YSL Y: EDT or Elixir?
Of the 4 reviewers who compared both, 0 pick the EDT and 0 pick the Elixir; 4 prefer another version or name none.

YSL Y Eau de Toilette
Clean, fresh, light, laundry-like scent lasting about 5.5 to 7 hours; reviewers disagree on whether it beats the EDP.
1 of 7 reviewers who compared it pick this version.
Reviewers smell: fresh, aldehydes, lavender, airy, bergamot, sage, ginger, sweet
Picked by BowTie FragranceGuy
YSL Y Elixir
Soapy, clean, aromatic and unlike the rest of the line; priciest version, with reviewers split on whether it is worth it.
0 of 4 reviewers who compared it pick this version.
Reviewers smell: lavender, oud, soapy, clean, sweet, amber, amberwood, aromatic
How they compare
| What reviewers say | EDT | Elixir |
|---|---|---|
| scent | Mostly praised5 praise, 1 criticise | Mostly praised3 praise, 1 criticise |
| longevity | Mostly criticised0 praise, 2 criticise | Mixed2 praise, 1 criticise |
| projection | No comment | Mixed1 praise, 1 criticise |
| occasion | Mostly praised3 praise, 1 criticise | Mostly praised2 praise |
| value | Mostly criticised0 praise, 2 criticise | Mostly criticised0 praise, 3 criticise |
| compliments | Mostly praised2 praise | Mostly praised2 praise |
overall
EDT
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2023MixedSmells great but there are better options in the line, in his view.
“so many better options um at least subjectively uh”Watch at 6:01
Gents ScentsReviewed in 2024PraiseThe current 2022 reformulation is better than the discontinued 2017 original.
“this new version the 2022 version is better”Watch at 1:22
Gents ScentsReviewed in 2024PraiseOne of the best in the lineup if you want versatility. (if you want extreme versatility)
“you're looking for just extreme versatility this is going to be one of the best in the entire lineup”Watch at 3:50
Elixir
Gents ScentsReviewed in 2024MixedAt its price a cheaper version may be the better buy, unless price doesn't matter.
“may be better off uh going with one of these but if the price doesn't matter this is a comp puller”Watch at 21:22
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2025MixedHe likes it but thinks other versions are better options for the money.
“So, I do like it. I just think that maybe there”Watch at 15:21
SoCal ScentsReviewed in 2024MixedShe liked it but rated it 6.5 to 7 because it is so different. (on first spray)
“I give it like a 7 or a 6.5 I like it, it's just very different.”Watch at 3:15
scent
EDT
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2023PraiseSmells very clean, like fresh linen and freshly washed clothes.
“smells like clean linen smells like clean fresh”Watch at 5:39
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2023PraiseCrisp, clean and very inoffensive.
“and super inoffensive”Watch at 5:49
Gents ScentsReviewed in 2024PraiseExtremely fresh and easy to wear, a bit like clean laundry.
“it's extremely fresh very easy to wear might remind you a little bit of like clean laundry”Watch at 2:52
Elixir
Gents ScentsReviewed in 2024PraiseSoapy, clean and classy, more aromatic than the others.
“so a bit soapy very clean very classy”Watch at 18:55
Gents ScentsReviewed in 2024PraiseSmells higher quality than the cheaper versions when compared side by side.
“it does smell higher quality when you put it side by side with some of the cheaper versions in the line”Watch at 21:30
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2025PraiseHe loves the smell; keeps the original DNA with a punchier, sweeter depth.
“I personally love how it smells”Watch at 13:50
longevity
EDT
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2023CriticismSecond-weakest performer in the line; not a good choice if you want performance.
“this one doesn't really have the best performance”Watch at 4:49
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2023MixedLasts roughly 6 to 7 hours, fine alone but weak next to the others.
“it's in that 6 6 and 1/2 maybe”Watch at 6:32
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2025CriticismLasts six to seven hours, weaker than basically all the others.
“six, seven hour performer. That's not hateful.”Watch at 4:08
Elixir
Gents ScentsReviewed in 2024PraiseLongevity is good; it lasts a long time.
“the longevity is good lasts a long time”Watch at 19:01
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2025PraiseGood performer, lasting about ten to eleven hours.
“it's a good performer. It's a 10 11”Watch at 14:52
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2026CriticismGoes soft too quickly. (on his skin)
“I also feel it goes a bit too soft too fast at least on my skin”Watch at 8:56
occasion
EDT
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2023PraiseWorks well for many situations. (for collectors who already own the others)
“theoda tolet is a great wear”Watch at 6:26
Gents ScentsReviewed in 2024CriticismMay feel too light in winter for people who want something heavier. (for people who prefer warm, spicy, heavier scents in winter)
“winter time it may not pack enough punch for a lot of people”Watch at 3:09
Gents ScentsReviewed in 2024PraiseOffice safe and good for casual daytime wear.
“it's office safe it's a great casual fragrance great for a day out in general”Watch at 3:27
Elixir
Gents ScentsReviewed in 2024PraiseWearable year round, day or night.
“you can wear this yearr round Daytime Nighttime does not matter”Watch at 19:19
SoCal ScentsReviewed in 2024PraiseThe host calls it safe for the office and school. (for office or school)
“This is going to be office safe, school safe.”Watch at 12:10
value
EDT
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2023CriticismCosts about the same as versions that last roughly twice as long.
“the same price as some of the others that perform”Watch at 6:15
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2025CriticismStill costs $80 or more at discounters, so not cheap for what it offers.
“you're not getting the OD twelet for cheap”Watch at 3:10
Elixir
Gents ScentsReviewed in 2024CriticismThe most expensive in the line, and only sold in the smaller bottle.
“this is the most expensive why especially when you consider it only comes in the smaller size bottle”Watch at 17:07
Chaos FragrancesReviewed in 2025CriticismMost expensive and only sold in 60 ml; he dislikes the price.
“I just don't really like the price point really”Watch at 13:57
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2026CriticismYou are mostly paying for lavender; more exciting lavender scents cost less.
“you can get more exciting lavender focused scents for less than that what you pay for”Watch at 8:51
compliments
EDT
BowTie FragranceGuyReviewed in 2021PraiseCalls the original a compliment magnet and has used up much of his bottle.
“as i told you guys before there's a compliment magnet i love the original dna”Watch at 3:11
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2026PraiseThe original EDT is one of his most complimented in the line. (original 2017 version)
“the OG is one of my most complimented in the line”Watch at 0:49
Rotten RebelReviewed in 2026PraiseThe 2022 EDT is his most complimented of the fresh Y scents. (2022 version)
“Y Eau de Toilette 2022 is my most complimented, most fresh Y so Y”Watch at 6:57
Elixir
Gents ScentsReviewed in 2024PraiseGets compliments; people like how it smells.
“it's also a compliment puller people love the way it smells”Watch at 19:24
SoCal ScentsReviewed in 2024PraiseThe host expects people to think you smell good wearing it.
“People are going to think you smell good wearing it.”Watch at 12:13