Fragrance versions for winter
Versions reviewers say suit winter, ordered by how many pick them. Ranked by reviewer counts across the fragrances we cover, not by a score of ours.
- 1Boss Bottled Elixir2 of 2 reviewers pick this versionA woody, spicy, smoky-incense version that reviewers call unique and niche-like. It is less mainstream, and one reviewer calls it the expensive one in the line.
- 2Paco Rabanne Invictus Victory Elixir5 of 6 reviewers pick this versionA sweet, vanilla-led, warm scent, louder than Victory, lasting about eight to ten hours. Some reviewers call it unoriginal, others rank it among the best Invictus.
- 3
Bleu de Chanel Eau de Parfum6 of 8 reviewers pick this versionSeen as the balanced middle: fresh like the EDT with more depth, versatile across seasons, and the usual pick if buying one. - 4Armani Stronger With You Absolutely6 of 8 reviewers pick this versionDescribed as smoother, boozier and more balanced than Intensely, with chestnut and vanilla; several reviewers rank it higher, but some find it redundant.
- 5
Montblanc Explorer Extreme3 of 4 reviewers pick this versionDescribed as a bolder, darker, richer Explorer, a mix of Aventus Absolu and Sauvage Elixir. One reviewer found it cheap and flat. - 6YSL Black Opium Over Red3 of 4 reviewers pick this versionThe original with a soft cherry twist, less sweet, creamy and woody. Reviewers are lukewarm to positive; some find it unoriginal and pricey.
- 7Jean Paul Gaultier Le Parfum6 of 9 reviewers pick this versionIris-led, spicy-warm and polished. Most reviewers rank it above the other two, with long wear and projection that is strong but not overpowering.
- 8
Acqua di Gio Parfum2 of 3 reviewers pick this versionRosemary and patchouli-led, green and spicy, and the more refined, dressy option; reviewers disagree on whether it beats Profondo. - 9
YSL Y Eau de Parfum5 of 8 reviewers pick this versionApple-led, sweeter and woodier than the EDT, with long wear and strong projection; most reviewers rank it highly, one ranked it last. - 10
Terre d'Hermès Eau de Toilette4 of 7 reviewers pick this versionThe original: orange over earthy vetiver and wood, peppery and fresh, moderate projection; most reviewers call it versatile and a good starting point. - 11
Viktor&Rolf Spicebomb Extreme4 of 8 reviewers pick this versionOriginal's profile with added vanilla, smoother and denser; reviewers disagree on performance, from very long-lasting to short. - 12
Valentino Uomo Born in Roma Intense3 of 6 reviewers pick this versionVanilla-led and sweet with lavender and woods; reviewers disagree whether it is light and breezy or dark, spicy and woody.