Safest fragrances to buy without smelling
Versions almost no reviewer criticises on scent. Ranked by reviewer counts across the fragrances we cover, not by a score of ours.
- 1
Dior Sauvage Eau de Parfumnone of 9 reviewers criticise how it smellsA deeper, sweeter, slightly spicier version of the EDT; reviewers often pick it as the balanced choice. - 2
Bleu de Chanel Parfumnone of 7 reviewers criticise how it smellsRichest, woodiest and most formal version, best for cold weather and evenings; several find the price hard to justify. - 3
YSL Y Eau de Parfum1 of 8 reviewers criticise how it smellsApple-led, sweeter and woodier than the EDT, with long wear and strong projection; most reviewers rank it highly, one ranked it last. - 4Armani Stronger With You Absolutelynone of 8 reviewers criticise how it smellsDescribed as smoother, boozier and more balanced than Intensely, with chestnut and vanilla; several reviewers rank it higher, but some find it redundant.
- 5Versace Eros Eau de Parfumnone of 7 reviewers criticise how it smellsMiddle ground between EDT and Parfum; most call it smoother and richer, but one finds it sweeter and more candy-like than the EDT.
- 6
Baccarat Rouge 540 Extrait1 of 8 reviewers criticise how it smellsRicher, denser, woodier version with almond and musk notes and longer staying power, though it costs more and some find it heavy. - 7
Club de Nuit Intense Man Eau de Parfum1 of 8 reviewers criticise how it smellsSmoother than the EDT with a similar smoky citrus character, often called the best value; one reviewer finds it the fruitiest. - 8Club de Nuit Intense Man Parfumnone of 6 reviewers criticise how it smellsDescribed as more refined, smoother and better balanced, with longer wear; reviewers differ on how well it projects.
- 9Club de Nuit Intense Man Limited Editionnone of 5 reviewers criticise how it smellsMost expensive; most reviewers call it smooth and refined, but one finds it harsh, loud and smoky like an older batch.
- 10
Acqua di Gio Eau de Toilette1 of 6 reviewers criticise how it smellsCitrus-heavy, clean aquatic original; reviewers call it a classic that is easy to wear, though performance is moderate to weak. - 11
Acqua di Gio Profondo1 of 8 reviewers criticise how it smellsMarine, mineral and aromatic, with rosemary and less citrus than the original; reviewers disagree on how it ranks, some calling it their favorite. - 12
Paco Rabanne 1 Million Eau de Toilette1 of 8 reviewers criticise how it smellsThe sweet bubblegum, leather and spice original. Reviewers call it still good and loud, though some find it youthful or dated, and newer bottles weaker.