YSL Y: EDP or Elixir?

Of the 4 reviewers who compared both, 2 pick the EDP and 0 pick the Elixir; 2 prefer another version or name none.

YSL Y Eau de Parfum

YSL Y Eau de Parfum

Apple-led, sweeter and woodier than the EDT, with long wear and strong projection; most reviewers rank it highly, one ranked it last.

5 of 8 reviewers who compared it pick this version. Bottle $97.

springfallwinternighteverydaydate nightnight outformalgym

Reviewers smell: apple, sweet, aromatic, woody, amberwood, bergamot, fresh, ginger

Picked by Chaos Fragrances, Chaos Fragrances, Rotten Rebel, Mr Seasons, Rotten Rebel

YSL Y Elixir

Soapy, clean, aromatic and unlike the rest of the line; priciest version, with reviewers split on whether it is worth it.

0 of 4 reviewers who compared it pick this version.

springsummerfallwinterdaynightoffice

Reviewers smell: lavender, oud, soapy, clean, sweet, amber, amberwood, aromatic

How they compare

What reviewers sayEDPElixir
scentMostly praised6 praiseMostly praised3 praise, 1 criticise
longevityMostly praised3 praise, 1 criticiseMixed2 praise, 1 criticise
projectionMostly praised3 praiseMixed1 praise, 1 criticise
occasionMixed4 praise, 2 criticiseMostly praised2 praise
valueMostly praised3 praiseMostly criticised0 praise, 3 criticise
complimentsMostly praised3 praiseMostly praised2 praise

overall

EDP

Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2023Praise

Still great and not made obsolete by newer flankers.

“probably the EDP and it's great it's not obsolete”
Watch at 16:22
Gents ScentsReviewed in 2024Praise

The most popular and best-selling version in the line.

“one is the most popular in the Y lineup”
Watch at 4:09
Gents ScentsReviewed in 2024Praise

Choose it if you want the sweeter, more playful, louder take. (if you want it sweeter and louder)

“little bit sweeter more playful a little bit more loud go for the OD param”
Watch at 13:52

Elixir

Gents ScentsReviewed in 2024Mixed

At its price a cheaper version may be the better buy, unless price doesn't matter.

“may be better off uh going with one of these but if the price doesn't matter this is a comp puller”
Watch at 21:22
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2025Mixed

He likes it but thinks other versions are better options for the money.

“So, I do like it. I just think that maybe there”
Watch at 15:21
SoCal ScentsReviewed in 2024Mixed

She liked it but rated it 6.5 to 7 because it is so different. (on first spray)

“I give it like a 7 or a 6.5 I like it, it's just very different.”
Watch at 3:15

scent

EDP

Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2023Praise

Apple-led sweetness with plenty of amberwood, aromatics and some citrus.

“uses a lot of Apple here going back to”
Watch at 15:31
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2025Praise

Adds sweet apple to the EDT DNA; sweeter, stronger, heavier and richer.

“It's sweeter. It's stronger. It's it's more heavy, more rich”
Watch at 5:05
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2022Praise

Opening is fresh and citrusy with some depth, slightly herbal and aromatic. (opening)

“fresh citrusy opening with some depth to it slightly herbal slightly aromatic but really nice and fresh”
Watch at 1:06

Elixir

Gents ScentsReviewed in 2024Praise

Soapy, clean and classy, more aromatic than the others.

“so a bit soapy very clean very classy”
Watch at 18:55
Gents ScentsReviewed in 2024Praise

Smells higher quality than the cheaper versions when compared side by side.

“it does smell higher quality when you put it side by side with some of the cheaper versions in the line”
Watch at 21:30
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2025Praise

He loves the smell; keeps the original DNA with a punchier, sweeter depth.

“I personally love how it smells”
Watch at 13:50

longevity

EDP

Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2023Praise

Strongest of the line, lasting 11 to 12 hours.

“11 12h hour performer very strong”
Watch at 15:42
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2025Praise

Lasts 12 hours or more and is often still going after that.

“12 plus hour longevity runs with the soda parfoam and a lot of times it'll still be kicking”
Watch at 5:46
Mr SeasonsReviewed in 2025Criticism

Like other fresh fragrances, it does not last particularly long.

“Like all freshies though, it doesn't last particularly long.”
Watch at 3:39

Elixir

Gents ScentsReviewed in 2024Praise

Longevity is good; it lasts a long time.

“the longevity is good lasts a long time”
Watch at 19:01
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2025Praise

Good performer, lasting about ten to eleven hours.

“it's a good performer. It's a 10 11”
Watch at 14:52
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2026Criticism

Goes soft too quickly. (on his skin)

“I also feel it goes a bit too soft too fast at least on my skin”
Watch at 8:56

projection

EDP

Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2023Praise

Great projection and scent trail.

“very strong great projection”
Watch at 15:42
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2023Mixed

About as strong and overpowering as the line gets.

“and obnoxious and overpowering as it gets”
Watch at 15:42
Gents ScentsReviewed in 2024Praise

Projects more and lasts longer than the EDT.

“it also packs more of a punch than yod to twet so it projects more it last longer”
Watch at 5:11

Elixir

Gents ScentsReviewed in 2024Criticism

Does not project as heavily as some other versions in the line.

“just doesn't project quite as heavily as some of these other fragrances”
Watch at 19:03
SoCal ScentsReviewed in 2024Praise

Not overpowering; more subtle while still fresh. (bonus reviewer)

“It's not too overwhelming either. Overpowering.”
Watch at 11:40

occasion

EDP

Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2023Criticism

May be too heavy and sweet for some in summer heat or humidity. (during the summertime)

“heavy and sweet for some during the summertime”
Watch at 15:50
Gents ScentsReviewed in 2024Criticism

Can be cloying and headache-inducing when sprayed heavily in hot weather. (in summer heat when applied heavily)

“very sweet it can be cloying and so that can cause some people to get headaches”
Watch at 5:24
Gents ScentsReviewed in 2024Praise

Works well for nights out, clubbing and dates.

“it's a great night out fragrance a great clubbing fragrance a great date fragrance”
Watch at 5:43

Elixir

Gents ScentsReviewed in 2024Praise

Wearable year round, day or night.

“you can wear this yearr round Daytime Nighttime does not matter”
Watch at 19:19
SoCal ScentsReviewed in 2024Praise

The host calls it safe for the office and school. (for office or school)

“This is going to be office safe, school safe.”
Watch at 12:10

value

EDP

Gents ScentsReviewed in 2024Praise

Discounters knock more dollars off the EDP than the EDT. (at discounters)

“actually more of a discount available for yod to parfum”
Watch at 4:43
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2025Praise

Around $100 at discounters, which he considers reasonable.

“It's reasonable, especially in this day and age. 100 bucks doesn't seem too bad”
Watch at 6:02
Mr SeasonsReviewed in 2025Praise

Offers more for the money than the EDT.

“You get more bang for your buck, baby.”
Watch at 7:41

Elixir

Gents ScentsReviewed in 2024Criticism

The most expensive in the line, and only sold in the smaller bottle.

“this is the most expensive why especially when you consider it only comes in the smaller size bottle”
Watch at 17:07
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2025Criticism

Most expensive and only sold in 60 ml; he dislikes the price.

“I just don't really like the price point really”
Watch at 13:57
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2026Criticism

You are mostly paying for lavender; more exciting lavender scents cost less.

“you can get more exciting lavender focused scents for less than that what you pay for”
Watch at 8:51

compliments

EDP

Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2025Praise

Gets a lot of compliments, which drives its popularity.

“compliment puller, everybody is wanting to get this stuff”
Watch at 5:57
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2022Praise

Gets a lot of compliments wearing it, which he treats as a bonus.

“all the compliments i get with it is just an amazing bonus”
Watch at 8:26
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2026Praise

Always in his versatile rotation and gets a lot of compliments.

“It's always been in my rotation of versatile fragrances and it's a compliment master”
Watch at 15:56

Elixir

Gents ScentsReviewed in 2024Praise

Gets compliments; people like how it smells.

“it's also a compliment puller people love the way it smells”
Watch at 19:24
SoCal ScentsReviewed in 2024Praise

The host expects people to think you smell good wearing it.

“People are going to think you smell good wearing it.”
Watch at 12:13

See every YSL Y version