Boss Bottled: EDT or Elixir?
Of the 0 reviewers who compared both, 0 pick the EDT and 0 pick the Elixir.
Boss Bottled Eau de Toilette
The light, clean apple-cinnamon original. Reviewers call it versatile and liked by women, but some find it dated, with average to medium longevity.
2 of 5 reviewers who compared it pick this version.
Reviewers smell: apple, cinnamon, clean, fresh, spicy, sweet, apple pie, aromatic
Picked by Hamza Saab, Riveraedgy
Boss Bottled Elixir
A woody, spicy, smoky-incense version that reviewers call unique and niche-like. It is less mainstream, and one reviewer calls it the expensive one in the line.
2 of 2 reviewers who compared it pick this version.
Reviewers smell: cardamom, incense, smoky, spicy, woody, amber, cedarwood, earthy
Picked by CurlyFragrance, Rotten Rebel
How they compare
| What reviewers say | EDT | Elixir |
|---|---|---|
| scent | Mixed4 praise, 2 criticise | Mostly praised2 praise |
| longevity | Mostly criticised1 praise, 2 criticise | One comment1 praise |
| projection | One comment0 praise, 1 criticise | Mostly praised2 praise |
| occasion | Mostly praised3 praise | Mixed2 praise, 1 criticise |
| value | One comment1 praise | One comment1 praise |
| compliments | Mostly praised2 praise | Mixed1 praise, 1 criticise |
overall
EDT
Jeremy FragranceReviewed in 2020PraiseGood enough to be a signature scent people know you for.
“its signature scent worthy meaning it could be your signature people know you for this fragrance”Watch at 0:19
Jeremy FragranceReviewed in 2020MixedOriginal scent that women love, but outdated and only medium-lasting.
“it's an original medium long-lasting fragrance outdated yet original fragrance DNA that ladies love”Watch at 3:03
Jeremy FragranceReviewed in 2020MixedA great fragrance, but not among the very best he would pick.
“great fragrance but we are on the fragrance channel so I really only pick the absolute peak of fragrances”Watch at 3:33
Elixir
CurlyFragranceReviewed in 2023PraiseHe likes it straight away but is unsure how ordinary buyers will react.
“I like it. I can already say that I like it, but I don't know how normal people will react to this”Watch at 2:25
CurlyFragranceReviewed in 2023CriticismNot a safe blind buy because it is so different.
“It's very different. So you this is not a safe blind buy at all”Watch at 2:57
CurlyFragranceReviewed in 2023PraiseBest suited to niche lovers and collectors tired of blue fragrances. (for niche lovers and collectors)
“This is really for the niche lovers actually for the people who are sick of the blue”Watch at 6:01
scent
EDT
Absolute FragranceReviewed in 2024PraiseOpens sweet, spicy, citrusy and aromatic. (in the opening)
“the EDT opens you know sweet spicy citrusy and aromatic”Watch at 0:44
Absolute FragranceReviewed in 2024PraiseFresh, clean and light in character.
“is fresh it's clean and is light”Watch at 0:57
Absolute FragranceReviewed in 2024PraiseTurns green, grassy, minty and aromatic after half an hour. (after about 30 minutes)
“the EDT has developed into you know this green grassy minty”Watch at 1:07
Elixir
CurlyFragranceReviewed in 2023MixedLess instantly likeable than usual Boss releases; not aimed at mainstream noses. (for mainstream noses)
“But this is not that likable not for the mainstream noses out there”Watch at 2:17
CurlyFragranceReviewed in 2023PraiseOpens very incense-heavy and smoky. (in the opening)
“Incensey and smoky in the air”Watch at 1:50
CurlyFragranceReviewed in 2023PraiseSmells like a creative, unique niche fragrance with high-quality materials.
“Because it smells pretty much like a niche fragrance if I'm being honest and what I mean with niche is that it is creative”Watch at 2:33
longevity
EDT
Absolute FragranceReviewed in 2024CriticismWeaker performance than the EDP.
“while the EDT was weaker”Watch at 2:18
Jeremy FragranceReviewed in 2020CriticismDoes not reach the eight hours similar apple-cinnamon fragrances manage; performance is average.
“must last at least eight hours and I know a lot that last eight hours plus this doesn't so the performance is just average”Watch at 0:43
Hamza SaabReviewed in 2025PraiseLasts a solid six to seven hours. (on his skin)
“I still get a solid 6 to 7 hours of longevity with soft projection”Watch at 5:18
Elixir
CurlyFragranceReviewed in 2023MixedExpects it to last long given the notes, but has not confirmed it. (first impression, not fully tested)
“I also think with the fragrance notes that it will stay long, but I don't know that for sure”Watch at 7:24
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2025PraiseLasted overnight; he could still smell it on his skin when he woke up. (on his skin)
“Lexz still oozing from my skin when I woke up”Watch at 7:17
projection
EDT
Hamza SaabReviewed in 2025MixedProjection is soft; not a powerhouse, but performance is decent.
“So although it's not a beast mode fragrance, I still think it offers decent performance.”Watch at 5:24
Hamza SaabReviewed in 2025CriticismIt will not be among the strongest fragrances on the market.
“going to be the strongest fragrance on the market”Watch at 16:37
Elixir
CurlyFragranceReviewed in 2023PraiseProjects well; he could smell it for the full two hours. (over the first two hours on his skin)
“It projects. I smell it the whole time the whole two hours. So I know that it projects”Watch at 7:18
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2025PraiseLasts quite a while with solid projection.
“they both last quite a while with solid projection”Watch at 7:24
occasion
EDT
Absolute FragranceReviewed in 2024PraiseLeans slightly unisex; the reviewer feels a woman can wear it. (for women as well as men)
“the EDT kind of leans slightly towards the unisex”Watch at 2:35
Jeremy FragranceReviewed in 2020PraiseWorks in every setting: casual, formal, clubbing and dating.
“usable in every situation casual formal clubbing dating it works everywhere very versatile”Watch at 0:26
Hamza SaabReviewed in 2025PraiseVersatile enough for any situation, occasion or season thanks to its clean undertone.
“you can wear this one at any situation, any occasion, any season, any reason”Watch at 9:56
Elixir
CurlyFragranceReviewed in 2023MixedNeeds some character to pull off; suits a leather jacket or suit-and-tie event.
“I don't know you really have to be a little bit of a character to pull this one off like bad boy”Watch at 6:21
CurlyFragranceReviewed in 2023PraiseMore of a fall and winter fragrance. (for fall and winter)
“It's more of a fall winter kind of a fragrance”Watch at 7:13
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2025PraiseWearable most of the year, best in fall, winter and spring.
“I do feel boss bottle elixir can be used pretty much throughout the entire year, but with the focus on fall, winter, and spring”Watch at 6:23
value
EDT
RiveraedgyReviewed in 2022PraiseYou get 200 ml for the same hundred dollars that buys 100 ml of the EDP.
“200 mils for this bad boy the same price hundred bucks”Watch at 6:58
Elixir
CurlyFragranceReviewed in 2023PraiseSmells expensive; he would believe a 300 euro price tag.
“if you would say like hey this fragrance costs 300 euros, I would believe it”Watch at 2:46
compliments
EDT
Jeremy FragranceReviewed in 2020PraiseWomen like how it smells.
“there's something in it that the ladies absolutely love”Watch at 1:44
Jeremy FragranceReviewed in 2020PraiseIts appeal may come from women associating it with the successful men who wore it.
“ladies have been smelling it on cool CEO type of guys”Watch at 1:56
Hamza SaabReviewed in 2025PraiseMost women he interviewed scored it around eight out of ten. (blind street reactions from women)
“majority of the scores were in that eight range”Watch at 16:51
Elixir
CurlyFragranceReviewed in 2023MixedUnsure whether women will like it; calls it unique rather than sexy.
“No, I wouldn't say that this is a sexy scent, but it's unique”Watch at 6:58
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2025PraiseMore mass appealing than Absolu because it is less smoky and intense. (compared with Absolu)
“Boss Bottle Elixir definitely without a single doubt has more mass appeal to it with its less smoky intense scent”Watch at 5:48
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2025CriticismNot among the most mass-appealing fragrances; not ideal if you only buy crowd-pleasers.
“None of these two are at the very top when it comes to mass appeal”Watch at 5:55