry, powdery vanilla take on the original, called smoother and less heavy; reviewers split on how special it is and how long it lasts.
  11. 11Terre d'Hermès Eau de Toilette4 of 7 reviewers pick this versionThe original: orange over earthy vetiver and wood, peppery and fresh, moderate projection; most reviewers call it versatile and a good starting point.
  12. 12Viktor&Rolf Spicebomb Extreme4 of 8 reviewers pick this versionOriginal's profile with added vanilla, smoother and denser; reviewers disagree on performance, from very long-lasting to short.