Boss Bottled: EDP or Elixir?

Of the 0 reviewers who compared both, 0 pick the EDP and 0 pick the Elixir.

Boss Bottled Eau de Parfum

A richer, spicier take on the line with cardamom and pepper. Reviewers find it modern and smooth but familiar, and one calls it pricey at full retail.

1 of 3 reviewers who compared it pick this version.

springfall

Reviewers smell: apple, bergamot, black pepper, cardamom, chestnut, cinnamon, musk, sweet

Picked by Chaos Fragrances

Boss Bottled Elixir

A woody, spicy, smoky-incense version that reviewers call unique and niche-like. It is less mainstream, and one reviewer calls it the expensive one in the line.

2 of 2 reviewers who compared it pick this version.

fallwinterspringformal

Reviewers smell: cardamom, incense, smoky, spicy, woody, amber, cedarwood, earthy

Picked by CurlyFragrance, Rotten Rebel

How they compare

What reviewers sayEDPElixir
scentMostly praised3 praiseMostly praised2 praise
longevityMostly praised2 praiseOne comment1 praise
projectionMostly praised2 praiseMostly praised2 praise
occasionMixed2 praise, 1 criticiseMixed2 praise, 1 criticise
valueMixed1 praise, 1 criticiseOne comment1 praise
complimentsOne comment1 praiseMixed1 praise, 1 criticise

overall

EDP

Absolute FragranceReviewed in 2024Mixed

Shares the EDT's DNA but ends up smelling like a different perfume.

“makes them end of smelling like two absolutely different perfumes”
Watch at 1:58
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2020Praise

Well done cardamom twist on the Boss Bottled DNA, much better than he expected. (if you like the Boss Bottled line)

“it's honestly pretty good a lot better than i was expecting”
Watch at 8:19
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2020Mixed

He likes it, but it is not his favorite release of the year.

“is it my favorite release of the year probably not there's a few others that i like more”
Watch at 7:35

Elixir

CurlyFragranceReviewed in 2023Praise

He likes it straight away but is unsure how ordinary buyers will react.

“I like it. I can already say that I like it, but I don't know how normal people will react to this”
Watch at 2:25
CurlyFragranceReviewed in 2023Criticism

Not a safe blind buy because it is so different.

“It's very different. So you this is not a safe blind buy at all”
Watch at 2:57
CurlyFragranceReviewed in 2023Praise

Best suited to niche lovers and collectors tired of blue fragrances. (for niche lovers and collectors)

“This is really for the niche lovers actually for the people who are sick of the blue”
Watch at 6:01

scent

EDP

Absolute FragranceReviewed in 2024Praise

Opens sweet and spicy with a strong woody note. (in the opening)

“the EDP is sweet spicy with a strong Woody note”
Watch at 0:48
Absolute FragranceReviewed in 2024Mixed

Rich, dense and quite heavy compared with the EDT.

“the EDP is rich is dense and it's quite heavy”
Watch at 1:01
Absolute FragranceReviewed in 2024Praise

Mid stage is aromatic with mintiness and wood. (after about 30 minutes)

“quite aromatic it has that mintiness as well and wood”
Watch at 1:19

Elixir

CurlyFragranceReviewed in 2023Mixed

Less instantly likeable than usual Boss releases; not aimed at mainstream noses. (for mainstream noses)

“But this is not that likable not for the mainstream noses out there”
Watch at 2:17
CurlyFragranceReviewed in 2023Praise

Opens very incense-heavy and smoky. (in the opening)

“Incensey and smoky in the air”
Watch at 1:50
CurlyFragranceReviewed in 2023Praise

Smells like a creative, unique niche fragrance with high-quality materials.

“Because it smells pretty much like a niche fragrance if I'm being honest and what I mean with niche is that it is creative”
Watch at 2:33

longevity

EDP

Absolute FragranceReviewed in 2024Praise

Lasts longer than the EDT.

“the EDP was definitely stronger in terms of projection and Longevity”
Watch at 2:14
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2020Praise

Lasts a solid seven to eight hours. (on his skin)

“longevity on my skin has been a solid seven eight hours really good”
Watch at 5:48

Elixir

CurlyFragranceReviewed in 2023Mixed

Expects it to last long given the notes, but has not confirmed it. (first impression, not fully tested)

“I also think with the fragrance notes that it will stay long, but I don't know that for sure”
Watch at 7:24
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2025Praise

Lasted overnight; he could still smell it on his skin when he woke up. (on his skin)

“Lexz still oozing from my skin when I woke up”
Watch at 7:17

projection

EDP

Absolute FragranceReviewed in 2024Praise

Projects more strongly than the EDT.

“the EDP was definitely stronger in terms of projection and Longevity”
Watch at 2:14
RiveraedgyReviewed in 2022Praise

Has a more dominant, present, attention-grabbing character.

“more dominant more present more kind of bam you know i'm here”
Watch at 6:39
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2020Mixed

Projection is okay; it will not fill a room but gets you noticed.

“it's not going to fill a room it's not going to push out super far but it will get you noticed”
Watch at 6:07

Elixir

CurlyFragranceReviewed in 2023Praise

Projects well; he could smell it for the full two hours. (over the first two hours on his skin)

“It projects. I smell it the whole time the whole two hours. So I know that it projects”
Watch at 7:18
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2025Praise

Lasts quite a while with solid projection.

“they both last quite a while with solid projection”
Watch at 7:24

occasion

EDP

Absolute FragranceReviewed in 2024Praise

Reads as the more masculine of the two.

“the EDP is definitely more masculine”
Watch at 2:31
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2020Praise

Very versatile scent that works in a lot of situations.

“it's going to be a very versatile scent”
Watch at 4:58
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2020Praise

Best in the transitional seasons, fall and early to mid spring. (in fall and spring)

“so fall be a really great phenomenal fall fragrance and also spring”
Watch at 5:18

Elixir

CurlyFragranceReviewed in 2023Mixed

Needs some character to pull off; suits a leather jacket or suit-and-tie event.

“I don't know you really have to be a little bit of a character to pull this one off like bad boy”
Watch at 6:21
CurlyFragranceReviewed in 2023Praise

More of a fall and winter fragrance. (for fall and winter)

“It's more of a fall winter kind of a fragrance”
Watch at 7:13
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2025Praise

Wearable most of the year, best in fall, winter and spring.

“I do feel boss bottle elixir can be used pretty much throughout the entire year, but with the focus on fall, winter, and spring”
Watch at 6:23

value

EDP

RiveraedgyReviewed in 2022Criticism

Not bad, but expensive for what you get.

“this one's not bad but the price you pay for it it's actually kind of expensive”
Watch at 6:47
RiveraedgyReviewed in 2022Criticism

Not worth full retail; look for a deal.

“trying to find a good deal on it don't buy full retail it's not worth it in my opinion”
Watch at 7:03
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2020Praise

Already available at discounters, so you can save money on it.

“you can already get it on discounters save yourself some money”
Watch at 8:03

Elixir

CurlyFragranceReviewed in 2023Praise

Smells expensive; he would believe a 300 euro price tag.

“if you would say like hey this fragrance costs 300 euros, I would believe it”
Watch at 2:46

compliments

EDP

Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2020Praise

Mass pleasing; his girlfriend loved it instantly, so he expects quite a few compliments.

“you're probably going to get quite a few compliments from this one”
Watch at 7:26

Elixir

CurlyFragranceReviewed in 2023Mixed

Unsure whether women will like it; calls it unique rather than sexy.

“No, I wouldn't say that this is a sexy scent, but it's unique”
Watch at 6:58
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2025Praise

More mass appealing than Absolu because it is less smoky and intense. (compared with Absolu)

“Boss Bottle Elixir definitely without a single doubt has more mass appeal to it with its less smoky intense scent”
Watch at 5:48
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2025Criticism

Not among the most mass-appealing fragrances; not ideal if you only buy crowd-pleasers.

“None of these two are at the very top when it comes to mass appeal”
Watch at 5:55

See every Boss Bottled version